Magic Bagels of Hewlett Inc

1749 Peninsula Blvd, Hewlett
(516) 374-3384

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Tuna Fish or Tuna Salad on a Rainbow Bagel
Omlette and Home Fries
Scallion Cream Cheese
French Toast
Whole Wheat
Roast Beef
Everything
Sunflower
Sausage
Plain

Menu

Fresh Homemade Bagels
Everything Bagel
Plain Bagel
Sesame Bagel
French Toast Bagel
Rainbow Bagel
Egg Bagel
Blueberry Bagel
Pumpernickel Bagel
Egg Everything Bagel
Onion Bagel
Raisin Bagel
Whole Wheat Everything Bagel
Whole Wheat Bagel
Egg Onion Bagel
Poppy Bagel
Salt Bagel
Whole Wheat Everything Raisin Bagel
Rye Bagel

Fresh Homemade Flat Bagels
Everything Flat Bagel
Multigrain Flat Bagel
Sunflower Flat Bagel
Whole Wheat Everything Flat Bagel
Sesame Flat Bagel
Egg Flat Bagel
Raisin Flat Bagel
Whole Wheat Flat Bagel
Plain Flat Bagel
Whole Wheat Multigrain Flat Bagel

Fresh Homemade Mini Bagels
Plain Mini Bagel
Sesame Mini Bagel
Poppy Mini Bagel
Raisin Mini Bagel
Egg Mini Bagel
Whole Wheat Mini Bagel
Whole Wheat Mini Bagel

Homemade Salads
Egg Salad (1/4 Pound)
Tuna Salad
Choose your size: Quarter Pound: $5.20 Half Pound: $10.40 Full Pound: $20.80
Honey Chicken Salad
Choose your size: Quarter Pound: $5.20 Half Pound: $10.40 Full Pound: $20.80
Vegetable Egg White Salad
Choose your size: Quarter Pound: $5.20 Half Pound: $10.40 Full Pound: $20.80
Italian Tuna Salad
Choose your size: Quarter Pound: $5.20 Half Pound: $10.40 Full Pound: $20.80
Lite Vegetable Chicken Salad
Choose your size: Quarter Pound: $5.20 Half Pound: $10.40 Full Pound: $20.80
Chicken Salad
Choose your size: Quarter Pound: $5.20 Half Pound: $10.40 Full Pound: $20.80
Lite Vegetable Tuna Salad
Choose your size: Quarter Pound: $5.20 Half Pound: $10.40 Full Pound: $20.80
Chicken Salad Supreme
Choose your size: Quarter Pound: $5.20 Half Pound: $10.40 Full Pound: $20.80
Spinach & Mushroom Egg White Salad
Choose your size: Quarter Pound: $5.20 Half Pound: $10.40 Full Pound: $20.80
Scallion Egg White Salad
Choose your size: Quarter Pound: $5.20 Half Pound: $10.40 Full Pound: $20.80
Mushroom Onion Egg Salad
Choose your size: Quarter Pound: $5.20 Half Pound: $10.40 Full Pound: $20.80

Muffins & Pastries
Double Chocolate Chip Muffin
Cookies
Berry Blast Muffin
Coffee Cake Muffin
Croissant
Banana Nut Muffin
Apple Turnover
Blueberry Muffin
Cappuccino Muffin
French Vanilla Chip Muffin
Corn Muffin
Cranberry Muffin
Banana Chip Muffin
Cranberry Apple Pastry

Hot & Fresh Breakfast
Hash Browns
Two Eggs
Two Egg Whites
Home Fries
One Egg
French Toast
One Egg White

Spreads
Cream Cheese
Scallion Cream Cheese
Vegetable Cream Cheese
Butter
Jalapeno Cream Cheese
Lox Cream Cheese
Walnut Cream Cheese
Olive Cream Cheese
Strawberry Cream Cheese

Deli by the Half Pound
Turkey (1/2 Pound)
American Cheese (1/2 Pound)
Ham (1/2 Pound)
Roast Beef (1/2 Pound)
Muenster Cheese (1/2 Pound)
Swiss Cheese (1/2 Pound)
Provolone Cheese (1/2 Pound)

Deli by the Pound
Swiss Cheese (1 pound)
Ham (1 pound)
Pepper Turkey (1 pound)
Roast Beef (1 pound)
Turkey (1 pound)
American Cheese (1 pound)
Provolone Cheese (1 pound)
Muenster Cheese (1 pound)

Smokehouse Sandwiches
Hand Sliced Nova Sandwich
White Fish Sandwich
White Fish Salad Sandwich
Baked Salmon Sandwich

Smokehouse by the Quarter Pound
Baked Salmon (1/4 Pound)
Hand Sliced Nova (1/4 Pound)
White Fish (1/4 Pound)
White Fish Salad (1/4 Pound)

Smokehouse by the Half Pound
White Fish (1/2 Pound)
White Fish Salad (1/2 Pound)
Baked Salmon (1/2 Pound)
Hand Sliced Nova (1/2 Pound)

Smokehouse by the Pound
Baked Salmon
Hand Sliced Nova (1 pound)
White Fish
White Fish Salad

Beverages
Fresh Iced Coffee
Choose your size: Small: $3.32 Medium: $4.42 Large: $5.14
Fresh Flavored Iced Coffee
Choose your size: Small: $3.71 Medium: $4.80 Large: $5.40
Fresh Hot Coffee
Choose your size: Small: $2.54 Medium: $3.19 Large: $3.45
Juice
Soda
Choose: Can: $2.20 Bottle: $3.90
Fresh Iced Tea
Choose your size: Small: $3.32 Medium: $4.42 Large: $5.14
Hot Chocolate
Choose your size: Small: $2.67 Medium: $3.19 Large: $3.64
Fresh Hot Flavored Coffee
Choose your size: Small: $2.67 Medium: $3.32 Large: $3.64
Cappuccino
Choose your size: Small: $3.32 Medium: $4.42 Large: $5.14
Milkshake
Vitamin Water
Water
Choose your size: Small: $2.20 Medium: $2.75 Large: $4.00
Flavored Water
Choose your size: Small: $2.75 Large: $4.75
Hot Tea
Choose your size: Small: $2.59 Medium: $3.19 Large: $3.45

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+34 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+33 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I’ve been coming to this bagel shop for years, and with the new management, it just keeps getting better! The quality of the bagels is top-notch — perfectly chewy on the inside with that crisp, golden crust on the outside. The variety is fantastic, from classic flavors to creative new options that I’m excited to try
April 2025
I recently visited [magic bagel of hewlett] under its new management, and I have to say, I was really impressed! The new team has brought fresh energy and a clear passion for great food and customer service. The bagels were absolutely delicious—perfectly crispy on the outside, warm and fluffy on the inside. It’s clear that they’re using high-quality ingredients, and the variety of flavors is fantastic
April 2025
One thing I noticed was that the new management seems focused on staying true to the classic bagel shop experience while also bringing in some innovative new items to the menu. If you're into trying new things, their bagel sandwiches and specialty cream cheese spreads are definitely worth checking out!
April 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Tony D’s Pizzeria - 1751 Peninsula Blvd
Pizza, Italian, Vegetarian
Little Fu's - 1739 Peninsula Blvd
Chinese, Japanese, Vegan, Vegetarian
Green Deli - 1710 Rockaway Ave
Deli, Grocery

Magic Bagels of Hewlett Inc

1749 Peninsula Blvd, Hewlett, NY 11557
(516) 374-3384