Hancock House Bar & Restaurant

Overall, not bad, but really only the decent option for food in the area unless you want fast food. The French fries were shoe string homecut, and not my particular favorite. The grilled chicken sandwich overall was decent. The HH burger lacked flavor. Shrimp cocktail presentation wise wasn't appealing and flavor was okay. The wings were overcooked but the hot sauce flavor was good. Our waitress was friendly and efficient. The atmosphere was cozy with the locals enjoying their time.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Very tasty and juicy blue cheese burger with perfectly done golden, hot fries.Shared half with wife...fillimg.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Black

I ordered garlic, parm chicken wings. They were completely tasteless. I also ordered a medium rare cheese burger. It was like eating a hockey puck. The service was very poor.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

Ordered a steak, is was raw, and less than desirable. If your going to charge a good buck for something, you should deliver.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 3

Great food and service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We ended up staying here on a fluke but the staff was very pleasant and helpful and made our stay a lot less stressful than when we entered. The rooms are very dated, a "tubed" tv from the 80's, no refrigerator in the room, and a ceiling fan that didn't work didn't do much to raise our comfort level. However the rooms were clean and very quiet and for the one night we planned on staying, it was more than adequate. The restaurant and bar on the main floor is nice for a bite to eat but stop serving by nine.

Way over priced for this podunk town. And don't even think of going on a Sunday night because the women bartender is a WITCH!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

We stayed here 2 nights while exploring fishing access points along the West Branch of the Upper Delaware River. This inn had a very solid homey feel! This is not a highway motel. The tavern, Honest Eddie's, was a delight. Really really good tavern food, great waitstaff, and just a great feeling in the pub. Our room was large and very comfortable, great mattress and pillows, and had a nice balcony. Very clean and tastefully appointed. We will stay there again.

Been going there for years...love it!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Very well kept, cozy, and friendly hotel. The kitchen and bar were a bit understaffed but they did their best and the food came out in reasonable time. This is definitely the right place to get a good start on the NEBDR - we even got our Gaelic blessing :)

My wife and I recently had a wonderful dinner for two while we were staying at the Lodge at Starlight Lake. The dining room is located in the Historic Hotel on Main Street in Hancock. The atmosphere is wonderful and it is a great place for couples or families to dine

4 adults and 2 children dined in the Maple Room Restaurant at Hancock House Hotel. We started with Mussels in Garlic/Wine sauce (we're from Long Island and we ordered mussels in the Catskills?). The Mussels were Great! After that, I would not hesitate to order any of their seafood. So we were less shocked when the rest of the meal was equally delicious! Barbequed Brisket and Baby Back Ribs are done in a smoker and had a choice of 3 sauces. The Brisket was especially outstanding (2 of us had the Brisket). A Pork Schnitzel in a mushroom cream sauce was also great. These dishes are only served when the dining room is open. If the dining room is not open, then I would suggest getting one of the best burgers you'll find in the Hancock House Taproom.

We were travelling form New York to Niagara Falls and spend one night at this hotel. The people at the recepción were very kind. The rooms were clean and very cozy. It doesn't look like a hotel but the house of your grandmother. It includes breakfast and was very delicious.

Rooms, food and atmosphere are enjoyable

Rooms, food and atmosphere are enjoyable