This place has GOT TO BE KIDDING! I Was once my go to place on the way out to Montauk. Now apparently it has been sold and Everything Uncle Joe is gone. The prices were so ridiculous I had to laugh. I didnt bother ordering anything as I could see the place had been ruined. If you Loved Uncle Joes... Run from it now! You have been warned
Joseph R.
Best pizza in town, the chicken parm was outstanding, great service and the wine room is spectacular!!!!
Mimi B.
sorry to say, the new owners have really not kept the quality of Uncle Joe's. pizza was like something from a school cafeteria and the tiramisu was frozen. Not going back. The prior pizza maker was awesome.
Steven Easton
After transferring of ownership they don't care about you at all. If you order anything and there is a special deal if you add a drink they won't tell you. 4 plain slices $17..... 2 specials $7 X 2 = $14 comes with 4 slices with 2 toppings and 2 sodas.... way to help out ur
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Brad K.
I have eaten twice at Uncle Joe's. The food is always great and the new renovations have made the place look amazing. The staff is very friendly. If you last visited before they decorated for Christmas, you are missing out. The backroom is warm and cozy with the new decorations. I love what the new owners are doing with the place. I'll be back again soon.
Bridget O.
Ordered a cheese pizza yesterday and ate in the dining room up front. It was the best pizza that we have had in a long time. Plenty of cheese, perfect sauce and that crust! We will be back for pasta. The waitstaff were very pleasant. Very clean restaurant. A real pleasure!
Thomas M.
Went there last night with my family , the Veal Sorrentino with fresh mozzarella was the best, Baked clams with a nice wine sauce. Pizza was great and the owner was very nice. we also had chicken Parm it was really good and large portion. Will be back
Mike H.
I got charge a service fee and a $19 tip for a order I picked up , I had to wait 15 mins after the time they said it would be ready, wont be back , sub par at best .
Bobs N.
Not horrible but....Ordered 2 pies late. I know, I know, dick move, but we were starving and I asked if it was ok first. I arrived 10 minutes early so I didn't keep them waiting. Paid my bill and threw a $10 in the tip jar since they were very sweet about making food so late. As they were almost boxing up the pies I asked for pepper flakes and cheese to go. One of the counter girls, obviously new, asked for here to get them. A more seasoned employee came over apologizing for the additional charges. .75 a small plastic container. .50 for garlic powder. .75 for cheese filled halfway. I'm talking really small containers. My buddy asked if the charge for condiments if we ate there. No, she said. So if we eat there the cheese was free but to go is .75 cents. I paid for that, but I gotta say that's obscene. It's the equivalent of getting a cheeseburger and fries to go and paying extra for ketchup. The goodwill gained by making us a pie at 9:35pm when they close at 10pm was completely lost. In fact now I was extremely annoyed. I let the young lady know how I felt, that it wasn't her and asked she tell the owner. Still bothered this morning I told the story a few times and the people listening said it was crazy too and will stay away. Stop gouging your customers... I know I'm a tourist, but there plenty of places to anting our money. Oh!!! The pizza? Meh. Not stretched by hand. Too much corn meal on the bottom. Not grande cheese. Give it a 5, on par with dominos. Won't ever be back.
Nick Corley
Pizza OK, servers were distracted. The atmosphere could use a refresh.
Outstanding white calm sauce ?!Outstanding baked calms!Outstanding fried zucchini!Outstanding Margarita ? !Outstanding Pistachio gellato !Ashley's service top notch!
Rich B.
I have gone to Uncle Joes for my Italian Food for years. After my experience tonight picking up eggplant rollatini, I am not going back. I had called the order in advamce and specifically asked if the eggplant rollatini was breaded. I was told that it would have no breading. Upon picking it up, the cashier asked if it was cash or card as I would get a "discount" if I used cash. I asked how much and she leaned over to Uncle Joe who was talking to a person near the registe. He said $3 extra for a special order. I asked..... what special order? He said it was a special request. He continued to rant about the price of everything going up and the "special order". I kept saying you won the argument Uncle Joe..... you won because I just paid over $25 for the "special" order. He kept blabbering about the cost of things and then said in a sarcastic condescending manner...... "do you want me to work for free"? I said ENOUGH Uncle Joe..... you won tonight...... but your loss going forward because I was a a good customer who has a BIG MOUTH!!!
Prena G.
I hate to write this review to such a long time staple in our community who has been feeding our family since the 80's. But we ordered an entree, appetizer and soup for delivery at $60.50. The prices for all three items were significantly more than their printed menu and the entree came with three shrimp. This would be fine but when I called to ask about the price differences I was met with a very combative waitress who spoke over me and kept repeating their clause "prices subject to change". I can appreciate price changes but to be rude and not allow someone to speak is very poor customer service. From what I hear, this isn't the first time with said waitress. Unfortunately, we will no longer be able to support this business. My apologies to Uncle Joe.
