Delicious 3 course meal on a Tuesday night. Pork shank was so tender and lobster was perfect!
Teresa
Food was absolutely delicious you have to wait a bit but so worth it staff was attentive and friendly would definitely recommend and go back.
Frederick
Great seafood I thought the servers tried very hard. The kitchen was busy so delays were to be expected but every server was attentive ps I had the roast beef -delicious! Good value and good food.
Alan
Although we generally love Nautilus Cafe, our last visit was not quite what we have come to expect. The place was filled to capacity. We waited 10 minutes for menus and another 20 minutes for a server. Then we waited an hour for our entree's. Although the manager actively apologized, the kitchen clearly couldn't keep up with the demand of a full house. The food, however, was up to its high standards.
Diane
There were 4 of us for the Prix Fixe dinner. We all thoroughly enjoyed ourselves. We eat at the bar to get a chance to chat with other locals as well as to meet new people. The parmesan crusted scallop appetizer was delicious as was the salad with strawberries and parmesan cheese. We also enjoyed an extra appetizer of seared tuna. As a tuna fisherman, I only order tuna in a few places and this is definitely one if them. We each had a different main course: prime rib, lobster, halibut with lobster meat and a new addition to the menu, a chilled half lobster, shrimp and lump crabmeat cocktail. we each thoroughly enjoyed our meals and the portions were plentiful. Desserts of tartufo and carrot cake complimented the meals. We have eaten her regularly for over 30 years and will continue to dine here. You cant go wrong at Nautilus for either a relaxing dinner out or a special occasion.
Rick
Been dining here for many years. It never disappoints. Food is delicious and the service is always beyond compare. It is the only place we will eat seafood on Long Island. Always fresh and prepared to perfection.
Mina
A cozy atmosphere and fantastic food. The staff is accommodating. This is my go to restaurant.
Catherine
Lovely dinner with friends. The prime rib was perfectly prepared. The cod was excellent. The restaurant is somewhat dated but the food is spot on. The service was excellent. Thanks Nautilus.
Darren
Went on prix fixe nite, Tues, prime rib with app and desert $39.99. Couldn't ask for a better deal. Food was excellent and our waiter Josh was super attentive Will def return
Ricardo
Very unique place... I highly recommend the Prime rib, was out of this world! Roneynour waiter was attentive and informative I'll be back for more steak!
Just splendid - every time! A terrific dining experience. I couldn't be more laudatory about my visit on March 1st. Like all my other visits - superior in every way. Msgr. Batule
MINDY
The prime rib is excellent! The full cut can be shared. Tender, juicy and delicious. Great service!
Nelson
My wife & I frequent Nautilus Café on an irregular basis and normally we're not disappointed; however, yesterday's dining experience was subpar. We found the food to just be fair. This won't detract us from going back, but we weren't overly satisfied.
BILLY BORJAS
Great food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Arpita Barua
good food and amamazing atmosphere.. Food is great for the ?.... Amazing hospitality ☺️
Delicious 3 course meal on a Tuesday night. Pork shank was so tender and lobster was perfect!
Food was absolutely delicious you have to wait a bit but so worth it staff was attentive and friendly would definitely recommend and go back.
Great seafood I thought the servers tried very hard. The kitchen was busy so delays were to be expected but every server was attentive ps I had the roast beef -delicious! Good value and good food.
Although we generally love Nautilus Cafe, our last visit was not quite what we have come to expect. The place was filled to capacity. We waited 10 minutes for menus and another 20 minutes for a server. Then we waited an hour for our entree's. Although the manager actively apologized, the kitchen clearly couldn't keep up with the demand of a full house. The food, however, was up to its high standards.
There were 4 of us for the Prix Fixe dinner. We all thoroughly enjoyed ourselves. We eat at the bar to get a chance to chat with other locals as well as to meet new people. The parmesan crusted scallop appetizer was delicious as was the salad with strawberries and parmesan cheese. We also enjoyed an extra appetizer of seared tuna. As a tuna fisherman, I only order tuna in a few places and this is definitely one if them. We each had a different main course: prime rib, lobster, halibut with lobster meat and a new addition to the menu, a chilled half lobster, shrimp and lump crabmeat cocktail. we each thoroughly enjoyed our meals and the portions were plentiful. Desserts of tartufo and carrot cake complimented the meals. We have eaten her regularly for over 30 years and will continue to dine here. You cant go wrong at Nautilus for either a relaxing dinner out or a special occasion.
Been dining here for many years. It never disappoints. Food is delicious and the service is always beyond compare. It is the only place we will eat seafood on Long Island. Always fresh and prepared to perfection.
A cozy atmosphere and fantastic food. The staff is accommodating. This is my go to restaurant.
Lovely dinner with friends. The prime rib was perfectly prepared. The cod was excellent. The restaurant is somewhat dated but the food is spot on. The service was excellent. Thanks Nautilus.
Went on prix fixe nite, Tues, prime rib with app and desert $39.99. Couldn't ask for a better deal. Food was excellent and our waiter Josh was super attentive Will def return
Very unique place... I highly recommend the Prime rib, was out of this world! Roneynour waiter was attentive and informative I'll be back for more steak!
Restaurantji Recommends
Just splendid - every time! A terrific dining experience. I couldn't be more laudatory about my visit on March 1st. Like all my other visits - superior in every way. Msgr. Batule
The prime rib is excellent! The full cut can be shared. Tender, juicy and delicious. Great service!
My wife & I frequent Nautilus Café on an irregular basis and normally we're not disappointed; however, yesterday's dining experience was subpar. We found the food to just be fair. This won't detract us from going back, but we weren't overly satisfied.
Great food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
good food and amamazing atmosphere.. Food is great for the ?....
Amazing hospitality ☺️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...