11 Best Bakeries near Horseheads

“Wow! That’s all I can say about Desiraes Creations! I asked for the cutest cookies for our daughter’s baby shower and was amazed at the perfection! Fresh cookies with the perfect design! Highly recommend her!“

“I called P's macarons desperate to order cupcakes for my daughters birthday at school. I called on a Friday and needed them for the following Tuesday. Every other place i called didnt do the type of cupcakes i wanted or it was way to late to order for them to be done on time. Danielle, even though she doesn't really make cupcakes, was so kind and said she'd do it. There was a red dye allergy in my daughters classroom and she made the frosting pink using dried fruit and strawberries to accomodate that. The frosting was an 100/10. The cupcakes itself was so moist and airy it was difficult to not eat them all. She was so sweet and kind and even delivered them straight to me so I didn't have to take my sick child out in the cold. Wonderful experience with a small business.
The pricing, I thought, was generous but I would pay way more if i had to for the quality of the cupcakes and the person making them.“

“Me and my friend saw this little cookie shop and thought we'd get some and omg the options they have are extremely cheap and all the cookies looked absolutely amazing.

The guy serving us was very kind and patient and I'd definitely highly recommend coming here for a sweet treat.“

“some of the best desserts come from these guys!!! phenomenal service, amazing food, these guys are the place I stop every week or so for cookies for my kiddos.“

“had to wait 10 minutes but we enjoyed fresh hot Auntie Anne's pretzels“

“I’m from Long Island, where good bagels are basically in my DNA, and I’ve been searching everywhere for something that compares. This place actually comes close — fresh, delicious, and clearly made in-house. The quality is undeniable.
That said, $6.18 for a single bagel is outrageous. Even in New York City or Long Island, you don’t see prices like that. It’s a real shame, because if the prices were reasonable, they would’ve had a loyal customer in me for life.“

“EVERYTHING IS THE BEST!!!!“

“My husband took me to the Cakery for our anniversary 12/23/2025. I had never been there before and what a quaint and homey place to do something so different, eat sweets and forget the whole meal. Miss Lisa made the most superb cake for us, white cake and divine white icing with designs with gold in them which you can eat. There is only one other bakery that made cake like this and unfortunately went out of business long ago. Thrilled with Miss Lisa's cake. Seeming as we moved up here from New Orleans my favorite dessert is creme brulee. Unable to find the real dessert I was totally surprised when Miss Lisa made the dessert which put me back to the dessert of New Orleans. So delicious. This was a totally charming way to spend our anniversary, Miss Lisa and her brother were fantastic hosts and that evening will forever be in the top part of my experiences. If you have not been there, go!! We plan on making it a special place place to go not only for the desserts but the two people who made it possible for a unique and magical evening. They make you feel like family.“

“Best fish fry in the area“

“Chris is an amazing general manager . He is always eager to help out when need be and plus more . He’s very kind to not just customers but to his staff . Anytime something is wrong he will go out of his way to make sure the customer has the right item and will call the customer to resolve the issue .“

“Excellent food - great staff - great owners- I have tried many different things that’s on the menu and haven’t found anything that I didn’t like yet. 100 stars“