Lighthouse Seafood

36 Lighthouse Rd, Hampton Bays
(631) 728-5186

Recent Reviews

Pedro Benitez

Fresh catch big selection

M Pell

The seafood here is so fresh, I love buying all sorts of fresh fish here. Scallops and flounder are outstanding, but there are so many choices. Service is wonderful too.

Maria Moreno

The best fish . Fresh. Great variety.

Jan Kalanda

Great place, more reasonable then many seafood markets in the area.

Andrew Smith

Great fresh seafood and a friendly staff!

Rachael Lara

SO FRESH!

Judith Lapidus

Great local fresh seafood.

Adore Ehmewiz

we still miss the days of Cor-J but fortunately little has changed and this is still our #1 choice for seafood on the east end~ best product/selection + knowledgeable staff. they'll do #littlenecks on the halfshell (when we dont have time to shuck at home) it's a dream and reasonably priced. the blackfish was write-home-about level delicious

Kerry Wilkie

Always fresh! Service is terrific. Never disappoints.

Michael Feldman

Freshest seafood for your home and your BBQ

Maribel Ortiz

Beautiful outdoor eating, all types of fresh seafood. They prepare it you way! Bit pricey

Condor Aerial Video and Photography LLC

Very nice seafood store , everything is nicely displayed on ice . We got some clams, steamers, and mussels and they were fresh and delicious .

Mark Watson

The fish is very fresh. No problem there. But the prices are ridiculously high. I would say 5 or 6 dollars a pound higher than other fish markets and some things as high as 10 dollars a pound higher. I'll take my business somewhere else from now on. What happened to Cor J ? New owners ?? It's not the same old place anymore. Sad.

steve behar

I have to say this place is a true gem. Ordered for NY Eve and everything was perfect! Delicious and fabulous service from Michael. I highly recommend this place. We will be back very soon!Thank you for being so terrific and making this such a great experience.Steve

Hope Loveandlight

So sorry to say this fish market has changed for the worse. Prices are much higher -like $10 a lb higher for black sea bass and striped bass than some of the more expensive markets in the hamptons. Not worth the trip off the highway..no cars in the parking lot. Did they change ownership? When asked was told rent may be lower at other fish stores. A real shame! I won't be back.

Load More