Restaurants near Frewsburg

“If you're looking for authentic Italian cuisine that feels straight out of Italy, Anthony’s supper club is an absolute gem. From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted with warm smiles, the comforting aroma of fresh herbs, and an atmosphere that perfectly balances rustic charm with modern elegance. We started with the red, white and blue burger — creamy, rich, and perfectly paired with the truffle fries. The sauce was this beautiful balance of heat, richness, and spice that hit every note. The pasta is clearly made fresh daily; the prime rib was tender and flavorful, and the shrimp was cooked to perfection with just the right amount of spice and garlic. The service deserves its own mention — attentive without being overbearing, and the staff truly know their menu. Our server even recommended a lovely pizza that paired beautifully with our main courses. To finish, the pies they served were heavenly — light, airy, and not too sweet — easily one of the best I’ve had outside of Italy. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or just craving an exceptional meal, Anthony's Supper Club is the way to go!”

“Great place to eat! Try it you won’t be dory!”

“The cupcakes are to die for!!!”

“We had a delicious dinner last night at The Horseshoe Inn. We sat at the bar and enjoyed a lively conversation with John - our high spirited bar tender and owner. The chili salmon was delightful and the fried bologna sandwich was very much enjoyed by my hubby. Highly recommend a visit 😎”

“Good Food, Good Service! We always order out the wings because they have some awesome sauces.”

“Great food”

“We were up at Lake Chautauqua from Pittsburgh, had breakfast at this diner. What a hidden gem. Food was delicious and owner Mark who is also the cook is salt of the earth type person. Must eat there!!!!!”

“Probably the best restaurant from Erie to Buffalo. Simple ingredients, elevated. 10 orders in 17 minutes, plated. Every element on each dish- perfected. I did not expect to find a new favorite restaurant, but here we are, each member of our group aged 5-60+, with the kind ofsmile that only comes from stomach-happiness.”

“tried today for the 1st time absolutely delicious ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐”

“From the first bite to the last interaction, this place feels like NYC at its finest. The quality, the professionalism, and the depth of flavor are on another level. It’s rare to experience excellence so consistently. Thank you for being such a remarkable company.”

“Delicious drinks and food! Fabulous and friendly service!”

“My daughter came to us and said yall got to try this little place in Russell and now every time we’re by there we stop in. Clean, friendly, highly recommend.”

“I had a great experience! The food was delicious, fresh, and exactly what I was hoping for. We decided to order online and the drinks were never delivered. The owners remade the coffee and hand delivered it to our door. Their customer service was excellent, and they were quick to fix the issue. Great people working there.”

“I have been coming here since I was a lil kid and same with my sister Dean's haves always been my favorite place to go to for breakfast they have amazing food amazing employees and most of the customers there are nice too I do recommend to go with family or friends”

“We visit here often. It has become our favorite breakfast place in town. The Men who own and run it, learn your order if you become a regular. They are pretty awsome.”

“We have quickly became regulars at this local diner! They always have great food, friendly staff, quick wait times for food, and very reasonable prices. Highly recommend for breakfast or lunch!”

“Best Breakfast place around!”

“The food was great the bartender was not very friendly at all chairs had no cushions on chairs that needed them tables need to be cleaned don't recommend dining in”

“While in Jamestown to see Nat Comedy Center & Lucy/Desi Museum, we stopped for lunch at The Pub. Excellent service! Great food! 😋 Will def eat here again next time I'm up that way.”

“Very friendly staff. Good food and great prices.”

“This place was fantastic! Found it from a Google search. We had the stuffed shrimp, Greek Burger with fries, baked beans and a salad. So flavorful, the tomato Alfredo sauce with the shrimp was excellent! Make sure to get their grapeseed vinaigrette dressing. Our server was delightful, overall great food, service and atmosphere! Will definitely come back!”

“One of the best kept secrets in Jamestown. Excellent food, service with very reasonable prices.”

“Came in with a custom drink order and Juana made it and exceeded expectations she's also always so sweet and kind!”

“I made the trip up from PA just for the Concord Grape pies, because I didn't have time to make them myself. I was very happy to find them available not far away, as I always figured I'd have to make a day trip up by the Finger Lakes region to get my hands on one. I just had a slice, and it was absolutely delicious!! I'll definitely be going back for special occasions - it's a beautiful little shop & you should check it out!”

“The meals were great, service was friendly, and the atmosphere was inviting. Looking forward to coming back here, especially when the weather is nicer and the outdoor seating is more welcoming. 😁”

“The hot dogs are amazing.”

“Amazing food”

“Best pizza and wings around!”

“What a great place! We were up for a Visit Oct 1,2025. Outside was clean and cute as any Irish Pub in Ireland, inside was too! Great atmosphere, Irish music playing. Food was amazing! Shepherds pie and Upside down Guinness Pie. Outstanding ! Will definitely be back! Our Bartender/waiter was the best,very welcoming and fun!”

“We have dined at the Good Time Saloon several times and have never been disappointed with the food, service, or atmosphere. The prices are more than reasonable and the food is delicious. The staff are friendly, the drinks aren’t watered down, and all the bartenders make a damn good LIT! Good Time Saloon is our new hangout when we’re in town… Cheers 🍻”