The Cakery
$ • BakeryAbout The Cakery
Customers' Favorites
Birthday Cake
Coconut Cake
Wedding Cake
The Cakery Reviews
53 ratings
Share your opinion about The Cakery
My husband took me to the Cakery for our anniversary 12/23/2025. I had never been there before and what a quaint and homey place to do something so different, eat sweets and forget the whole meal. Miss Lisa made the most superb cake for us, white cake and divine white icing with designs with gold in them which you can eat. There is only one other bakery that made cake like this and unfortunately went out of business long ago. Thrilled with Miss Lisa's cake. Seeming as we moved...read full review
I worked with Lisa recently at an event in my studio, The Sage Grove, and she is such a pleasure to work with. We have previously worked together in the past where I photographed her cakes at a wedding, and I have stopped in to her cafe for food multiple times. Everything she makes is incredible. I highly recommend her to everyone I can!
Delicious food & desserts, along with great atmosphere and service.
Hours
| Tuesday | 11AM - 6PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 6PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 6PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 6PM |
| Saturday | Closed |
| Sunday | Closed |
The Cakery is renowned for its stunning presentation and delectable treats. The bakery excels in both artistry and taste, offering visually appealing cupcakes and custom cakes that impress. Customers praise its homemade treats, including delicious gazpacho soup and fresh bread, which are considered out of this world. The atmosphere is very cool and interesting, making it a popular spot in Elmira. The staff is professional, friendly, and caring, with the brother of the owner often going above and beyond to ensure customers have everything they need. Service is prompt, and the place is easy-going and welcoming. The menu is changed often, offering a variety of sandwiches, brownies, cookies, pie, and more. The talented chef, Lisa, frequently creates beautiful cakes that go beyond expectations, often including thoughtful touches like gluten-free options that are both beautiful and delicious. Whether for a birthday, anniversary, baby shower, or private event, The Cakery's cakes and treats are sure to satisfy both the eyes and the palate.