Great food and great friendly service!! 3rd time visiting and excited for the next visit.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rita Moore
Somewhere to go with friends as a treat. Variety of meal options,
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
John P.
As a birthday treat last night , 2/25/'24 . I came here with my son for our second visit , after a 10-12 yeas absence . We did an owl watch at Target Rock and this cafe , being right off West Neck Road , with ample public parking , was a perfect choice . The 3.9 star rating here is very understandable , because Buenos Aires is definitely not a 5 star restaurant ..... That being said , what it gets right is exceptional . My shrimp Empadas were certainly exceptional , a flavorful chopped mix in a fluffy crout . The Chorizzo sampler , Albondiugas ( meatballs ) were given a thumbs up by my son and he regarded the Churros as clearly the best he had ever tasted . Although seating is a little too close for comfort ( understandable when trying to maximize with high rent in a relatively small space ) , the decor and layout is beautifully eye catching . Likewise , the tiny lavatory is immaculate and fairly well designed . Our main server , Douglas , answered questions thoroughly and courteously ( and willingly took two perfect photos of us ). Water was served in sanitary long stemmed goblets as it always should be and often is not , by a very attentive young server..... So , what went wrong ? Although we had a reservation , our greeting was somewhat perfunctory , with no effort made to provide a choice of the 3 or 4 two seat tables available . While my Piquillu ( stuffed red pepper ) was delicious , I had to cough up what appeared to be a large seed ; trimming a small pepper should not be an issue . The fresh bread served had a thick , hard crust for a very narrow loaf . Finally , my Flan contained two potentially tooth chipping pieces of VERY HARD crystalized sugar ..... And if a Hispanic restaurant can't get Flan right , you do have a problem ........ Finally , the bill . There was a switch at the start of our visit from a young , inexperienced server to our veteran who could answer our questions , but one unavailable item remained on the bill , Veal Sweetbread for $24 . Luckily , I caught it ! ..... My son , Francis , will return with a lady one day , and I will stop by this summer for more Empadas and the unavailable Veal Sweetbread after another woodland hike , but we will be wary ( and no deserts for me ! ) !
Katherine Andriotis
Delicious!Delicious empanadas, calamari, steak, and chicken. The desserts are incredible. We had crepes, churros, peach, whiskey sundae, and the banana creme brûlée. Isabelle was a sweet and attentive server and an added bonus, a cat lover :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Churros, Nutella Empanadas
Matt L
Food really stands out here. The waitress said the Paella is one of the best things on the menu. We thought it was so worth it. Our waitress, Isabel, was friendly and on point all evening. I gave atmosphere 4 stars as this has been a busy neighborhood staple for years, and it kinda shows. Don't let that stop you tho, experience was so enjoyable.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jamie J.
We have visited a few times and it is always consistent, friendly and accommodating staff and food was delicious! Clean and well kept atmosphere. Must try!
Mary Spence (Ebraheem)
Very disappointed. Came for brunch on a Saturday 30 min after they opened . Waited for a while to get food and when it came it was just plain terrible. We tried the Argentinian toast and chicken + waffles. The only thing that was mediocre was the chorizo that came as a side with my toast. Had high hopes and this place let me down . An extra star for alfajores that came at the end of your meal that my daughter loved.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
DianaD
Going to make this short and to the point. Entering the restaurant, the waiter had an attitude. Waited about 10 minutes for menus, then waited another 10 minutes or so for the drinks to come back(1 coffee, 1 apple juice, 1 Bellini) It took about 30 minutes or more for the 4 plates to come out. The poached eggs were severely overcooked and I thought I would get 2 eggs with my order , but only came with 1. The waiter never came to inquire if we needed something or wanted anything else to drink until we were practically done eating . His attitude the whole time was rude and I feel inappropriate for someone who works in the restaurant business. My reservations were 1230 , Saturday morning. There were only 2 other small parties there.. so not too busy! Definitely will not be back! To top, it was my birthday !
Emma Anderson
A bit pricey but worth every penny. Great food in an authentic South American atmosphere.
This restaurant has been around a long time and for good reason. I have been coming here for many years. The food is always excellent with daily specials that add to the excellent selection. The staff is always circling and checking on you. The place is spacious allowing it not to be too loud even with a good amount of people. I love the tapas way of eating giving you a myriad of different foods throughout your meal.
Angelina Curcio
Food was delicious and service on point. I had the gnocchi and my husband the paella, which I thought did not look authentic but the flavor was wonderful. Will definitely go back again soon.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Paella Valenciana
Lee Gee
I LOVE THIS PLACE FOR YEARSSS!! THE OWNER HUGO IS A DOLL AND THE FOOD IS ALWAYS PERFECT!!!Vegetarian options: Everything is delishhh!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
HeleneF
The restaurant is spacious , tables are not to close, the food was excellent ! They make a great salad , I had the paella and it is filled with seafood . We shared a delicious dessert, crepe with carmelized bananas and filled with dulce leche. An overall great experience .
