Tony's Pizza

505 Main St, Highland Falls
(845) 446-4000

Recent Reviews

Sort by
625debg

We have eaten here many times and the food is wonderful with great service but they are now closed for remodeling, in spite of what the pages say. If you are planning on going there-- call first.

chuleriawr

If I could give a no star rate for food I would. The only reason for a star is that the guy who took my order over the phone was nice and so was the delivery guy. I never give a review like this but the food was terrible. I ordered late maybe because my son just moved in the area and we needed something to eat. We ordered pizza half pepperoni and bacon. It was just sprinkles of bacon bites. The Buffalo wings were way over cooked and hard. The fried calamari was bad. Smelled bad and tasted bad. I wouldn't order from here again. And I think they over charged me. It went from $22 for just food to $47 with a bottle of ice tea and 1 can of gingerale added. Didn't know a bottle of ice tea was $20

Viviana T

Went here on 4/14/22, my daughter and I had a really good time. The boss and employees were very amicable and attentive. The food was just as good. We had mozzarella sticks and a pepperoni pie. Which was more than enough for 2 ppl, we took the rest home. We parked right out front, didn't even have to pay the meter since it was after 6pm. You only pay the meters 8-6. We will be back, thank you.

Sara Kantor

The pizza was the best that I have had in a while and hands down the best in town. Only reason they don't get 5 starts is the mozzarella sticks were horrible.

Max Power

Love this place, great pizza but even better garlic knots!

Joseph Patterson

Well, looks like Tony ran out of pepperoni tonight. This paper thin pizza was at least delivered warm. The garlic knots were the highlight of the order. Oh well, Tony's was worth a shot.

David Hurtado

Use to be good when Sal the Original owner had it. It's has changed Drastically. Someone needs to go learn how to cook Italian food. Pizza is terrible. So sad it used to be very very good.

Marla Brown

Great little "hole in the wall" type place, and that is said with all due respect. Small place with character everywhere you look. Felt like we were in NYC.Dino is adorable, and the food was fabulous: Penne ala vodka sauce with chicken, Eggplant parm, and Chicken marsala. Absolutely will return.

Heidi Coffman

The guy behind the counter was amazing. Family weekend at WP. He was slammed and he had everything under control, knew who everyone was, and was amazing. Pizza is great!!

DickfromSeattle

Tony's has been feeding cadets since I was a cadet in 1970. Granted, cadets are hungry young adults, and mess hall food is not a hard act to follow, but Tony's has been around forever, so they must be doing something right

Dee Joslin

Tony wasn’t there. However, Dino was…

Isaac Were

Meatlovers. Honestly only tasted tomato sauce. Stingy on cheese and meat.

Thomas Kastner

Sorry but when you expect a meat lover pizza, don't bother ordering it from here you definitely won't see enough of it on their version of it!Don't serve the stingy version to the locals and because we won't be back!

Ram Radhe

Worst serviceThey took 3 hours for deliveryEvery time we call they lied driver on the wayWhen delivered- Gv someone’s order to usSince we were unable to go out we accepted it but it was not tastyThey r understaffed n lack of trained staff for handling phone calls

Jordan Mansour

Wonderful old school Italian joint. Food was awesome - eggplant parm sub, cold cut combo, cheese pizza and spaghetti. Garlic bread was on point! Service was great on a quiet Monday night.

Loading...