I have been coming here for years, but I’m not sure exactly what happened here. Food was disgusting, I ordered salmon and it was complete mush drowned in oil/butter. Shrimp were under cooked and inedible. I only ever got the chance to order 1 drink, since our waiter never returned while sitting here for a total of an hour. The food arrived about 50 minutes after ordering. Worst dining experience I’ve ever had. Also got attacked by bees the entire time. Another couple was smart enough to get up and leave after how long it took for the server to come out. I couldn’t even finish my food.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
cocot1919
Just happened upon this place. The menu was excellent with variety and depth. We both had the salmon seafood platter with different sides. The fish was so fresh. Never tasted scallops like that before, and the shrimp was tender and delicious. My oysters were fresh from the bay served with a cold Blue Moon . The dessert tray was breathtaking. We chose tiramiso and the most perfect carrot cake, light and not too sweet. Even the coffee was delicious. The service was exceptional 👏. If they're open off season I'll definitely return before the holidays.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chris Lannon
Place is dying . They have the best guy come to perform (travelen Max)There is about 10 tables close to where he is . Wanted to have dinner . Hostess wanted to put us on other side of deck. Asked to sit closer and she said they all reserved. They were waiting for bigger parties . Hope they stay empty all night
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Gustav Tracchia
Two Sundays ago I was there with friends they never had been before. The service was very poor. It seems they had no training of any kind. We had to repeat twice our orders. They waiter made a mistake on the bill and came with a new one of higher value after we had paid. The Bossboys seemed like they're lost with no idea of their function. I've been at the Otto's Grill many times before Katrina and COVID. I had always a pleasant and excellent experience. I'm sad I can't say the same now.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Ana Vasquez
Hey friends! I wanted to take a moment to share my experience about this place tonight, we were 4 people only and we order 4 drinks very simple drinks, we order 2 appetizers plus two main dishes and that’s all, and the bill was almost $300 the food was not enough it’s was little and we didn’t even got full.. terrible price for very little food… not recommended at all…
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 4
Gisela Aguilar
The price is too expensive, and it’sn the best food, one long island ice tea $20?. Margarita $15? And a plate of caserole seafood $38? With 3 Shrimps only one dry potato food is terrible.. not worthy for the price we paid, ohhh on top of everything 20% of gratuity.😡😡
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
o k
Janet is a sweetheart! Great atmosphere & hospitality. Will be back!
julianne Valot
I went and a young man with curly hair and glasses was very rude serving me and just nasty. And when he brought the food out it was cold
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
J K
Food was good 👍 delicious not salty Perfect !!! Waiter was nice everyone was sweet just one older lady seemed cranky 😠 not she wasnt having it but besides that we had a goodtime food was great 👍 But cocktail was a nono it tasted like melted ice ㅜㅜ 😭 😢
Absolutely perfect! Happy hour is fantastic and Janet is lovely. The Cherry clams were incredible and their oysters, true blue pony super delicious 🤤. A ver cozy and calm spot, they made us feel right at home. We’ve surely found our happy hour spot 🫶🏻
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Theresa Caras
The food is ok just very pricey. Great atmosphere especially when they have a good band. Hopefully they have a good summer line up
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Luki Henderson
I love this place! The food is really good. There's a singer who sings sings to various tracks (everything from 2000's R&B to Yacht Rock), his voice is so good and he has lots of charisma. If I think of his name I will edit this review. Good food portions, tasty drinks and attentive service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Maryann Hernon
Casual. Nostalgic
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
S
Had food here before that's why we returned, had excellent food and service. We come here because we can bring our puppy. Very disappointing this time, however. Were seated for a while before the young waiter came to us. Our Diet Cokes were flat. Waited almost a half hour for our wings, which were stale and just lukewarm on the inside. Had to ask for paper napkins. My cheese burger was tasteless and dry, no lettuce or tomato. The fries were actually quite good. The menu has been whittled down and overall the food was very mediocre. Would not recommend... will likely never return
Food was cold
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 3
I have been coming here for years, but I’m not sure exactly what happened here. Food was disgusting, I ordered salmon and it was complete mush drowned in oil/butter. Shrimp were under cooked and inedible. I only ever got the chance to order 1 drink, since our waiter never returned while sitting here for a total of an hour. The food arrived about 50 minutes after ordering. Worst dining experience I’ve ever had. Also got attacked by bees the entire time. Another couple was smart enough to get up and leave after how long it took for the server to come out. I couldn’t even finish my food.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Just happened upon this place. The menu was excellent with variety and depth. We both had the salmon seafood platter with different sides. The fish was so fresh. Never tasted scallops like that before, and the shrimp was tender and delicious.