Mattia Terranova
Awesome place , the food was great too , friendly ? I will go back !
Great food and great friendly service!! 3rd time visiting and excited for the next visit.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Somewhere to go with friends as a treat. Variety of meal options,
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
As a birthday treat last night , 2/25/'24 . I came here with my son for our second visit , after a 10-12 yeas absence . We did an owl watch at Target Rock and this cafe , being right off West Neck Road , with ample public parking , was a perfect choice . The 3.9 star rating here is very understandable , because Buenos Aires is definitely not a 5 star restaurant ..... That being said , what it gets right is exceptional . My shrimp Empadas were certainly exceptional , a flavorful chopped mix in a fluffy crout . The Chorizzo sampler , Albondiugas ( meatballs ) were given a thumbs up by my son and he regarded the Churros as clearly the best he had ever tasted . Although seating is a little too close for comfort ( understandable when trying to maximize with high rent in a relatively small space ) , the decor and layout is beautifully eye catching . Likewise , the tiny lavatory is immaculate and fairly well designed . Our main server , Douglas , answered questions thoroughly and courteously ( and willingly took two perfect photos of us ). Water was served in sanitary long stemmed goblets as it always should be and often is not , by a very attentive young server..... So , what went wrong ? Although we had a reservation , our greeting was somewhat perfunctory , with no effort made to provide a choice of the 3 or 4 two seat tables available . While my Piquillu ( stuffed red pepper ) was delicious , I had to cough up what appeared to be a large seed ; trimming a small pepper should not be an issue . The fresh bread served had a thick , hard crust for a very narrow loaf . Finally , my Flan contained two potentially tooth chipping pieces of VERY HARD crystalized sugar ..... And if a Hispanic restaurant can't get Flan right , you do have a problem ........ Finally , the bill . There was a switch at the start of our visit from a young , inexperienced server to our veteran who could answer our questions , but one unavailable item remained on the bill , Veal Sweetbread for $24 . Luckily , I caught it ! ..... My son , Francis , will return with a lady one day , and I will stop by this summer for more Empadas and the unavailable Veal Sweetbread after another woodland hike , but we will be wary ( and no deserts for me ! ) !
Delicious!Delicious empanadas, calamari, steak, and chicken. The desserts are incredible. We had crepes, churros, peach, whiskey sundae, and the banana creme brûlée. Isabelle was a sweet and attentive server and an added bonus, a cat lover :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Churros, Nutella Empanadas
Food really stands out here. The waitress said the Paella is one of the best things on the menu. We thought it was so worth it. Our waitress, Isabel, was friendly and on point all evening. I gave atmosphere 4 stars as this has been a busy neighborhood staple for years, and it kinda shows. Don't let that stop you tho, experience was so enjoyable.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
We have visited a few times and it is always consistent, friendly and accommodating staff and food was delicious! Clean and well kept atmosphere. Must try!
Very disappointed. Came for brunch on a Saturday 30 min after they opened . Waited for a while to get food and when it came it was just plain terrible. We tried the Argentinian toast and chicken + waffles. The only thing that was mediocre was the chorizo that came as a side with my toast. Had high hopes and this place let me down . An extra star for alfajores that came at the end of your meal that my daughter loved.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Going to make this short and to the point. Entering the restaurant, the waiter had an attitude. Waited about 10 minutes for menus, then waited another 10 minutes or so for the drinks to come back(1 coffee, 1 apple juice, 1 Bellini) It took about 30 minutes or more for the 4 plates to come out. The poached eggs were severely overcooked and I thought I would get 2 eggs with my order , but only came with 1. The waiter never came to inquire if we needed something or wanted anything else to drink until we were practically done eating . His attitude the whole time was rude and I feel inappropriate for someone who works in the restaurant business. My reservations were 1230 , Saturday morning. There were only 2 other small parties there.. so not too busy! Definitely will not be back! To top, it was my birthday !
A bit pricey but worth every penny. Great food in an authentic South American atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Willing adjust food for me.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Malbec
Restaurantji Recommends
This restaurant has been around a long time and for good reason. I have been coming here for many years. The food is always excellent with daily specials that add to the excellent selection. The staff is always circling and checking on you. The place is spacious allowing it not to be too loud even with a good amount of people. I love the tapas way of eating giving you a myriad of different foods throughout your meal.
Food was delicious and service on point. I had the gnocchi and my husband the paella, which I thought did not look authentic but the flavor was wonderful. Will definitely go back again soon.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Paella Valenciana
I LOVE THIS PLACE FOR YEARSSS!! THE OWNER HUGO IS A DOLL AND THE FOOD IS ALWAYS PERFECT!!!Vegetarian options: Everything is delishhh!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The restaurant is spacious , tables are not to close, the food was excellent ! They make a great salad , I had the paella and it is filled with seafood . We shared a delicious dessert, crepe with carmelized bananas and filled with dulce leche. An overall great experience .
Awesome place , the food was great too , friendly ? I will go back !
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Grilled Octopus, Alfajores