Guiseppe's Pizza

CLOSED
$ •

About Guiseppe's Pizza

Guiseppe's Pizza is a beloved family tradition in Long Island and New York, cherished for generations. Their original sweet sauce makes their pizza special and is often praised by loyal customers. Fans of all ages, from 6-year-olds to those born in 1993, swear by its unmatched taste. The pizzeria's closure left a void in the hearts of its loyal customers, but it recently reopened under new ownership. The warm, welcoming atmosphere feels like a family reunion, making every visit special. The new owners have added vegan cheese to the menu, allowing more people to enjoy their delicious pizza. Customers love the sweet slices and sesame crust, which they say is the best thing ever. While some feel the sweetness isn't quite as good as it used to be, many are happy to return and try more items. The staff is very nice, and the place remains a top choice for great pizza, especially for those who enjoy a sweet sauce and sesame crust. Despite higher prices compared to similar joints in Nassau, Queens, and Brooklyn, many customers believe it’s worth it for the quality food. Guiseppe's Pizza isn't just a meal – it's an experience that keeps customers coming back for more.