Butternuts Beer & Ale

4020 NY-51, Garrattsville
(607) 263-5070

Recent Reviews

Jennifer Reed

Great brews, great people, always a fun time! By far, my favorite place to stop for a drink.

Anna Smith

Friendly place Good Beers and tasty food

Janette Green

Good beer and lovely setting. Games available and tasty food too. A real country location.

Chris Skoog

Exceptional beers. Super friendly people. Worth the drive and adventure to get to this spot. Live music on the Saturday we stopped by. Authentic crafted brew, and a great variety.

Ben Sandman

Great beers, beautiful spot, friendly and welcoming. To say this place is off the beaten path is an understatement—but definitely worth a drive. My favorite brewery in the area.

John Feeley

Excellent variety of brews and brats. Chuck & Annmarie are gracious hosts. Good times to be had, beautiful setting inside and out. Certainly will become a regular.

Matt M

Great little spot. Try to stop here when visting family in the area. Love the Porkslap Ale. Can no longer find it here in Massachusetts or Rhode Island.

Ben

Great beers, beautiful spot, friendly and welcoming. To say this place is off the beaten path is an understatement—but definitely worth a drive. My favorite brewery in the area.

Maria Breuninger

The owners brew some mighty fine brews, bring business to the area and maintain the integrity of the original buildings, preserving history and strengthen memories. Yum and thank you.

Peter Martin

Tasty beer. Good prices and located in a nifty old barn. Friendly owner and staff !

Thomas Bosco

Great beers and atmosphere. Loved it

Andrew Turner

This brewery is awesome! Very friendly and knowledgeable owner. Great beer and good times will be had here! If you are nearby you should stop in.

A.C. Antonelli

Butternuts is a little further away from the other Cooperstown area breweries but it's absolutely worth the visit. The brewery has a much smaller, more grassroots vibe then the others as well, but the beer is excellent (and there's much more to try than the iconic Porkslap you've no doubt had if you're from out of town like me). I should note the tasting room is closed during the winter months, but we showed up not knowing that and we were welcomed in anyway for a full private tour and a tasting of whatever was available. There just aren't enough people left on Earth who are willing to inconvenience themselves for strangers and I think it really speaks volumes. Go pay them a visit.

Chris Rill

The owner is cool and the beer is awesome. Literally the best weissebier I've ever had!

Dapanpan Panda

This brewery is awesome! Very friendly and knowledgeable owner. Great beer and good times will be had here! If you are nearby you should stop in.

Load More