Bought some pre-made manicotti for an easy dinner. Wow! They were awful! Globs of off -tasting cheese with almost no pasta and a little acidy tomato sauce.It was very sloppily tossed into an aluminum tin. This was $19.99. Most of the revolting mess got tossed into the trash. Scotto's , you should be ashamed to sell such half-assed, sub-par food. I won't be back and suggest Francesca's for better food ,better prices and better experience.
Greenman
Food is very good but prices are bit steep
Ruby Ernst
Been supporting this place for over 15 years this is not
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Judian Johnson - Cooney
We love Scottos. They have everything my Italian Mom made for us,25yrs.wonderful Sullivan Street Bread from Brooklyn,on weekends. Great breads made daily. Fresh mozzarella,Braciole,Sausageready to go frozen dinners for our kids who cook on there own...lol. Geneoa Salami,nice sliced thin.Homemade.Sauce,Ravioli and Stuffed Shells...just the best! Pizza is awesome too..xo.Thanks Jack&Jude - Sag Harbor NY
Denisse DePaz
I ordered a personal pie and absolutely loved it! They have a tasty selection of foods and ready to eat meals as well.
Michael Nappo
Always a great meal. If I am on my deathbed bring me the Chicken Francese and some Garlic Knots...
Elyssa M
I've had a few sandwiches here, both hot and cold, and they were not good. The meatballs were kind of gross. The roast beef was very fatty. I asked if they had honey mustard salad dressing, and they took mustard and added water then gave it to me. Disgusting. Place is run by teens. I dont get why it has a good reputation.
A C.
Great food. Nice owners and staff. Really great local option for pizza and italian specialties
Amy S.
The food is always made fresh and to order. All service industries continue to struggle to find excellent help and I think we all need to learn to be a bit more patient in life. I love the staff at Scotto's and I've seen people be really rude and impatient. Good food takes time to prepare. After all, we are only human. That said, any thing you order will be without a doubt amazing. Tastes like what my Italian grandmother would make. I've been coming here for years and every time I'm in town this is a must during our visit back home on Long Island.
I've been going to Scott's for 30 yrs but surprisingly I never had one of their pizzas. Last wk I ordered the Chicken Marsala Pizza. It was the best pizza I've ever had. Excellent! I've found my new pizza haunt.
Andy Seaman
Love this place. Pizza and meat cuts are really great.
Josie T.
I love Scotto's with all my heart. Truly a staple of Hampton Bays. Great quality food and great cuts of meat. My go to is the prosciutto, mozzarella, tomato on focaccia sandwich. A perfect combo of flavors that you can never go wrong with. If you're checking out yelp before you go in - take my word for it - this place is amazing! Friendly staff and a great warm ambiance!
Raquel B.
This place is always great pizza and food! We always stop by when we are going up the island and pass through Hampton bays. Please check this place out best pizza on the island hands down!
Eliana Giraldo
CALLED 1 HOUR AGO FOR PICKUP THEY FORGOT TO PUT THE ORDER!HORRIBLE SERVICE AND MANAGER JUST SAID WELL WE ARE SHORT STAFF! STAY AWAY
Bought some pre-made manicotti for an easy dinner. Wow! They were awful! Globs of off -tasting cheese with almost no pasta and a little acidy tomato sauce.It was very sloppily tossed into an aluminum tin. This was $19.99. Most of the revolting mess got tossed into the trash. Scotto's , you should be ashamed to sell such half-assed, sub-par food. I won't be back and suggest Francesca's for better food ,better prices and better experience.
Food is very good but prices are bit steep
Been supporting this place for over 15 years this is not
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
We love Scottos. They have everything my Italian Mom made for us,25yrs.wonderful Sullivan Street Bread from Brooklyn,on weekends. Great breads made daily. Fresh mozzarella,Braciole,Sausageready to go frozen dinners for our kids who cook on there own...lol. Geneoa Salami,nice sliced thin.Homemade.Sauce,Ravioli and Stuffed Shells...just the best! Pizza is awesome too..xo.Thanks Jack&Jude - Sag Harbor NY
I ordered a personal pie and absolutely loved it! They have a tasty selection of foods and ready to eat meals as well.
Always a great meal. If I am on my deathbed bring me the Chicken Francese and some Garlic Knots...
I've had a few sandwiches here, both hot and cold, and they were not good. The meatballs were kind of gross. The roast beef was very fatty. I asked if they had honey mustard salad dressing, and they took mustard and added water then gave it to me. Disgusting. Place is run by teens. I dont get why it has a good reputation.
Great food. Nice owners and staff. Really great local option for pizza and italian specialties
The food is always made fresh and to order. All service industries continue to struggle to find excellent help and I think we all need to learn to be a bit more patient in life. I love the staff at Scotto's and I've seen people be really rude and impatient. Good food takes time to prepare. After all, we are only human. That said, any thing you order will be without a doubt amazing. Tastes like what my Italian grandmother would make. I've been coming here for years and every time I'm in town this is a must during our visit back home on Long Island.
Great focaccia, meats and pizza!
Restaurantji Recommends
I've been going to Scott's for 30 yrs but surprisingly I never had one of their pizzas. Last wk I ordered the Chicken Marsala Pizza. It was the best pizza I've ever had. Excellent! I've found my new pizza haunt.
Love this place. Pizza and meat cuts are really great.
I love Scotto's with all my heart. Truly a staple of Hampton Bays. Great quality food and great cuts of meat. My go to is the prosciutto, mozzarella, tomato on focaccia sandwich. A perfect combo of flavors that you can never go wrong with. If you're checking out yelp before you go in - take my word for it - this place is amazing! Friendly staff and a great warm ambiance!
This place is always great pizza and food! We always stop by when we are going up the island and pass through Hampton bays. Please check this place out best pizza on the island hands down!
CALLED 1 HOUR AGO FOR PICKUP THEY FORGOT TO PUT THE ORDER!HORRIBLE SERVICE AND MANAGER JUST SAID WELL WE ARE SHORT STAFF! STAY AWAY