Buttercooky Bakery & Cafe

495 New York Ave, Huntington
(631) 424-4034

Recent Reviews

Sort by
ddiorgio

This is not the first time I’ve attended this location, I’ve giving this place various opportunities to see if the costumer service would be better and it hasn’t, I’ve experienced and other of my friends and family as well this place makes up their prices on top of the head and also have giving us pastries with mold I’ve asked for refund and the guy only refunded one knowing he touched the other and in general it would all be cross contamination due to it being in the same enclosure blonde boy who I believe is a supervisor also always has an attitude towards costumers

Mildred Tavarez

The food is absolutely delicious and the portions are generous. The buttermilk pancakes are a must! The environment is very family friendly, nice and chill.

Shreya Patel

love this place!!

Mark Zaharis

Visited Buttercooky before and enjoyed it , this time on Wednesday July 16 , we went in for a small sweet treat. We ordered the Jelky Cronut Croissant and Pignoli nut cookies . The jelly Cronut was expected to be soft and you could tell it was not fresh , it was hardened , the same for the cookies . I paid $6.95 for the Cronut , Kings Park Bake shop charges $3.00 for a similar , no a better and fresher product . I asked if the items were baked at the shop and surprisingly told no and the counter person agreed that the product was unusually hard. I am disappointed to learn that this bake shop has fallen to the same baking principles as Dunkin Donuts. I was further disappointed that the counter person never offered a substitute or refund. I will not be back anytime soon .

Robert Astrachan

This place is the best! I cannot understand how it is not 5 stars. Great cronuts, donuts, rainbow cookies and strawberry short cake. Do not hesitate!

Maria Ontaneda

Freindly staff

Padmini Purwar

Very good cake and nice place

Neel Purwar

Fruit cake is so gooddd

Amanda Penny

10 out of 10 love the food

Jeff

First time here. Great place to sit and enjoy a tasty treat.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bakery

Iqra Khan

Food and atmosphere is wonderful

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Z N

so delicious! would def come here again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

James Wood

I recently tried a large assortment of baked goods from Buttercookie Bakery and Café in Huntington, and everything was fresh and delicious. The flavors were incredible, and the quality was top notch. Highly recommend for anyone with a sweet tooth!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Ganache, Fudge, Strawberry, Bakery, The Buttercooky, Cannoli Cake

Sara Hernández

I want to emphasize this has been my favorite place because they do an excellent job but this time I ordered a cake filled with fruits and when I broke it it was filled with chocolate. At no time did I mention chocolate to the person who was taking the order and well I am totally sad

Peter Khachadurian

An absolutely amazing Bakery. Tremendous selection, great atmosphere and wonderful staff. Bakery heaven right here in Huntington, I can’t say enough wonderful things, the greatest bakery on Long

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...