Buttercooky Bakery & Cafe

495 New York Ave, Huntington
(631) 424-4034

Recent Reviews

Farzeen S.

I had the papa's burrito and tres leches iced latte and it was definitely a luxurious experience! The latte was definitely catered towards those with a big sweet tooth, and was super silky and rich! The papa's burrito was super filling and warm and cheesy!

Soraida Valentine

Deliciously fresh prepackaged cookies, not too sweet. One pound is $26ish with tax.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Jin Ryou

I buy cakes from here a lot. The strawberry cake and the tres leches cakes are some of my favorite. I also tried their in house waffle one time and it was pretty good. Would recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mona N.

Another birthday ruined ... 4 cakes purchased within 2 months time and all of them horrible. The supposed "buttercream" cakes purchased were so slimy from the CRISCO it was like eating slug slime. This place should be called "CRISCOCOOKY" ...there is no way any butter in these cakes. Keep driving until you find another bakery !!!

Courtni Hale

I love this jazzy little French Bakery on a rainy day. Delicious food - I ordered a Crepe with veggie omelette inside!The coffee is also amazing.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mike R

What a waste of money. Bought a very overpriced Easter Bunny, upon opening it it was cracked and discolored. Paper thin. So not worth the price they charged.

Food: 1

Agustin C.

What a fun bakery to visit! Looks amazing and clean. The treats are delicious and beautiful to look at. The service is great. A must-go-to for holiday sweets.

Jaimie Hoeflich

Amazing coffee shop. The food was delicious and my cappuccino, perfect!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rehan AfzaL

Delicious breakfast pastries! Had the cookie croissant and was sooo

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cherie G.

Always love stopping here for a treat. Great treats, special hot chocolate that's seasonal and sit down area. Great service and I want to eat everything. Outdoor seating in Huntington area.

Anthony Fontana

Love it. Best bakery with 50

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Vanessa Jean

I had my 30th birthday cake done by this place, it was the worst experience for me the cake look nothing like the picture and when we put the cake at the table 30mns later it was melted it looks like left over cake or something they were rushing to do. I couldn't sing happy birthday and I couldn't serve cake I have to pay extra to order ice cream for everyone. We have to throw everything in the garbage. When I contact them they I'll give you a 35$ store credit. I ask to talk to the owner he always always not available to talk I leave my phone number nothing. At this point I need my money back. They don't care for their customer. For almost 300$ cake looks like a 80$ cake.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

Larry

Stale bread and muffins. Third time. Brought bread back once. Not worth the effort. Would give store credit and that took 20 minutes. Today bran muffins hard as a rock. Don't have time to bring back. I suggest examining food before leaving store.

Lisa A.

Go for the crumbly buttery treats and caramel macchiato heaven. They have such a variety of goodies it's hard to choose. It is worth the price; workers are attentive. And there are tables and chairs if you want to eat inside. The place is immaculate.

Ben Kapner

I would give this place less stars if I could. The pastries were not fresh.

Load More