Geneseo Diner
CLOSED$ •
About Geneseo Diner
Geneseo Diner Reviews
Today I ordered an omelette. It was very undercooked. I sent it back and asked for it to be cooked a bit more. It came back the same way. When my bill came, I told the server I would just take it home and cook it there. A moment later a person I assume to be the manager came and took my plate and the bill and told me that’s not cooked. I thought he would bring back my food but that didn’t happen. He brought back a bill that he “took off my omelette “ but was actually more...read full review
Not very impressed. Hash browns were super salty and omelette was floating in butter/oil, something. Two people with bfast and coffee $37. Nope
We have been to Geneseo Diner 2 times now and will never go back!
The first time we went is when they first opened up. Went for lunch as my boyfriend ordered Cod and I ordered a wrap. Our waitress seemed to have a hard time understanding for what we wanted and had to point it out on menu. Our drinks came and we waited, waited. and waited - about a half hour now so a different waitress came to our table as she must of seen how long we have been waiting for our food. We told...read full review
Ratings
Menu
People in Geneseo Also Viewed
Geneseo Diner offers good food, a clean atmosphere, and fair prices. It has become a popular breakfast-lunch spot after other nearby diners closed down. Visitors often praise the friendly service, especially mentioning a lovely waitress. Many customers enjoy the variety of menu options, such as steak and eggs with pancakes, which are often cooked perfectly, and the BLT with fries and homemade chili with a great kick. The food is consistently fresh, hot, and delicious, with some dishes like the Irish Benedict cooked to perfection. While service can sometimes be slower when it comes to checks, staff members are pleasant and attentive. However, some dishes like the hot open face turkey sandwich may not meet everyone's expectations due to lumpy mashed potatoes, small portions, and bland gravy. Overall, the diner remains a favored place for good food and friendly service, with many customers planning to return.