Anthony’s Supper Club

174 Ivory St, Frewsburg
(716) 922-4054

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Richard Zock

3 hrs.....3hrs waiting for salty food. I dont usually write 1 star reviews unless it was a bad experience but this really was. First of we were seated after a group showed up after us as we walked in.
No drinks menu so we ordered basic drinks. We sat outside and the tables were covered in ants and dirty. Ordered apps, got the ahi tuna crisps which were good. Placed our order for the 20oz ribeye steak specials ($45) each. Went with brussel sprouts instead of the baked potato (wrong move), should have stuck with the potato. After placing our food order we waited 30 min, then another 30 min, then another 30 min, until i over heard the table behind us ( which also waited 2 hrs for their food) that no one inside has had their food yet. At that point we were about to pay our drinks and leave but the waitress was apologetic about the wait and the table behind said it would be worth the wait ( im assuming they were regulars). So we waited another 30 min until finally our food was served. The food looked good but dam my taste buds were not ready for the salt shock it was about to endure. This is where that baked potato would have come in handy. Steak was cooked good but it was overly salty and so were the tiny portion of salty brussel sprouts. I didnt want dessert as i thought that too might be salty, lol. Really sad for waiting 3 hrs for salty over priced food. Service could have been better too as our waitress just walked past us a few times without asking if we needed anything. Wont be back.

Dewayne Parkinson

Delicious pizza and food. Great service. Nice atmosphere. Looks to be well cared for. And did I mention delicious pizza 🍕!

UPDATE: GO TO ANTHONY'S, you will not be disappointed! The quality, quantity and price of the food makes it well worth the visit. We have tried many menu items over the past few times visiting and have never had a bad experience. I would even go as far as to say that we have never even had a mediocre experience. It has been excellent every..... single....... time! The truffle fries are amazing! The pizza is off the hook!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizzas

Kathryn W

Awesome food and service!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gail Kirsch

Our server was absolutely fantastic! She was probably the best we've ever had eating out anywhere. Food was delicious and generous portions. We will be returning!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

chastity prine

The best pizza around.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizzas

Connie Dove

Hard to have a conversation. Very popular place and delicious food.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Andrea Decker

Delicious meals and great waitress!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jay HoL

Probably one of the best pizzas in the area. Food was all excellent. Drinks were good. Did I mention the food was excellent? My only complaints were that the service was very slow and the blue walls and bright lights don't match the quality of food you are getting. We will definitely be returning and probably making this my new pizza joint.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 3

Toni Dunn

this may be a long review but please read it all!! I've eaten here a few times. but I decided to rent out the location for tonight. after tonight I decided I needed to write this. from the first interaction til the end of the event anthony was kind curteous, and very informative about prices and any food details. he helped pick out a custom menu for my event. come to the evening of my event everything was on time as discussed. I chose family style dining since that is what I usually prefer. when it came to the main course, the ribeye was cooked perfectly, sliced nicely and had a delicious herb butter on top. the chicken was tender, moist and also delicious. the green beans were lightly seasoned which helped cleanse the palate. he even went above and beyond with the baked potatoes with adding sides to make it a loaded baked potato. this is absolutely the best food we have eaten!! he uses a higher quality product which makes the biggest difference in flavor, and tenderness. be warned. it may cost a little more. BUT I'd rather pay more for a delicious higher quality meal we can enjoy vs paying less for crap. we highly recommend this restaurant to everyone. especially those who would love for their taste buds to be entertained by delicious flavors and textures. I absolutely can't wait to eat there again. YUM!!

Nathaniel Colley

I have just recently ate here and it was the best food I've had in a long time. Every item on the menu is cooked to perfection and the staff are all so welcoming! It truly feels like home every time I step through the doors.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Staci Whittenhall

We went for our 17th anniversary, and everything was outstanding. From the Pub Fries to the AMAZING PIZZA! Could not resist the Peanut Butter Cheesecake with Chocolate coating. Anthony, I especially appreciated sitting below a picture of "Pops". Thank you so much for a Wonderful and Memorable Dinner! As stated in several previous posts - Please make reservations.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizzas

Robert Mizell

I would recommend this dining for everyone. Very friendly and personable!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

lynne mclaughlin

Anthony’s does catering and catered my nephew and nieces graduation party today! The chicken BBQ and side veggie and hot, cold pasta salads were amazing! Best grilled chicken I have ever had, no lie, juicy, tender and skin was grilled perfect- flavor was Amazing! 200% recommend!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Wil Keyes

I had Sicilian sauce and meat balls over rigatoni, very delicious!.. the meat balls are amazing!.. and my wife had the grilled chicken cob salad, she said it was excellent, fresh ingredients.. and the carrot cake was amazing as well.. Anthony and the servers were all very nice and hospitable, will definitely be back!..

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

shannon Priester, REM, GSP

The steak was fantastic!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...