Had an enjoyable evening dining here. Was served promptly, meals were delicious. could have waited for a better table by the window, but the wife was hungry
Mary Ann
The Tuesday night dinner special is a good deal, many options to choose from. Everyone enjoyed their meals, my prime rib was overdone but still tender.
Kira Sheldon
This restaurant was absolutely disgusting 🤮, the server was very rude and the food was distasteful I’m so disappointed
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 1
Frank
Very good location with valet parking. The service was excellent as was the food. Would highly recommend this restaurant. 
thomas
My food was very good The dish advertised on the special menu that my husband wanted was unavailable a 5:45PM The trout he got was very bland
Diane G
The clam and jumbo shrimp appetizer was tasty. We had the steamed lobster and halibut for dinner; both excellent. Service was top-notch as well. Christian is such a gem!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Daniel
Best rare bone in prime rib on Long Island. Steak night every Wednesday year round. If you can go to Peter Lugers in Brooklyn, you can make the trip to Freeport.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Andrew Simon
Ate dinner on 8/31/25. All 4 of us had Lobster special. Everything was wonderful, lobster best I ever had. Looking forward to another great meal at Nautilus Cafe.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Shelley
Everything was wonderful. They honor reservation time, excellent Svc , enjoyed our dinner to the fullest.
Annabella Baluyut
This place is a family favorite! We had the lobster, skirt steak & shrimp and the prime rib (medium rare). Everything was excellent!
The service was great. I was disappointed with the sole and the cauliflower. The sole was heavily breaded and the cauliflower too dry. I was not thrilled with a la carte. Some dishes should not be a la carte. How can you have chicken parm without a side of pasta.
Meg Redling
Great entree
Kostas Brellas
Food was delicious and service amazing . Recommended for sure
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lon
Nautilus Cafe is a rare gem of a restaurant that we frequent a few times per year. The restaurant and lounge area are small, so make a reservation. The food, drinks and service are outstanding. There is ample parking behind and near the restaurant. Lobster bisque, seafood, everything is fresh and well prepared. They also serve prime rib which looked incredible. We do love this restaurant and will be back.
arna
A tried and true neighborhood gem. Food was delicious and the service was on point. Never a disappointment.
Had an enjoyable evening dining here. Was served promptly, meals were delicious. could have waited for a better table by the window, but the wife was hungry
The Tuesday night dinner special is a good deal, many options to choose from. Everyone enjoyed their meals, my prime rib was overdone but still tender.
This restaurant was absolutely disgusting 🤮, the server was very rude and the food was distasteful I’m so disappointed
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 1
Very good location with valet parking. The service was excellent as was the food. Would highly recommend this restaurant. 
My food was very good The dish advertised on the special menu that my husband wanted was unavailable a 5:45PM The trout he got was very bland
The clam and jumbo shrimp appetizer was tasty. We had the steamed lobster and halibut for dinner; both excellent. Service was top-notch as well. Christian is such a gem!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best rare bone in prime rib on Long Island. Steak night every Wednesday year round. If you can go to Peter Lugers in Brooklyn, you can make the trip to Freeport.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ate dinner on 8/31/25. All 4 of us had Lobster special. Everything was wonderful, lobster best I ever had. Looking forward to another great meal at Nautilus Cafe.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Everything was wonderful. They honor reservation time, excellent Svc , enjoyed our dinner to the fullest.
This place is a family favorite! We had the lobster, skirt steak & shrimp and the prime rib (medium rare). Everything was excellent!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
The service was great. I was disappointed with the sole and the cauliflower. The sole was heavily breaded and the cauliflower too dry. I was not thrilled with a la carte. Some dishes should not be a la carte. How can you have chicken parm without a side of pasta.
Great entree
Food was delicious and service amazing . Recommended for sure
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nautilus Cafe is a rare gem of a restaurant that we frequent a few times per year. The restaurant and lounge area are small, so make a reservation. The food, drinks and service are outstanding. There is ample parking behind and near the restaurant. Lobster bisque, seafood, everything is fresh and well prepared. They also serve prime rib which looked incredible. We do love this restaurant and will be back.
A tried and true neighborhood gem. Food was delicious and the service was on point. Never a disappointment.
Loading...