11 Best Bakeries near Horseheads

“Grandparents 68th wedding anniversary cake ordered. It was a beautiful white cake, white icing with a slightly beveled design on both layers. Only detractor: a lot of icing. This probably wouldn’t be a problem for most people and no one certainly minded terribly. Every was delicious and it was requested a week before hand. Customer service via email and in person was excellent. Would definitely recommend.“

“They did exactly what i wanted for my girl's 15th birthday party and the kids and their friends loved it. The price was great too for their biggest sheet cookie cake! They even texted a picture of it when it was ready. That was very much appreciated. Thank you for great product and great service!“

“EAT AT YOUR OWN RISK- once you have these bagels, you will be forever dissatisfied with any other breakfast option. I had a bagel and schmear from this place 2 weeks ago and every morning since, I am thinking about these bagels. The bagels haunt me. Eggs and bacon at home make me want to cry. I want more bagels. If I gave in to these thoughts, I would have to rent a space in their parking lot to live in because I could not afford rent. If I were on death row, my last meal would include a bagel and schmear from Bagels and Blarney. Truly a local gem. I cannot wait to try all of the options and flavor combos.“

“I called P's macarons desperate to order cupcakes for my daughters birthday at school. I called on a Friday and needed them for the following Tuesday. Every other place i called didnt do the type of cupcakes i wanted or it was way to late to order for them to be done on time. Danielle, even though she doesn't really make cupcakes, was so kind and said she'd do it. There was a red dye allergy in my daughters classroom and she made the frosting pink using dried fruit and strawberries to accomodate that. The frosting was an 100/10. The cupcakes itself was so moist and airy it was difficult to not eat them all. She was so sweet and kind and even delivered them straight to me so I didn't have to take my sick child out in the cold. Wonderful experience with a small business.
The pricing, I thought, was generous but I would pay way more if i had to for the quality of the cupcakes and the person making them.“

“had to wait 10 minutes but we enjoyed fresh hot Auntie Anne's pretzels“

“some of the best desserts come from these guys!!! phenomenal service, amazing food, these guys are the place I stop every week or so for cookies for my kiddos.“

“EVERYTHING IS THE BEST!!!!“

“This little bakery is a hidden gem! The food is absolutely delicious—everything is homemade with so much care. The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, perfect for a relaxing coffee or catching up with friends. Highly recommend stopping by for a treat!“

“Chris is an amazing general manager . He is always eager to help out when need be and plus more . He’s very kind to not just customers but to his staff . Anytime something is wrong he will go out of his way to make sure the customer has the right item and will call the customer to resolve the issue .“

“As soon as you walk into Ma's you feel at home. She will feed you like your own Mother or Nana would. Of course the cheesecake is amazing and one of kind, but there are many other goodies to taste too. She has some of the best wings in town on Tuesday nights.“

“The coffee sticks (which are circles) they are Freaking FABULOUS!! I don't know who is making them but they are the best they have been since the switch im owners. Please continue making these donuts. They are a signature donut from Lights. The cream inside is 👄 chefs kiss! I know many feel the same way. 💯💯💯 10/10 5 Stars“