My oysters were fresh from the bay served with a cold Blue Moon . The dessert tray was breathtaking. We chose tiramiso and the most perfect carrot cake, light and not too sweet. Even the coffee was delicious. The service was exceptional 👏. If they're open off season I'll definitely return before the holidays.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Place is dying . They have the best guy come to perform (travelen Max)There is about 10 tables close to where he is . Wanted to have dinner . Hostess wanted to put us on other side of deck. Asked to sit closer and she said they all reserved. They were waiting for bigger parties . Hope they stay empty all night
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Two Sundays ago I was there with friends they never had been before. The service was very poor. It seems they had no training of any kind. We had to repeat twice our orders. They waiter made a mistake on the bill and came with a new one of higher value after we had paid. The Bossboys seemed like they're lost with no idea of their function. I've been at the Otto's Grill many times before Katrina and COVID. I had always a pleasant and excellent experience. I'm sad I can't say the same now.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Hey friends! I wanted to take a moment to share my experience about this place tonight, we were 4 people only and we order 4 drinks very simple drinks, we order 2 appetizers plus two main dishes and that’s all, and the bill was almost $300 the food was not enough it’s was little and we didn’t even got full.. terrible price for very little food… not recommended at all…
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 4
The price is too expensive, and it’sn the best food, one long island ice tea $20?. Margarita $15? And a plate of caserole seafood $38? With 3 Shrimps only one dry potato food is terrible.. not worthy for the price we paid, ohhh on top of everything 20% of gratuity.😡😡
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
Janet is a sweetheart! Great atmosphere & hospitality. Will be back!
I went and a young man with curly hair and glasses was very rude serving me and just nasty. And when he brought the food out it was cold
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Food was good 👍 delicious not salty
Perfect !!! Waiter was nice everyone was sweet just one older lady seemed cranky 😠 not she wasnt having it but besides that we had a goodtime food was great 👍 But cocktail was a nono it tasted like melted ice ㅜㅜ 😭 😢
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Absolutely perfect! Happy hour is fantastic and Janet is lovely. The Cherry clams were incredible and their oysters, true blue pony super delicious 🤤. A ver cozy and calm spot, they made us feel right at home. We’ve surely found our happy hour spot 🫶🏻
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food is ok just very pricey. Great atmosphere especially when they have a good band. Hopefully they have a good summer line up
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
I love this place! The food is really good. There's a singer who sings sings to various tracks (everything from 2000's R&B to Yacht Rock), his voice is so good and he has lots of charisma. If I think of his name I will edit this review. Good food portions, tasty drinks and attentive service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Casual. Nostalgic
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Had food here before that's why we returned, had excellent food and service. We come here because we can bring our puppy. Very disappointing this time, however. Were seated for a while before the young waiter came to us. Our Diet Cokes were flat. Waited almost a half hour for our wings, which were stale and just lukewarm on the inside. Had to ask for paper napkins. My cheese burger was tasteless and dry, no lettuce or tomato. The fries were actually quite good. The menu has been whittled down and overall the food was very mediocre. Would not recommend... will likely never return
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 2
Loading...