The fredonia Mary's is a sight for Sore Eyes, but that doesn't matter because the food there is good.It is probably my favorite pizza in the Fredonia Dunkirk area.Typically it's just one man in the kitchen making everyone's food. He is alway polite whenever I pick up my food.There really isn't much else to say. Good pizza is good pizza.
Food: 5
Matthew Vercant
Great subs, generously heaped, delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wayne Ceallaigh
Every year we return to Fredonia, we get a pie, and a big cup of blue cheese. This last time it was so good I actually cried with a nostalgic joy, especially when I had been subjected to so much inferior pizza in Florida where I live now. The guy who owns and runs it is a national treasure, he does such a good job and was truly happy that we got a pizza from him. The only bit of sadness was the state of wear that the inside of his establishment he is in. It made me worry that the next time O visit, yet another artifact of Fredonia will fade into the mists of memory. So good! This pizza seems like it will always be the best!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ruthann Whitfield
The food was terrible. The pizza was nasty and cold. I would not eat there again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Anita Morales
Service was good, food was ok. They don’t accept anything but cash for payment, so that’s a little inconvenient.
Anita
Service was good, food was ok. They don’t accept anything but cash for payment, so that’s a little inconvenient.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 4
Jody Scott
Best pizza in town!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Toni Rae Benedict
Best pizza ever. Everytime I'm in town I order and usually take one back home with me to Central N.Y. If you've had a bad experience, remember everyone makes mistakes or could have a bad day. Be glad you can at least get a good pizza there, it all sucks out here. Thank You Mary's in Fredonia, I always look forward to coming there when I'm in town.
nick kish
Grabbed a slice to go and I gotta say, It tasted like off-brand cleaning products… I’ve had some bad pizza in the past but damn…. Pizza is supposed to be easy lol
Cassandra Holland
Ordered a steak sub with cheese, cooked peppers, onions and mushrooms. Its edible but not great at all. Sub is made with what looks and tastes like a cheap burger patty. Sub is super sloppy and after being told it would take 25 minutes, we showed up to pick up 30 minutes later and the subs weren't even started yet.
The fredonia Mary's is a sight for Sore Eyes, but that doesn't matter because the food there is good.It is probably my favorite pizza in the Fredonia Dunkirk area.Typically it's just one man in the kitchen making everyone's food. He is alway polite whenever I pick up my food.There really isn't much else to say. Good pizza is good pizza.
Food: 5
Great subs, generously heaped, delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Every year we return to Fredonia, we get a pie, and a big cup of blue cheese. This last time it was so good I actually cried with a nostalgic joy, especially when I had been subjected to so much inferior pizza in Florida where I live now. The guy who owns and runs it is a national treasure, he does such a good job and was truly happy that we got a pizza from him. The only bit of sadness was the state of wear that the inside of his establishment he is in. It made me worry that the next time O visit, yet another artifact of Fredonia will fade into the mists of memory. So good! This pizza seems like it will always be the best!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food was terrible. The pizza was nasty and cold. I would not eat there again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Service was good, food was ok. They don’t accept anything but cash for payment, so that’s a little inconvenient.
Service was good, food was ok. They don’t accept anything but cash for payment, so that’s a little inconvenient.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 4
Best pizza in town!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza ever. Everytime I'm in town I order and usually take one back home with me to Central N.Y. If you've had a bad experience, remember everyone makes mistakes or could have a bad day. Be glad you can at least get a good pizza there, it all sucks out here. Thank You Mary's in Fredonia, I always look forward to coming there when I'm in town.
Grabbed a slice to go and I gotta say, It tasted like off-brand cleaning products… I’ve had some bad pizza in the past but damn…. Pizza is supposed to be easy lol
Ordered a steak sub with cheese, cooked peppers, onions and mushrooms. Its edible but not great at all. Sub is made with what looks and tastes like a cheap burger patty. Sub is super sloppy and after being told it would take 25 minutes, we showed up to pick up 30 minutes later and the subs weren't even started yet.
Restaurantji Recommends
Wet, undercooked pizza, mmmm.Not.
Best pizza and wings!
Would not take any calls at 8 pm when open till 11pm
Best pizza in dunkirk ny
Don’t have the hours right and no one answers the phone.