B B
Sign says "Dinning room and bar". No Bar! Went up the road. (They do sell beer and such but only at tables)
Atmosphere: 2
Service: 2
Demetris Dozier
Uncle Joe's the best pizza spot in Hampton bay's moved here in October and been eating here almost every week the food is great the place is always clean and awesome costumer service this is where I'll be spending my money for sure
This place has GOT TO BE KIDDING! I Was once my go to place on the way out to Montauk. Now apparently it has been sold and Everything Uncle Joe is gone. The prices were so ridiculous I had to laugh. I didnt bother ordering anything as I could see the place had been ruined. If you Loved Uncle Joes... Run from it now! You have been warned
Best pizza in town, the chicken parm was outstanding, great service and the wine room is spectacular!!!!
sorry to say, the new owners have really not kept the quality of Uncle Joe's. pizza was like something from a school cafeteria and the tiramisu was frozen. Not going back. The prior pizza maker was awesome.
After transferring of ownership they don't care about you at all. If you order anything and there is a special deal if you add a drink they won't tell you. 4 plain slices $17..... 2 specials $7 X 2 = $14 comes with 4 slices with 2 toppings and 2 sodas.... way to help out ur
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
I have eaten twice at Uncle Joe's. The food is always great and the new renovations have made the place look amazing. The staff is very friendly. If you last visited before they decorated for Christmas, you are missing out. The backroom is warm and cozy with the new decorations. I love what the new owners are doing with the place. I'll be back again soon.
Ordered a cheese pizza yesterday and ate in the dining room up front. It was the best pizza that we have had in a long time. Plenty of cheese, perfect sauce and that crust! We will be back for pasta. The waitstaff were very pleasant. Very clean restaurant. A real pleasure!
Went there last night with my family , the Veal Sorrentino with fresh mozzarella was the best, Baked clams with a nice wine sauce. Pizza was great and the owner was very nice. we also had chicken Parm it was really good and large portion. Will be back
I got charge a service fee and a $19 tip for a order I picked up , I had to wait 15 mins after the time they said it would be ready, wont be back , sub par at best .
Not horrible but....Ordered 2 pies late. I know, I know, dick move, but we were starving and I asked if it was ok first. I arrived 10 minutes early so I didn't keep them waiting. Paid my bill and threw a $10 in the tip jar since they were very sweet about making food so late. As they were almost boxing up the pies I asked for pepper flakes and cheese to go. One of the counter girls, obviously new, asked for here to get them. A more seasoned employee came over apologizing for the additional charges. .75 a small plastic container. .50 for garlic powder. .75 for cheese filled halfway. I'm talking really small containers. My buddy asked if the charge for condiments if we ate there. No, she said. So if we eat there the cheese was free but to go is .75 cents. I paid for that, but I gotta say that's obscene. It's the equivalent of getting a cheeseburger and fries to go and paying extra for ketchup. The goodwill gained by making us a pie at 9:35pm when they close at 10pm was completely lost. In fact now I was extremely annoyed. I let the young lady know how I felt, that it wasn't her and asked she tell the owner. Still bothered this morning I told the story a few times and the people listening said it was crazy too and will stay away. Stop gouging your customers... I know I'm a tourist, but there plenty of places to anting our money. Oh!!! The pizza? Meh. Not stretched by hand. Too much corn meal on the bottom. Not grande cheese. Give it a 5, on par with dominos. Won't ever be back.
Pizza OK, servers were distracted. The atmosphere could use a refresh.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Restaurantji Recommends
Outstanding white calm sauce ?!Outstanding baked calms!Outstanding fried zucchini!Outstanding Margarita ? !Outstanding Pistachio gellato !Ashley's service top notch!
I have gone to Uncle Joes for my Italian Food for years. After my experience tonight picking up eggplant rollatini, I am not going back. I had called the order in advamce and specifically asked if the eggplant rollatini was breaded. I was told that it would have no breading. Upon picking it up, the cashier asked if it was cash or card as I would get a "discount" if I used cash. I asked how much and she leaned over to Uncle Joe who was talking to a person near the registe. He said $3 extra for a special order. I asked..... what special order? He said it was a special request. He continued to rant about the price of everything going up and the "special order". I kept saying you won the argument Uncle Joe..... you won because I just paid over $25 for the "special" order. He kept blabbering about the cost of things and then said in a sarcastic condescending manner...... "do you want me to work for free"? I said ENOUGH Uncle Joe..... you won tonight...... but your loss going forward because I was a a good customer who has a BIG MOUTH!!!
I hate to write this review to such a long time staple in our community who has been feeding our family since the 80's. But we ordered an entree, appetizer and soup for delivery at $60.50. The prices for all three items were significantly more than their printed menu and the entree came with three shrimp. This would be fine but when I called to ask about the price differences I was met with a very combative waitress who spoke over me and kept repeating their clause "prices subject to change". I can appreciate price changes but to be rude and not allow someone to speak is very poor customer service. From what I hear, this isn't the first time with said waitress. Unfortunately, we will no longer be able to support this business. My apologies to Uncle Joe.
Sign says "Dinning room and bar". No Bar! Went up the road. (They do sell beer and such but only at tables)
Atmosphere: 2
Service: 2
Uncle Joe's the best pizza spot in Hampton bay's moved here in October and been eating here almost every week the food is great the place is always clean and awesome costumer service this is where I'll be spending my money for sure
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5