Nelly's Taqueria - Hicksville

356 W Old Country Rd, Hicksville
(516) 261-9177

Recent Reviews

Enaid Dyob

I’m sorry but the food was not great. Ordered calamari and it was bland and the sauce was even blander. If that’s even a word. Ordered tostadas, they were awful. The taco shell was stale. I couldn’t even bite it. The chicken was cold. It wasn’t a authentic tostada at all. Not that I was expecting it but the bare minimum would of been nice. My wife ordered “chipotle wings” to her it taste like bbq. When asked they said chipotle bbq wings. Never heard such a thing. Drink was okay. Nothing spectacular. Please save your money and go else where. This isn’t it. The music was probably the only thing that was good. Honestly. If I could give no stars I would.

Mary Morse

Under new management and changed name. The food was fantastic and our waitress maria was lovely.Vegetarian options: Yes vegan options but make sure you explain no sour cream.

Jessica Biondo

I was suppose to get a chicken burrito and this is what came. Where did the potato’s come from. The place was a mess and the people were super unprofessional.

Lloyd M.

my phone was accidentally dropped into a sink full of water !! i found "" artie "" on the internet and i want to say !!!!! his reviews are wonderful but nothing like going into the store and letting him do his "" magic "" !! ---thank you artie ---!!!!!!

Debbie Giordano

Just had nachos that were very good and two drinks. Drink was tasty but a bit shy on the alcohol especially for the price.

Ar Sa

Ordered a birria burrito. It was okay-ish. The salsa had good flavor and the consume was not bad. The rest of it didn’t have much flavor though. General impression was grease, mush from the frozen crinkle fries and meh flavor.

Claudia Vasquez

This place looked more like a nightclub than a restaurant taqueria didn’t got in because of that, they had security by the door, wanted to dine in but I went to a different place, maybe if it had been busy would had try to go in but I don’t think anyone was there eating or partying

Robert P.

Went with a few friends my one friend ordered a patacon and was told as the rest of the food came out that they didn't have it he then ordered a quesadilla that had really chewy steak but the cheese wasn't even melted. We ordered drinks and they were over priced. Was left disappointed

Brandon C.

What happened to this place? New ownership? Rice is completely different texture in there burritos. Chips taste like their out of a bag compared to fresh chips a few months ago.

Eelen H.

All I tried were the tacos but they were the worst I've ever eaten. The beef had no flavor, their sauce was a Russian dressing and they used packaged tortillas Their food is not really Mexican

Henry Thomas

Ordered and picked up 6 minutes away from our hotel an order of chicken tacos (3included) a steak quesadilla(nothing but steak and cheese) and a piece of cake. All was wet, nasty and disgusting. Cake was dripping wet and melting, quesadilla was not one full one... it was half ? Both tacos and quesadilla were soggy, cold and oily . Got a full refund from store after purchase. Unsalvageable food after spending 30 plus dollars.... annoyed is the main feeling. Wouldn’t recommend to anyone

hannah anderson

Didn't put the vegan chorizo in my burrito but did put guacamole even tho it doesn't say there's guacamole and I don't like guac.

Art D.

Purchased the Steak Fajitas went to pick up and noticed the bag was very light, looked inside and saw 2 small tortillas, With a light portion of meat I went back inside to tell them it was missing some ingredients , they handed me some sour cream, and I thought that was the only thing missing, turns out when I got home it was missing guacamole, Rice and beans. Also the meat was a little tough. Not worth $21

Joana S.

This was my first time at this restaurant. I generally do not write reviews but my experience here was very unpleasant. The waitress was rude. We ordered "papas a toda madre"with meat on the side. My friend doesn't eat meat and we requested the meat on the side. Twice she brought the food back to us with the meat on it. She didn't care about the service, gave attitude And never removed the meat from the dish. Save your money and go somewhere else .

Rubica L.

Came here for cinco de Mayo thinking we would get nice drinks and food . We ordered papas a toda de madre and a few drinks. Upon ordering we told them that we don't eat meat and to put it on the side. Christina the waitress brought out the food and said "oh I saw the meat" but I'll bring you forks and you can pick it out. Then we said we would like it on the side she brought out the same plate with the meat still on the platter. The third time she brought out the plate it looked like it was picked at and the MEAT was still on the platter!! But what got us grossed out was that she placed the plate on the table and said what's wrong with it and started cleaning her FINGERNAILS with the napkins on the table and not sanitized her hands. To top it she had a sass bc attitude! We did not eat it at all and 5 minutes later she just took the plate and we were still charged for the food; to top it off there was a $6 gratuity charge placed on the bill that we did not even feel comfortable paying.

Load More