Overpriced basic seafood dishes, definitely not worth it. Much better options in the area
STEPHANIEK
This was so disappointing! I haven't been here in about 15 years. I remember enjoying the clam chowder. This time it was was too thick, likely overcooked, and without seasoning. The food was subpar but pricey. The servers were very nice but very slow. The brownies a la mode were burned and really dry throughout. Sadly, I won't be returning.
MaryannL
I think the best reason to eat at Claudio‘s is that it's been Claudio's since 1860! It's a beautiful ambience, water view, the best location one could have in a charming town. The food was good, not outstanding, but certainly good. It wasn't pricey, about middle of the road price-wise. All in all a lovely Christmas Eve experience with my family!
BridgetL
I usually love Claudio's and we are regulars. This only relates to their Thanksgiving spread. It was outrageously overpriced, and the food was not good. The ham was incredibly dry, there was no cranberry sauce, we were really shocked. As usual, the service was excellent. They had advertised saying there were arts and crafts, and we thought it would be festively decorated, but it was not. But we were extremely disappointed and won't be back for a Thanksgiving meal. But we will continue to return for their excellent seafood and their beautiful location on the water. 
Rich
Quiet night. The restaurant wasn't crowded. Service and food were excellent. The GM Malik gave us a tour of this historic landmark. He is a wealth of knowledge. Lots of history. Lovely evening in the NOFO off-season
Rita Levey
We celebrated our wedding at Crabby Jerrys this summer. We could not have been happier with the service and the special attention that day. Jonathan and his staff worked tirelessly to provide an incredible experience. The guests are still talking about what a great time they had. Many guests approached me, and told me that the service was impeccable, and that the food was the best!All of our needs were met beyond expectations that day. The planning process was very thorough and detailed. The entire staff seemed genuinely excited and happy to participate in our special day. We are incredibly grateful for the beautiful venue, the fabulous food and drink, the fantastic service, detailed planning and for our new friends at Crabby Jerry's!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chelsea Connor
This is a strange place. It has the prices of a high end restaurant and they expect tipping but you have to go up, order, and receive your own food. The food itself was fine, tasted like a fish and chips type place. Beautiful views though.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 1
Mark
We had not been to Claudio's in many years and were blown away by how much it has changed from the Claudio of old. If you like me, remember Claudio as being part of the history of Greenport but somewhere to avoid then please go back. Nice decor, interesting menu, good bar and a kitchen and serving staff that know what they are doing.
Grenten Dhuli
A good place for large crowds, however, maintenance of the area could of been better. Food was decent, especially if you’re paying around $40 for a lobster roll and a very small serving of fried calamari. There were a couple of bees swarming the establishment as people ate, making it uncomfortable for patrons. Cleanliness could be better. Dock view is obviously nice and we were able to hear the live music from across the dock, while there was nothing where we were. Overall, its a overpriced quick bite, but, I wouldn’t recommend coming back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Lobster Roll and Calamari
JeanC
The lobster was a disappointment. It was advertised as a 2 pound lobster, but it definitely was much less. It also seemed as though it had been sitting around already cooked. The service was excellent, and I would go back and try again, but I would not do the lobster special.
Great food and atmosphere. The staff was fantastic, with the manager Malik overseeing a great crew. Malik gave us a quick tour and made our birthday dinner special. He was awesome!
The atmosphere is good, service was good and food was good. Not excellent and paying $10 for parking was an absolute disappointment. We have been going to Claudio's for 50 plus years and this is ridiculous. Never have we had to pay for parking. But it does give you the whole East End experience.
LarryF
We were at Claudio's for my wife's birthday while in Greenport. While walking around town we stopped by the restaurant to confirm our reservation (about 5hr's before) and asked for a nice table outside or at least close to the window when we arrive. When we arrived, we were seated at a table adjacent to busboy station in the back of the restaurant and after reminding them of our request was told that was all they had. It was noisy with a lot of staff passing the table. I ordered the swordfish Bolognese it was the worst Bolognese I ever had ! There 3 or 4 small cubes of swordfish and 1 or 2 small carrot cubes no other vegetables and the sauce was thin like out of a jar with little flavor. My wife had the Lobster roll it was good but not like the old Claudio's. Claudio's has become a large operation and seems to have lost its focus. They appear to own everything by the water. Our waitress was working hard, but the dining room was understaffed and no coordination between waiters and other staff. Everything was slow to come out and could not find your waitress when needed. What a disappointment.
Kelly Ann
The whole family had a great experience and the food, lobster roll and crab cake sandwiche was insane!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John D
We went to Crabby Jerry’s on a Sunday for lunch. We wound up getting a great spot under a table with an umbrella next to the water. It was perfect. We had the live music in the distance from Claudio’s without it being annoying. The food was delicious and the drinks were outstanding. I got the dockside lemonade and then about 6 more. Definitely a great spot for a weekend hangout in the summer. OH and the shrimp quesadilla was PHENOMENAL!
