We have been coming here for years. Hands down some of the best food anywhere on Long Island.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nicole
As always, every single thing about this restaurant is outstanding. From the atmosphere to the fabulous staff to the incredible food & drinks, my boyfriend & I are NEVER disappointed. We were looking for a good seafood place 2.5 years ago & decided to wing it & try someplace on the mile. I just pulled in there & said "let's give this place a try" & it has become our go-to spot for seafood ever since. They have NEVER disappointed. Absolutely go & give this restaurant a try. I guarantee you will become a regular.
Dori Crescas
My boyfriend and I come to this restaurant frequently for their prix fixe dinner and we come from Queens which typically takes an hour to an hour and a half to get here. We usually have a great time until today. We came about 4:30 & were the only people in the restaurant besides few people at the bar. The second we got the prix fixe menu , We saw something different. They now add $12 for the Prime Rib which usually was free with the Prix Fixe. Next my boyfriend asked for the 2 lb Lobster. The waiter said it was sold out. We pleaded with him to find a 2LB Lobster but he wouldn’t budge. We asked to speak to the manager and he claimed he was the manager. My boyfriend’s family has been going to this restaurant for many, many years. He was shocked at how unwilling to help this man was especially when the restaurant was empty. We deserved better. We decided to leave but he could’ve offered something for next time. This was all handled very unprofessionally. It’s a shame that we have to write this review for a restaurant we’ve always loved and enjoyed. Hopefully they’ll order more lobsters so this doesn’t happen again to us or to anybody else.
Grace Domenchello
They have a pay one price option for appetizer and lunch that was great.The baked clams wee delicious 😋,crab cakes also great 👍
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Noah
I made my reservation a few days before our brunch. When we arrived we were giving a nice table by the window. Note that this restaurant is not "on the water", however the view was nice. The waiter was very attentive and the food was very good. I would recommend and return myself.
Arthur
Our dinner at The Nautilus was superb! The service was attentive buy the entire staff and the meal itself, Prime Rib and Shrimp Oreganta was scrumptious! The Nautilus continues to be one of our favorite restaurants!
Tracey
Always delicious! Great service, amazing quality steaks and seafood (Steakhouse quality) best Halibut ever. Will not disappoint. And you can stroll The Mile afterwards!
Dan
Had an enjoyable evening dining here. Was served promptly, meals were delicious. could have waited for a better table by the window, but the wife was hungry
Mary Ann
The Tuesday night dinner special is a good deal, many options to choose from. Everyone enjoyed their meals, my prime rib was overdone but still tender.
This restaurant was absolutely disgusting 🤮, the server was very rude and the food was distasteful I’m so disappointed
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 1
Frank
Very good location with valet parking. The service was excellent as was the food. Would highly recommend this restaurant. 
thomas
My food was very good The dish advertised on the special menu that my husband wanted was unavailable a 5:45PM The trout he got was very bland
Diane G
The clam and jumbo shrimp appetizer was tasty. We had the steamed lobster and halibut for dinner; both excellent. Service was top-notch as well. Christian is such a gem!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Daniel
Best rare bone in prime rib on Long Island. Steak night every Wednesday year round. If you can go to Peter Lugers in Brooklyn, you can make the trip to Freeport.
Nice people there
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We have been coming here for years. Hands down some of the best food anywhere on Long Island.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
As always, every single thing about this restaurant is outstanding. From the atmosphere to the fabulous staff to the incredible food & drinks, my boyfriend & I are NEVER disappointed. We were looking for a good seafood place 2.5 years ago & decided to wing it & try someplace on the mile. I just pulled in there & said "let's give this place a try" & it has become our go-to spot for seafood ever since. They have NEVER disappointed. Absolutely go & give this restaurant a try. I guarantee you will become a regular.
My boyfriend and I come to this restaurant frequently for their prix fixe dinner and we come from Queens which typically takes an hour to an hour and a half to get here. We usually have a great time until today. We came about 4:30 & were the only people in the restaurant besides few people at the bar. The second we got the prix fixe menu , We saw something different. They now add $12 for the Prime Rib which usually was free with the Prix Fixe. Next my boyfriend asked for the 2 lb Lobster. The waiter said it was sold out. We pleaded with him to find a 2LB Lobster but he wouldn’t budge. We asked to speak to the manager and he claimed he was the manager. My boyfriend’s family has been going to this restaurant for many, many years. He was shocked at how unwilling to help this man was especially when the restaurant was empty. We deserved better. We decided to leave but he could’ve offered something for next time. This was all handled very unprofessionally. It’s a shame that we have to write this review for a restaurant we’ve always loved and enjoyed. Hopefully they’ll order more lobsters so this doesn’t happen again to us or to anybody else.
They have a pay one price option for appetizer and lunch that was great.The baked clams wee delicious 😋,crab cakes also great 👍
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I made my reservation a few days before our brunch. When we arrived we were giving a nice table by the window. Note that this restaurant is not "on the water", however the view was nice. The waiter was very attentive and the food was very good. I would recommend and return myself.
Our dinner at The Nautilus was superb! The service was attentive buy the entire staff and the meal itself, Prime Rib and Shrimp Oreganta was scrumptious! The Nautilus continues to be one of our favorite restaurants!
Always delicious! Great service, amazing quality steaks and seafood (Steakhouse quality) best Halibut ever. Will not disappoint. And you can stroll The Mile afterwards!
Had an enjoyable evening dining here. Was served promptly, meals were delicious. could have waited for a better table by the window, but the wife was hungry
The Tuesday night dinner special is a good deal, many options to choose from. Everyone enjoyed their meals, my prime rib was overdone but still tender.
Restaurantji Recommends
This restaurant was absolutely disgusting 🤮, the server was very rude and the food was distasteful I’m so disappointed
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 1
Very good location with valet parking. The service was excellent as was the food. Would highly recommend this restaurant. 
My food was very good The dish advertised on the special menu that my husband wanted was unavailable a 5:45PM The trout he got was very bland
The clam and jumbo shrimp appetizer was tasty. We had the steamed lobster and halibut for dinner; both excellent. Service was top-notch as well. Christian is such a gem!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best rare bone in prime rib on Long Island. Steak night every Wednesday year round. If you can go to Peter Lugers in Brooklyn, you can make the trip to Freeport.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...