Maggiano's Little Italy

600 Garden City Plaza, Garden City
(516) 877-9640

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Eileen

We did the family style. Food was good. They raised the price and it is no longer unlimited. Also the cut down on the choice of food you can get

Patricia Mccormack

My son and new daughter in law had a small wedding dinner at this restaurant. The food was delicious and more than abundant! The wait staff and the chef were so attentive! I have food allergies, and the chef met with me to ask what I would like made gluten free. This has never been provided for me before! I cannot recommend this restaurant enough.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Isai S

Awesome place, great location, fenomenal service and excellent food... I'll definitely recommend it! 💯🤩✨ #Restaurant #Food #Service #Location #Recommendation

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Tiramisu, Maggiano's Salad, Chocolate Cake, Calamari Fritté, Chicken Marsala, Nutella Cheesecake

Tissan Riley

I've been to Maggianos many times for lunch and service is always fast and efficient. The servers are always very friendly and knowledgeable about the menu. The food is always delicious and well within my budget

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

James Daniel

Amazing experience the food was plenty full. The bread was soft and the server was great. His name was Dylan. The managers name was Eddie , I told Eddie that it was my first time there and how well Dylan was doing. It wanted to be Dylan‘s first day as well as my first day. I went there for a birthday dinner for my mother. Eddie gave us a free appetizer gift card for next time. Was very happy with our meals. The wagyu meatballs were great. Calamari was a classic. I ordered rigatoni and vodka. My family ordered other stuff and it was all so good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

B B

Went to celebrate a family member’s birthday. We were a large group of family and friends. The food was delicious and the waiters were phenomenal. Everyone enjoyed their food. Not one negative comment. I highly recommend this restaurant.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Chris

Server Ashley was robot like. Very cold and very little of a personality . Was odd and difficult to communicate with her. Everything else was great.

Diane Nicholson

My now favorite restaurant. Excellent food, clean, nice atmosphere, great parking.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Maggiano's Salad

Tony Moussignac

My wife and I chose Maggiano’s to celebrate our anniversary but our experience was somewhat mixed. Although we didn’t wait long to be seated, WHERE we were seated was the issue.
As we were led into the dining area, we noticed that there were only about 3 families dining (not including a party on the other side).

However, the hostess led us past numerous tables and all the way to the back corner of the restaurant. This felt completely unnecessary and a bit off-putting since the restaurant was nearly empty. And yes, we did take notice of “who” the other families were. It left me wondering if we were being profiled.

On a better note, we requested different seating and were accommodated. Our waitress was attentive, kind, and professional — and the food was delicious. So while the initial service was questionable and could have been more welcoming, the rest of our dining experience was great.

We’re willing to give it another chance but are hoping that our next visit will be different, because great food does not outweigh the experience.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nasteiope Jastippe

The atmosphere fit the occasion.

Carla David-Rose

Got a Catered Order to Go... It was Amazing, ready on time and Well organized with the proper Utensils. Delicious

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

DAVID ENGLISH

I loved this place food was awesome great service I will visit this place again NO COMPLAINTS PERIOD.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kha nhu Chau thi

The atmosphere was bright and lively.

Sandra

We enjoyed the ambiance very much and the round table was perfect for our party of six. Appetizer of fried calamari was perfect! The chopped salads were delicious! The spaghetti, however, was a disappointment. No one said anything but the three of us who ordered chicken parm and shrimp parm left ALL the pasta on the plate. Sauce was awful and pasta overcooked. Biggest disappointment which actually ruined the evening was when we were paying for dinner. The waitress handed my husband the credit card machine to just swipe and add a tip. The “itemized” bill was not visible so he had to find the link to the bill...and “study” it to see the tip ($60+) was already included...and the waitress did NOT mention it when she asked for payment. NOT CLASSY. We may not return. Left a bad TASTE in our mouths.

Afshan Ahmed

Everything perfect

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...