Years ago this place was amazing. Few weeks ago I came into DiMaggios for a couple of slices. Slices were okay. The selection on the counter was minimal the pies looked like they were sitting there all day. Today I called for a delivery keep in mind they have their own delivery service but today apparently they have no driver?! Whoever is running this place now step your game up. Place is being poorly managed.
James Barbosa
Smaller place but best regular pizza hands down with the sesame seed crust . Pizza does not taste salty as hell it’s like great pizza sauce and almost tastes mildly fried if that makes sense. Blows the doors off of 2 brothers pizza. I don’t understand how two brothers is so busy their food sucks. Let’s make this place
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rob Khojandi
Terrible place…sent us two old and wet on the bottom large pies. Called next day and guy pretending to be a manager, offered me something for the mistake. Called again to give them another try and the owner refused to honor the exact words of his so called manager. Then explained to me that it was his driver who I was talking to. So with all that nonsense and a rude owner, I highly recommend not to go there. And by the way my mom got sick and threw up from her one slice she tried to eat.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Robbie K.
Terrible place...sent us two old and wet on the bottom large pies. Called next day and guy pretending to be a manager, offered me something for the mistake. Called again to give them another try and the owner refused to honor the exact words of his so called manager. Then explained to me that it was his driver who I was talking to. So with all that nonsense and a rude owner, I highly recommend not to go there. And by the way my mom got sick and threw up from her one slice she tried to eat.
Nedda T.
This local pizzeria is good. I feel it's better than Two Brothers pizzeria. Cheap paper plates provided to customers. Cheap giving out napkins. Zero ambiance. Food can be a bit fresher.
Zay T Studio
The best pizza I have ever had in over 35 years of my life! I have tried everything at this pizzeria, the chicken parm is out of this world the sauce they use is incredibleKid-friendliness: They do have children favorites like chicken fingers fries and more.
Ordered 10 pies for a party yesterday. The Pizza was amazing! Love the sesame crust! Everyone was asking where it was from!!! Delivery was great and on time!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Niurka Rosa
Got the thin crust cheese pizza ?.. They added sesame seeds to the crust.. Soooo good. Thanks Dimaggio!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Stephanie M.
I didn't even get to taste anything to review. I am so disgusted with the customer service I received while trying to put in an order for my office. and Once I finally got the order placed after 10 minutes of trying to give the information I was informed that the delivery person could not come to this building. I asked to speak to a manager to find out the reason because if it was legitimate I would have picked it up but I received no reason except that he just could not come to this building. So frustrating having to be treated like that.
DiMaggio's has been a long time staple in Hicksville. Even though it's under new management, they kept the quality of the food the same. Staff is incredibly friendly, like having a family member behind the counter. Food is excellent, pizza is still over the top!! However, if you have food allergies, they use a lot of sesame seeds in the kitchen. That is my only warning. Otherwise, there's no place else like DiMaggio's!!! Buon appetito!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
ireneb71
Our family's favorite pizza place!All the dishes are great ??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
King J.
Pizza was trash deliver guy trash he wouldn't give me my change food was 32 gave him a 50 he tried to walk offff 7/11 got better pizza can I give 0 stars
Carlos L.
Great pizza, came in for a regular slice and a pepperoni pinwheel and it hit the spot. The girl at the counter is nice great service. Nice ambiance, they got outside seating as well. They also have Italian ice very big temptation while eating inside
Glenn V.
Hole-in-the-wall pizza shop that just doesn't miss a beat. Consistently excellent pizza for decades. Sesame seed crust is killer. DiMaggios is an especially good choice when ordering pizza for a party. I just love it, and your guests will too.
Best slice on the island
Years ago this place was amazing. Few weeks ago I came into DiMaggios for a couple of slices. Slices were okay. The selection on the counter was minimal the pies looked like they were sitting there all day. Today I called for a delivery keep in mind they have their own delivery service but today apparently they have no driver?! Whoever is running this place now step your game up. Place is being poorly managed.
Smaller place but best regular pizza hands down with the sesame seed crust . Pizza does not taste salty as hell it’s like great pizza sauce and almost tastes mildly fried if that makes sense. Blows the doors off of 2 brothers pizza. I don’t understand how two brothers is so busy their food sucks. Let’s make this place
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Terrible place…sent us two old and wet on the bottom large pies. Called next day and guy pretending to be a manager, offered me something for the mistake. Called again to give them another try and the owner refused to honor the exact words of his so called manager. Then explained to me that it was his driver who I was talking to. So with all that nonsense and a rude owner, I highly recommend not to go there. And by the way my mom got sick and threw up from her one slice she tried to eat.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Terrible place...sent us two old and wet on the bottom large pies. Called next day and guy pretending to be a manager, offered me something for the mistake. Called again to give them another try and the owner refused to honor the exact words of his so called manager. Then explained to me that it was his driver who I was talking to. So with all that nonsense and a rude owner, I highly recommend not to go there. And by the way my mom got sick and threw up from her one slice she tried to eat.
This local pizzeria is good. I feel it's better than Two Brothers pizzeria. Cheap paper plates provided to customers. Cheap giving out napkins. Zero ambiance. Food can be a bit fresher.
The best pizza I have ever had in over 35 years of my life! I have tried everything at this pizzeria, the chicken parm is out of this world the sauce they use is incredibleKid-friendliness: They do have children favorites like chicken fingers fries and more.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian Pizza, Meatball Parm Hero, Pepperoni Pizza, Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Ordered 10 pies for a party yesterday. The Pizza was amazing! Love the sesame crust! Everyone was asking where it was from!!! Delivery was great and on time!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Got the thin crust cheese pizza ?.. They added sesame seeds to the crust.. Soooo good. Thanks Dimaggio!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
I didn't even get to taste anything to review. I am so disgusted with the customer service I received while trying to put in an order for my office. and Once I finally got the order placed after 10 minutes of trying to give the information I was informed that the delivery person could not come to this building. I asked to speak to a manager to find out the reason because if it was legitimate I would have picked it up but I received no reason except that he just could not come to this building. So frustrating having to be treated like that.
Restaurantji Recommends
DiMaggio's has been a long time staple in Hicksville. Even though it's under new management, they kept the quality of the food the same. Staff is incredibly friendly, like having a family member behind the counter. Food is excellent, pizza is still over the top!! However, if you have food allergies, they use a lot of sesame seeds in the kitchen. That is my only warning. Otherwise, there's no place else like DiMaggio's!!! Buon appetito!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our family's favorite pizza place!All the dishes are great ??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza was trash deliver guy trash he wouldn't give me my change food was 32 gave him a 50 he tried to walk offff 7/11 got better pizza can I give 0 stars
Great pizza, came in for a regular slice and a pepperoni pinwheel and it hit the spot. The girl at the counter is nice great service. Nice ambiance, they got outside seating as well. They also have Italian ice very big temptation while eating inside
Hole-in-the-wall pizza shop that just doesn't miss a beat. Consistently excellent pizza for decades. Sesame seed crust is killer. DiMaggios is an especially good choice when ordering pizza for a party. I just love it, and your guests will too.