It's my goal to try out all the pizza places in Central NY. Oliveri's is a stand out - friendly staff and a warm little cozy place probably does a lot of business in takeout. They do a good crust here - crispy thinner crust is key. Sauce and cheese are decent too. I will return. Prices are the fairest I have seen in the area.
Kathleen S.
A huge shoutout to Oliveri's Pizzeria. They catered a lunch for about 75 people for the Hamilton Central School musical. Mike is a joy to work with, thorough and generous. And the food, as always, was delicious. It's not the first time he's provided food for our Masquers program, and it's not the first time it was delicious. We had a great variety to suit different ages and different palettes. It was delivered piping hot and on time. We ordered pizzas, baked ziti, tortellini in Alfredo sauce, salads, baked meatballs, chicken tenders, and their delicious baked chicken (I can't say enough about this baked chicken). I think I got everything. We did have leftovers, which is great, as some of us are now able to enjoy everything for just a bit longer. Thank you Mike and the crew at Oliveri's. We know where to find you, and we will definitely be calling on you in the future.
Adam West
Places is a joke glad that colgate is the only thing that maters like we dont pay for it to be delivered if you need extra gas money say
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jake Lamb
This restaurant is managed by an extremely rude man with no customer service skills . I was applaud by the way he spoke to me when asking for my order . Very rude and I’d never suggest Olives Pizzeria in Hamilton,NY to
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Large
Valley and Chenango Court Management
Great meatball subs over here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Valley Management
Great meatball subs over here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Samantha Hafelin
Always get good service and great food!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Wings
Timothy T.
One of the best small town pizzerias of central NY, hands down. I grew up in upstate NY and this features some of the best pepperoni and anchovy pizza I've had south of Utica. The staff is welcoming, service is excellent, but the details put it over the top, such as Manhattan Special espresso soda, fresh parm and Utica grind for your pie. They even had chocolate milk and butter from a local creamery. But the one thing you can't miss are the wings with homemade blue cheese sauce--oof, Madone! 9.7/10, highly recommend.
Allison T.
We just moved back to the area and have been sampling all the pizza joints around, and this is hands down our favorite. The pizza is perfect, with a bubbly crust. Great wings. You have to try the homemade blue cheese dressing. They just don’t make it like that anymore. Friendly staff, clean bathroom, and they have local chocolate milk and sodas to drink. Charming place. We happily drive 30 minutes to get pizza here once a week. Love Oliveri’s!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
John Tresohlavy
The price paid was a little more than the online menu says but other than that, pretty darn good pizza.
My husband loves NY style pizza, and whenever we are in Hamilton, we eat
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Alex Liseo
Best pizzeria around, by far!! The food is top tier and the pizza shop itself looks amazing! This family owned restaurant has amazing owners who put a lot of passion into this pizzeria and it shows! If you’re debating on where to eat, issue solved. Eat here! You won’t be disappointed!!
It's my goal to try out all the pizza places in Central NY. Oliveri's is a stand out - friendly staff and a warm little cozy place probably does a lot of business in takeout. They do a good crust here - crispy thinner crust is key. Sauce and cheese are decent too. I will return. Prices are the fairest I have seen in the area.
A huge shoutout to Oliveri's Pizzeria. They catered a lunch for about 75 people for the Hamilton Central School musical. Mike is a joy to work with, thorough and generous. And the food, as always, was delicious. It's not the first time he's provided food for our Masquers program, and it's not the first time it was delicious. We had a great variety to suit different ages and different palettes. It was delivered piping hot and on time. We ordered pizzas, baked ziti, tortellini in Alfredo sauce, salads, baked meatballs, chicken tenders, and their delicious baked chicken (I can't say enough about this baked chicken). I think I got everything. We did have leftovers, which is great, as some of us are now able to enjoy everything for just a bit longer. Thank you Mike and the crew at Oliveri's. We know where to find you, and we will definitely be calling on you in the future.
Places is a joke glad that colgate is the only thing that maters like we dont pay for it to be delivered if you need extra gas money say
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
This restaurant is managed by an extremely rude man with no customer service skills . I was applaud by the way he spoke to me when asking for my order . Very rude and I’d never suggest Olives Pizzeria in Hamilton,NY to
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Large
Great meatball subs over here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Great meatball subs over here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Always get good service and great food!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Wings
One of the best small town pizzerias of central NY, hands down. I grew up in upstate NY and this features some of the best pepperoni and anchovy pizza I've had south of Utica. The staff is welcoming, service is excellent, but the details put it over the top, such as Manhattan Special espresso soda, fresh parm and Utica grind for your pie. They even had chocolate milk and butter from a local creamery. But the one thing you can't miss are the wings with homemade blue cheese sauce--oof, Madone! 9.7/10, highly recommend.
We just moved back to the area and have been sampling all the pizza joints around, and this is hands down our favorite. The pizza is perfect, with a bubbly crust. Great wings. You have to try the homemade blue cheese dressing. They just don’t make it like that anymore. Friendly staff, clean bathroom, and they have local chocolate milk and sodas to drink. Charming place. We happily drive 30 minutes to get pizza here once a week. Love Oliveri’s!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
The price paid was a little more than the online menu says but other than that, pretty darn good pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
These best!
Great pizza, great people, great place. Best in Madison County coming from a person who grew up in NYC.
The owner is a utica local , his food is east utica classic but In Hamilton . Definitely a must try .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Greek Salad, Wings, Lupo Panini, Baklava
My husband loves NY style pizza, and whenever we are in Hamilton, we eat
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Best pizzeria around, by far!! The food is top tier and the pizza shop itself looks amazing! This family owned restaurant has amazing owners who put a lot of passion into this pizzeria and it shows! If you’re debating on where to eat, issue solved. Eat here! You won’t be disappointed!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Fries