Nice atmosphere, but- The lobster crab bisque was WAY over salted. And the bisque had about 1 teaspoon of seafood in it. The special cherry mojito was just a regular mojito with a frozen cherry juice ice cube suspended over ut that eventually watered it down when it melted. My friend’s mule was made with ginger beer that was more flat than carbonated. Less than stellar all around, and definitely overpriced.
ALLISON FOX BARRATT
Great spot on the Keuka Lake Wine Trail to stop for lunch! Kids menu, good draft beers, and service with a smile!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Billie-Jo Stanford
We were here last fall and it was great.... we live a good hr a2ay so we don't get this way often... today we had to go to Penn Yan and looked up to hours and it said open til 8pm... was so happy... got back this way and stopped just to find that it wasn't open .... how disappointing... if you are going to shut down after Christmas... common sense would be to make that clear on Google listing...
Doug Frederick
CiY little place with good food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ashley Johannes
We had dinner here on Saturday night and we were so excited as every time we are in town we have lunch here and the burgers, service, drinks, spicy shrimp are always so delicious. Saturday we decided to try dinner instead and what a mistake... My margarita was pure acid and we were charged $20 for a special Margarita that we did not order, we ordered spicy shrimp and then as I went to order my Entree, the tenderloin I was told it's their last night open and they were out of the steak and I looked at the menu again and my husband tried to order the chicken and was told they were out of that as well... why we were not told they were out of half their menu before we were sat down or even before we ordered drinks I do not know.. then, my husband ordered the grilled cheese and soup and I ordered the ribeye. The ribeye was ok but the veggies were undercooked and cold, potatoes were cold. My husband's grilled cheese had a pound of cheese and was so greasy and the soup was thick like spaghetti sauce. The entrees came out and she asked if we needed anything else and I asked about the shrimp and she said we never ordered it although we definitely did. This was the worst experience we've had here. Very disappointing.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
AHOY CNY
Food was phenomenal, adorable atmosphere, great staff!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Escape02296999386
Phenomenal good. Fantastic atmosphere. Wonderful staff! They opened just for us for a corporate dinner. They were so accommodating!!!
Amber Snyder
We had Timber Stone Grill cater our wedding on 10.11.25 and it was PHENOMENAL! Chloe and Jeff were great to work with, we knew exactly what we were getting and they were so accommodating! They went out of their way to provide excellent food and excellent service, our guests loved the options we had and everything was delicious. Just a few pics from our wedding! We are still waiting for final pics :) Such a great experience! We HIGHLY recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kris Cochrane
My sister and I, who are both veg, went to dinner here as it was recommended for their vegetarian and vegan options. I always appreciate a restaurant having clearly marked or easily modified vegan options, and they sounded great on the menu. The service was quick and attentive. However, the food was extremely lackluster and overpriced. $17 for frozen, pre-made pierogies is outlandish. The veggie grain bowl, while a good portion, was sorely lacking in flavor. The tofu was fried nicely, but was completely unseasoned; it was advertised as maple tofu, and it just had a little bit of sauce on top that we could hardly taste. The veggies and rice were well cooked, but we both needed hot sauce to give the dish any sort of flavor, and for nearly $30 a plate, it was a steep price to pay for bland food. If you’re a vegetarian or vegan visiting, I would recommend trying a different restaurant. We both described our food as “mid” as we left.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
Michelle Mancuso
The burger was delicious and the chicken tenders tasted like heaven. Would eat again.
It can be a bit noisy, depending on the crowd. I suppose that could be true for any popular place. But the food is excellent: artisan bread plate is wonderful and features their own hand-churned butter(!). We had squash soup, and a tomato bisque, and wee completely satisfied. Oh, recommend the Prison City Mass Riot IPA, if you like those.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Erik Z
Decent restaurant. The food was good, service was good. It's an American restaurant. I got burgers and fries. It's a little pricey, but overall I had a good experience.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Audie Simons
Food was great along with beautiful salad accompaniments!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Thetman 92
First time and last time visiting. Menu looked ok. Everything was overpriced. I had the pulled pork mac and cheese. For $31 you'd think it would be topped with gold flakes..waitress seemed annoyed and bothered that she had the wait on us.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Sonja Bell
This is what it looks like when you get takeout. Chicken sandwich did not say it was spicy and did not include lettuce, tomato and onion listed. Paprika fries were an extra $2 for side and just had paprika lol. Veggie grain bowl was soupy. $20 for Mrs T’s pierogies. Ordered peanut butter pie, noticed it was missing when we got back to car. It took another 10 minutes to get the skinniest slice of pumpkin cake because they were out of the pie they forgot to give us. We were compelled to order from here after the recommendation from a local and the good reviews. Maybe everything they got was different?? $100 later, very disappointed.
