Out of the Blue Seafood
252 E Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays
(631) 728-3474
Recent Reviews
Sort by
252 E Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays
(631) 728-3474
Fish and chips super good, flaky batter, fried to perfection; both fish and chips.. yum
The food was good. Service isn't really table service but I did enjoy the fish and chips
Everything is fresh and absolutely delicious.
Fantastic!
Ordered takeout from this place. Got a salmon, and shrimp scampi. Both extremely bland and not seasoned. The Caesar salad came with literally one teaspoon of dressing. would never order from here again, unfortunately. no flavor in the food.
I came in right at 10 and was asked to come back after 12 if I wanted a lobster roll. Came back around 1 and still waited over 20 mins for an unpalatable lobster roll. The lobster was oddly mushy, excessively seasoned/salty and, I suspected, was not fresh which made the long wait for it even more frustrating. The fries were very good at least.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
Good food
Soo bomb! I live an hour away and was told to come here from a local. Well seasoned, fresh, and tasty. 10/10 recommended. Shrimp cocktail was beautiful price as well
Tried smoked tuna for the first time was very good, topped it off with some calamari and fried scallops. Scallops were the best I have eaten all season
If you’re looking for a quick lunch or dinner, this is not the place to go. We ended up waiting 45 minutes for our food, and it was incredibly frustrating to see other tables—who arrived 15 minutes after us—being served first. When we brought it up, the server was dismissive and rude. He said, “The kitchen is busy and it’s only been 40 minutes,” when in fact it had clearly been longer. What really shocked me was when I pointed out they hadn’t even set our table, and the server had the nerve to ask, “Well, did you ask to be seated?” Completely unprofessional.
Despite the poor service, we still paid the standard tip, which just adds to the disappointment. This place has potential to be a great casual neighborhood spot, but it desperately needs more experienced and considerate staff running it. Sadly, this visit left a very bad impression.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great food. Wonderful service. Always a good time.
Great fresh fish - love the tuna.
Outstanding fresh seafood and great atmosphere at this market-restaurant. Calamari appetizer is tasty + generous proportion - enough for 4 or more.
Seafood was fresh, but waited for 40 mins for lobster roll 😅 loved their clam chowder and steamer.
I love the mozzarella sticks and the fries are really good I love it overall
Loading...