Overpriced basic seafood dishes, definitely not worth it. Much better options in the area
This was so disappointing! I haven't been here in about 15 years. I remember enjoying the clam chowder. This time it was was too thick, likely overcooked, and without seasoning. The food was subpar but pricey. The servers were very nice but very slow. The brownies a la mode were burned and really dry throughout. Sadly, I won't be returning.
I think the best reason to eat at Claudio‘s is that it's been Claudio's since 1860! It's a beautiful ambience, water view, the best location one could have in a charming town. The food was good, not outstanding, but certainly good. It wasn't pricey, about middle of the road price-wise. All in all a lovely Christmas Eve experience with my family!
I usually love Claudio's and we are regulars. This only relates to their Thanksgiving spread. It was outrageously overpriced, and the food was not good. The ham was incredibly dry, there was no cranberry sauce, we were really shocked. As usual, the service was excellent. They had advertised saying there were arts and crafts, and we thought it would be festively decorated, but it was not. But we were extremely disappointed and won't be back for a Thanksgiving meal. But we will continue to return for their excellent seafood and their beautiful location on the water. 
Quiet night. The restaurant wasn't crowded. Service and food were excellent. The GM Malik gave us a tour of this historic landmark. He is a wealth of knowledge. Lots of history. Lovely evening in the NOFO off-season
We celebrated our wedding at Crabby Jerrys this summer. We could not have been happier with the service and the special attention that day. Jonathan and his staff worked tirelessly to provide an incredible experience. The guests are still talking about what a great time they had. Many guests approached me, and told me that the service was impeccable, and that the food was the best!All of our needs were met beyond expectations that day. The planning process was very thorough and detailed. The entire staff seemed genuinely excited and happy to participate in our special day. We are incredibly grateful for the beautiful venue, the fabulous food and drink, the fantastic service, detailed planning and for our new friends at Crabby Jerry's!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is a strange place. It has the prices of a high end restaurant and they expect tipping but you have to go up, order, and receive your own food. The food itself was fine, tasted like a fish and chips type place. Beautiful views though.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 1
We had not been to Claudio's in many years and were blown away by how much it has changed from the Claudio of old. If you like me, remember Claudio as being part of the history of Greenport but somewhere to avoid then please go back. Nice decor, interesting menu, good bar and a kitchen and serving staff that know what they are doing.
A good place for large crowds, however, maintenance of the area could of been better. Food was decent, especially if you’re paying around $40 for a lobster roll and a very small serving of fried calamari. There were a couple of bees swarming the establishment as people ate, making it uncomfortable for patrons. Cleanliness could be better. Dock view is obviously nice and we were able to hear the live music from across the dock, while there was nothing where we were. Overall, its a overpriced quick bite, but, I wouldn’t recommend coming back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Lobster Roll and Calamari
The lobster was a disappointment. It was advertised as a 2 pound lobster, but it definitely was much less. It also seemed as though it had been sitting around already cooked. The service was excellent, and I would go back and try again, but I would not do the lobster special.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great food and atmosphere. The staff was fantastic, with the manager Malik overseeing a great crew. Malik gave us a quick tour and made our birthday dinner special. He was awesome!
The atmosphere is good, service was good and food was good. Not excellent and paying $10 for parking was an absolute disappointment. We have been going to Claudio's for 50 plus years and this is ridiculous. Never have we had to pay for parking. But it does give you the whole East End experience.
We were at Claudio's for my wife's birthday while in Greenport. While walking around town we stopped by the restaurant to confirm our reservation (about 5hr's before) and asked for a nice table outside or at least close to the window when we arrive. When we arrived, we were seated at a table adjacent to busboy station in the back of the restaurant and after reminding them of our request was told that was all they had. It was noisy with a lot of staff passing the table. I ordered the swordfish Bolognese it was the worst Bolognese I ever had ! There 3 or 4 small cubes of swordfish and 1 or 2 small carrot cubes no other vegetables and the sauce was thin like out of a jar with little flavor. My wife had the Lobster roll it was good but not like the old Claudio's. Claudio's has become a large operation and seems to have lost its focus. They appear to own everything by the water. Our waitress was working hard, but the dining room was understaffed and no coordination between waiters and other staff. Everything was slow to come out and could not find your waitress when needed. What a disappointment.
The whole family had a great experience and the food, lobster roll and crab cake sandwiche was insane!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We went to Crabby Jerry’s on a Sunday for lunch. We wound up getting a great spot under a table with an umbrella next to the water. It was perfect. We had the live music in the distance from Claudio’s without it being annoying. The food was delicious and the drinks were outstanding. I got the dockside lemonade and then about 6 more. Definitely a great spot for a weekend hangout in the summer. OH and the shrimp quesadilla was PHENOMENAL!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Stake Sandwitch