Ye Olde Pizza Pub

2528 NY-12B, Hamilton
(315) 824-1800

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Alexandria Nichols

This place smells amazing as soon as you walk in. I've never been in a place like it and the food was fantastic. I drive an hour and a half every few weeks to get food here.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Weston

Pizza is yummy so are the wings

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Melody Seaton

Waited over an hour and half for a pizza, wings and taters kept being told 10 more minutes. Run by teenagers no manager. People actually left before getting their food requesting money back. Worst experience will not return.asked for a refund and was totally ignored

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Warren Perry

Pizza isn’t half bad. The service, specifically the wait, is ridiculous. Told 30 mins and you’re waiting almost an hour. If this had happened one time, fine! But everytime…every single time.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 1

Deborah Edick

Not sure where the AI came up with overall review of amazing pizza and wings and consistency in quality after reading other reviews.
The wings are over priced, at least 1/2 the size of wings at other establishments, and the coating is mealy. I strongly recommend not ordering takeout especially close to opening time as the wings are usually left over from the previous days business . Since they are closed on Monday you’re just getting Sundays leftovers if ordering Tuesday between 4-6.
Loaded taters are greasy and nasty.
If you’re looking for a laxative this is the place to go, if you’re able to keep it down long enough without regurgitating.
This place has gone way downhill over the years.
Really should have a dress code for the girls on the front end as well as training in customer service.
Will definitely not be back anytime soon.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

The Happy Magic Co Brush Hour Studios

Shitty service, rude kids, young girls that are half clothed. Sticky tables, if you ask for a cloth to wash the tables you get snubbed. Bathrooms are a mess

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Bhailis

Amazing Pizza&Wings. I always get the highest and consistent quality orders from the pizza pub!

I’ll pop service to 3 stars only because getting charged 40.03 for a medium and 15 wings is highly overpriced. If the app worked and I did not have to call-in the order it would have been around 25-30$ so that makes 0 sense.

Mike Shay

Excellent food

GINA MORALES

I was up here for my niece’s wedding at Camp Fiver,they ordered pizzas Thursday evening,2 pepperoni 1 vegetable pizza and 2 cheese pizzas. I’m gonna tell you right now…THAT PIZZA WAS THE BEST I’VE EATEN IN YEARSSSSSS!!!! Thank you for putting your heart and soul and foot into making that pizza. The crust was amazing,now you know if the crust is good,the pizza is good. It reminded me of my youth growing up on the city in Queens NY. I’m telling everyone that decides to come your way or passing by,please stop and this business and get their pizza. It will not disappoint!! Thank you again guys for making pizza the correct way💯❤️

Brandon Himoff

While the food isn't amazing, the memories and camaraderie can't be beat. The taters are simple, but legendary.

chelsie stevens

Katie was very nice .

Douglas E Armstrong

Waited 55 minutes for a meatball sub 3 piece chicken dinner and mot sticks with no communication as to y it took so long then when the meatball sub finally got ready was told they made 2 cause the first one was bad. Honestly if u want food from there I would order for pick up saw lots of people coming to pick up food. Would not recommend dining in at all.!!!!!!

Eskinado Carvell

I've been 3 times, first time, they forgot my food in the back for an hour and a half, second time, they didn't make our food for an hour, third time, the forgot to make our food again, and waited an hour

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 1

Jon Wright

Never disappointed.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizzas, Salad Bar, Wings

Heather Brzostoski

Our experience wasn't the best. We got a large garlic pizza and 2 salad bars. Before we got there, we looked at the menu on-line. The pizza was the same price, but to our shock salad par was 4x the amount. As we were getting our salad, the waitress was dismantling the salad bar. It was almost 8pm. They close at 10pm on Friday. The table & bench were sticky. This was not our favorite dining experience.

Vegetarian options: There are a few plain pizzas, no veggie special. Saladbar was passable , but expensive. There are sides, like tater tots. It's not fine dining, but it will keep you full.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 4

Loading...