I don't usually go out of my way to leave a bad review, but after years of grabbing slices and squares from the front counter, we decided to treat some out-of-state guests with a whole Sicilian pie from Scalias. First off, the service was fantastic and both of the women who helped us were incredibly helpful and patient. They were the highlight of the entire experience.The slices from the counter in the past have always been solid, with no complaints except for the rare overcooked or undercooked mess that happens just about anywhere. However, the Sicilian pie we ordered, along with wings and garlic knots, was hands down some of the worst pizza we've had. We had really talked up Scalias to our friends since they come from a pizza dead zone, and ended up with a pizza that was undercooked, loaded with salt, and just all-around bland and inedible. The wings were salt bombs with no flavor, and the atomic sauce tasted like something a toddler made after sneaking into the kitchen to practice chemistry.The only saving grace were the garlic knots, which were okay.I have no idea what's going on over here, but the owners owe it to themselves to figure it out. This place went from being a Hudson Valley staple to a dump.The low rating is for forcing me to throw a pizza in the trash, never had to do that before.
Food: 1
Service: 5
Marion Miles
Absolutely the worst pizza ever burnt and just a waste of my money
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Russell Vandebogart
The worst pizza I've ever ate in my life burnt couldn't even chew it I do not recommend going here the place is really took a turn for the worst
The Pies Were Flying Out The Door! First Time In A Long Time. We Ordered Online, A Bit Chaotic...However, For A Friday Night Things, People & Orders Were Moving In & Out...Nice Touch With The Additional Parking In The Back Of The Building...Our Large Pepperoni Pie Was Fresh, Hot & Delicious! Thank You Team Scali ✌?✌?Parking: PLENTY Of Parking Located In Rear Of Building, On Columbia Street Side Of Building!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Carol Miller
They said an hour delivery and didn't show up until hour 45 minutes . Called and use excuse then delivery guy said the other driver had an accident and wasn't told by the person at Scalis and everything was cold. Never again
gerald von stoddard
Don’t order delivery here. Almost 2 hours to get our cold food. Cold wings cold appetizers, cheese on pizza already cold. Driver said there was an accident but they can’t call? Please don’t order delivery from here unless you like expensive cold food. Couldn’t be more disappointed, annoyed and disgusted by the lack of any communication, service or the like.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Zechariah Davidson-Cunningham
Don’t get delivery….
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Amy Fisher
Absolutely Disgusted with the food. Ordered a Chicken Alfredo with Penne. I've never complained about food before but it made me sick. it was absolutely Disgusting. A few bites and straight to the trash. I called and they wouldn't give a refund. Bad attitude from the staff. It was literally just a tub of Grease. ??
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
SandyPandy
Sad to leave such a bad review on old favorite pizza place .pizza was dry & tasteless the wings were like Christmas vacation turkey sawdust 2 female workers were rude on phone didn't try to fix their mistake even went as far to blame me for not eating it fast enough.
I don't usually go out of my way to leave a bad review, but after years of grabbing slices and squares from the front counter, we decided to treat some out-of-state guests with a whole Sicilian pie from Scalias. First off, the service was fantastic and both of the women who helped us were incredibly helpful and patient. They were the highlight of the entire experience.The slices from the counter in the past have always been solid, with no complaints except for the rare overcooked or undercooked mess that happens just about anywhere. However, the Sicilian pie we ordered, along with wings and garlic knots, was hands down some of the worst pizza we've had. We had really talked up Scalias to our friends since they come from a pizza dead zone, and ended up with a pizza that was undercooked, loaded with salt, and just all-around bland and inedible. The wings were salt bombs with no flavor, and the atomic sauce tasted like something a toddler made after sneaking into the kitchen to practice chemistry.The only saving grace were the garlic knots, which were okay.I have no idea what's going on over here, but the owners owe it to themselves to figure it out. This place went from being a Hudson Valley staple to a dump.The low rating is for forcing me to throw a pizza in the trash, never had to do that before.
Food: 1
Service: 5
Absolutely the worst pizza ever burnt and just a waste of my money
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
The worst pizza I've ever ate in my life burnt couldn't even chew it I do not recommend going here the place is really took a turn for the worst
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Best pizza in the
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: lrg Cheese Pizza, Chicken Wings, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Dozen Wings, Grandfather Pizza
The Pies Were Flying Out The Door! First Time In A Long Time. We Ordered Online, A Bit Chaotic...However, For A Friday Night Things, People & Orders Were Moving In & Out...Nice Touch With The Additional Parking In The Back Of The Building...Our Large Pepperoni Pie Was Fresh, Hot & Delicious! Thank You Team Scali ✌?✌?Parking: PLENTY Of Parking Located In Rear Of Building, On Columbia Street Side Of Building!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They said an hour delivery and didn't show up until hour 45 minutes . Called and use excuse then delivery guy said the other driver had an accident and wasn't told by the person at Scalis and everything was cold. Never again
Don’t order delivery here. Almost 2 hours to get our cold food. Cold wings cold appetizers, cheese on pizza already cold. Driver said there was an accident but they can’t call? Please don’t order delivery from here unless you like expensive cold food. Couldn’t be more disappointed, annoyed and disgusted by the lack of any communication, service or the like.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Don’t get delivery….
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Absolutely Disgusted with the food. Ordered a Chicken Alfredo with Penne. I've never complained about food before but it made me sick. it was absolutely Disgusting. A few bites and straight to the trash. I called and they wouldn't give a refund. Bad attitude from the staff. It was literally just a tub of Grease. ??
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Sad to leave such a bad review on old favorite pizza place .pizza was dry & tasteless the wings were like Christmas vacation turkey sawdust 2 female workers were rude on phone didn't try to fix their mistake even went as far to blame me for not eating it fast enough.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Pizza & Wings were way overcooked and burnt. Total garbage?. A waste of $35.00 .?????
Food: 1
Service: 1
Best pizzeria around! ??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Get the third Pizza that I getGet the third Pizza that I get delivered and it's
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 5
Old favorite in
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Godfather Pizza, Sausage, Caesar Salad, Sicilian Rice-Ball
Really bad customer service