Pizza Supreme

678 Stewart Ave, Garden City
(516) 962-2251

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza Slice

Square Extra Cheese Pizza Slice

Square Cheese Pizza Slice

Eggplant Parm Plate

Chicken Parmigiana

Square Cheese Pie

Sicilian Slice

Garlic Knots

Photos

+34 photos

+33 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Grubhub

Postmates

Doordash

Slicelife

Trycaviar

Recent Reviews

It's an old timey pizza joint that has a decent enough pepperoni slice. The service is prompt and friendly. It's not a bad choice if it's the only option in the area. The crust is crunchy enough and the toppings are okay. Granted things are pricey now, but I do expect more even from a humble slice. Hopefully next time is better

Vegetarian options: There are veggie slices and options available

Dietary restrictions: If you have...

August 2024

Definitely one of the better Sicilian slices I’ve had especially out on Long Island lots of sauce good amount of cheese nice crisp on the pie came fresh out of the oven definitely will be back for this Sicilian great spot great sauce!

March 2024

Pizza Supreme used to be located in Roosevelt Field near the Time Out Arcade. The square pie was always amazing. There is nothing better than a piping hot square slice with that incredible mozzarella on top, that delicious sauce and a nice crisp crust. Brings you back. Pizza Supreme is a gem.

December 2023

More Reviews

Restaurants in Garden City, NY

Pizza Supreme

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Order Online

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Pizza Supreme