Mama Theresa's

2429 Jericho Turnpike, Garden City Park
(516) 747-3111

Customers' Favorites

Photos

+36 photos
+35 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Ordered a neopolitan pie and for the price, I expected a pizza that could at least hold itself together. Instead, I got a glorified cheese puddle on what I can only assume was a whisper of dough. The crust was so thin it felt like a rumor, barely there, and certainly not sturdy enough to support the sauce and cheese, which seemed to be clinging on out of sheer desperation. Flavor? Meh. Structure? Nonexistent. Value? Laughable. If you're into edible paper topped with regret,...
This place has to be our new favorite spot for pizza. We have tried some of the renowned restaurants in the city and the island. Move over L&B in Brooklyn there is a new top Sicilian square.
I asked for extra alfredo sauce with my fettuccine. What they gave me was nearly drowning. I wish I could rate it 6 stars. (Also had a delicious salad and excellent service, but this is about how the chefs understand what an alfredo lover really wants.)

More Reviews