Bleecker street pizza

630 Old Country Rd, Garden City
(934) 200-5149

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Lexi C

Honestly for some mall pizza it wasn’t that bad. Crust was a little soft but the chicken was nice and spicy.

Gregoria Lizama de Rodriguez

My slice was super fresh and hot, 😋all the team are very friendly <3 …I will definitely visit this place again with my family. 💯 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ thank you 🙏

HANDS ON CHANNEL

I was so excited to find a Bleeker Street Pizza in the Roosevelt Field Mall food court. I have been going to the one in the village in Manhattan for years. I asked the guys if I could take a few pics of their delicious pies and they were more than happy. Highly recommend to try the chicken, crumbled bacon with ranch dressing pizza, it will send you out of this world. Another favorite is the Grandma Pizza. I had to take a whole pie home and of course freeze some of it for later eats. Shopping at this mall is great, and knowing there is a Bleeker Street Pizza inside is amazing.

w s

The garlic knots were hard and didn’t have much flavor :/

Rich H

So I went to the nyc location years back and I just finished my two slices from the Roosevelt field location and it is 10x’s better than the ones I had the first time!. I just had the nonna Maria and the grandma they were both excellent even better than my very first time!!. I’m impressed!!.

Amy Cruz

employees were making fun of my friends. as if they aren't working at the world’s saddest excuse of a pizza place. the one before Bleecker that had personal pizzas was my favorite spot and now I can’t even enjoy the mall with this bootleg replacement
Stay away from the chicken here. Anything with chicken in it. I got a buffalo chicken slice and it was the grossest thing I’ve ever eaten. the meat was disgustingly mushy and was definitely frozen and thrown onto a pie. Cheaped out on the ingredients. The crust was flavorless and dry. Very very flimsy with no good crunch whatsoever. I had to go back to my hometown pizzeria to get another buffalo slice to replenish my taste buds it was that bad. I should’ve known something was up when there was no line to order.

Johnny Drama

I went there at around 2 pm today and I was served by a Hispanic guy with tattoos who seemed angry for no reason and put my cup of sauce DIRECTLY on top of my margherita slice before bagging it up so that when I took it out there was sauce all over the cup. He had a foul attitude overall and rushed everyone he served. The pizza’s still good and I’ll probably still come back but if I see him I’ll just keep walking.

juan basurto

I first judge based on the pizza display, I thought the pizza wouldn’t taste good so I walked away but I then came back and wanted to give it a try, I was shocked when I tried the margarita slice, it was good as hell and I demolished it craz, I tried over 20 pizza store in Suffolk, Nassau, the city 9.1/10 the pizza I tried today

Allison Paul

I went to them when they first open and I asked for the pasta which is clearly on the menu. The guy misunderstood and gave me a plain slice and then I asked for pasta again and he said there was none, so I assumed that they just opened so they didn't have any yet. I went back a few hours later and asked another man if they have pasta and the original guy came and yelled at me that they never have pasta. There's no need to yell at me for that and also why is it on your menu if you never have it? You should probably work on the service and menu given the fact that your restaurant is the only one in the food court with no line ever, no wonder.

Kiro Chen

Good cheese slice..mediocre garlic knots. Could be softer

PhilYouIn

Located in the corner of the super clean food court, they serve excellent, fresh, hot pizza right out of the oven. Employees seemed friendly and eager to serve. More than enough seating for you to spend as much time as you please. A nice experience. ♿️

Bly

I aint gonna lie ya’ll
THIS JAWN

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Rudy Rosenberg

Went there last night (Wednesday). The Food Court was dead quiet. I ordered two regular slices and a 20 ounce Coke. $12 which is reasonable. There was the cashier and three guys standing around doing nothing, which I understand. I waited as it was heated and the fellow puts it into a paper bag, closes it up, and pushes it towards me. Not a word said. Nobody said anything, not a thanks, nothing. There must be 15 choices there and you'd think they'd be a little nicer. But as they are not the owners they don't give a ****. My wife said that's the norm these days...

As a business owner myself I'd want to know if an employee was not up to snuff. Consider this a message. Don't know if anyone at the home office cares, but this is more effective than calling and getting blown off.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 2

stvn332

I aint gonna lie ya’ll
THIS JAWN HIT

Mike Lauretti

Best pizza on Long Island. 9.1/10.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...