Nice atmosphere, but-
The lobster crab bisque was WAY over salted.
And the bisque had about 1 teaspoon of seafood in it.
The special cherry mojito was just a regular mojito with a frozen cherry juice ice cube suspended over ut that eventually watered it down when it melted.
My friend’s mule was made with ginger beer that was more flat than carbonated.
Less than stellar all around, and definitely overpriced.
Great spot on the Keuka Lake Wine Trail to stop for lunch! Kids menu, good draft beers, and service with a smile!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
We were here last fall and it was great.... we live a good hr a2ay so we don't get this way often... today we had to go to Penn Yan and looked up to hours and it said open til 8pm... was so happy... got back this way and stopped just to find that it wasn't open .... how disappointing... if you are going to shut down after Christmas... common sense would be to make that clear on Google listing...
CiY little place with good food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had dinner here on Saturday night and we were so excited as every time we are in town we have lunch here and the burgers, service, drinks, spicy shrimp are always so delicious. Saturday we decided to try dinner instead and what a mistake... My margarita was pure acid and we were charged $20 for a special Margarita that we did not order, we ordered spicy shrimp and then as I went to order my Entree, the tenderloin I was told it's their last night open and they were out of the steak and I looked at the menu again and my husband tried to order the chicken and was told they were out of that as well... why we were not told they were out of half their menu before we were sat down or even before we ordered drinks I do not know.. then, my husband ordered the grilled cheese and soup and I ordered the ribeye. The ribeye was ok but the veggies were undercooked and cold, potatoes were cold. My husband's grilled cheese had a pound of cheese and was so greasy and the soup was thick like spaghetti sauce. The entrees came out and she asked if we needed anything else and I asked about the shrimp and she said we never ordered it although we definitely did. This was the worst experience we've had here. Very disappointing.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Food was phenomenal, adorable atmosphere, great staff!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Phenomenal good. Fantastic atmosphere. Wonderful staff! They opened just for us for a corporate dinner. They were so accommodating!!!
We had Timber Stone Grill cater our wedding on 10.11.25 and it was PHENOMENAL! Chloe and Jeff were great to work with, we knew exactly what we were getting and they were so accommodating! They went out of their way to provide excellent food and excellent service, our guests loved the options we had and everything was delicious. Just a few pics from our wedding! We are still waiting for final pics :) Such a great experience! We HIGHLY recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My sister and I, who are both veg, went to dinner here as it was recommended for their vegetarian and vegan options. I always appreciate a restaurant having clearly marked or easily modified vegan options, and they sounded great on the menu. The service was quick and attentive. However, the food was extremely lackluster and overpriced. $17 for frozen, pre-made pierogies is outlandish. The veggie grain bowl, while a good portion, was sorely lacking in flavor. The tofu was fried nicely, but was completely unseasoned; it was advertised as maple tofu, and it just had a little bit of sauce on top that we could hardly taste. The veggies and rice were well cooked, but we both needed hot sauce to give the dish any sort of flavor, and for nearly $30 a plate, it was a steep price to pay for bland food. If you’re a vegetarian or vegan visiting, I would recommend trying a different restaurant. We both described our food as “mid” as we left.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
The burger was delicious and the chicken tenders tasted like heaven. Would eat again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
It can be a bit noisy, depending on the crowd. I suppose that could be true for any popular place. But the food is excellent: artisan bread plate is wonderful and features their own hand-churned butter(!). We had squash soup, and a tomato bisque, and wee completely satisfied. Oh, recommend the Prison City Mass Riot IPA, if you like those.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Decent restaurant. The food was good, service was good. It's an American restaurant. I got burgers and fries. It's a little pricey, but overall I had a good experience.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Food was great along with beautiful salad accompaniments!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time and last time visiting. Menu looked ok. Everything was overpriced. I had the pulled pork mac and cheese. For $31 you'd think it would be topped with gold flakes..waitress seemed annoyed and bothered that she had the wait on us.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
This is what it looks like when you get takeout. Chicken sandwich did not say it was spicy and did not include lettuce, tomato and onion listed. Paprika fries were an extra $2 for side and just had paprika lol. Veggie grain bowl was soupy. $20 for Mrs T’s pierogies. Ordered peanut butter pie, noticed it was missing when we got back to car. It took another 10 minutes to get the skinniest slice of pumpkin cake because they were out of the pie they forgot to give us. We were compelled to order from here after the recommendation from a local and the good reviews. Maybe everything they got was different?? $100 later, very disappointed.
Food: 2
Service: 2
Loading...