Mama Theresa's
$$ • Pizza, Italian, Vegetarian
Hours:
2429 Jericho Turnpike, Garden City Park
(516) 747-3111
About Mama Theresa's
Customers' Favorites
Mama Theresa's Reviews
Share your opinion about Mama Theresa's
I went for a family dinner Sunday. A waiter handed me a metal container that looked like milk. It was boiling water and he did not tell me. I got a 2nd burn on my lower back. No apology from wait staff they seemed more annoyed about cleaning it up. I left a message on their site the next day. I emailed the at info and the email didn’t work. When I finally had a chance to call the week later, the manager was very rude. Told me I should have contacted earlier and dismissed the fact that I sent emails. Told me she couldn’t do anything about it.
Ratings
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 10:30AM - 9:30PM |
| Tuesday | 10:30AM - 9:30PM |
| Wednesday | 10:30AM - 9:30PM |
| Thursday | 10:30AM - 9:30PM |
| Friday | 10:30AM - 10PM |
| Saturday | 10:30AM - 10PM |
| Sunday | 10:30AM - 9:30PM |
People in Garden City Park Also Viewed
Mama Theresa's is a beloved restaurant that has been pleasing palates for decades. Despite some inconsistency in portion sizes and service, the food remains excellent, with popular dishes like the "stuffed slice" appetizer being a standout. The restaurant boasts a huge parking lot, is kid-friendly, and has wheelchair accessibility. With a wide variety of options to suit all tastes, Mama Theresa's is a reliable choice for a satisfying meal, with favorites like boccachini and buffalo chicken chopped salad consistently impressing. The restaurant is conveniently located in a busy shopping center, making it easy to visit for lunch or dinner. The vibes are good, and the staff is attentive, providing friendly service to a loyal local crowd. The menu offers a range of options, including takeout and table service, with generous portions and a cozy atmosphere. During busy times, the back dining room fills up, especially on Fridays, with guests enjoying bread and butter made from pizza dough and various lunch specials. Customers have recently praised the restaurant for its pizza, calling it their new favorite spot and comparing it favorably to other top Sicilian square pizzas. The service remains consistently good, with attentive staff like Melvin and helpful hosts making guests feel welcome. Occasionally, the food can vary in quality, but overall, Mama Theresa's continues to be a popular spot known for its good food, welcoming environment, and reliable service.