Catch 25 Seafood & Steaks

Food was very expensive and did not have a lot of flavor. I asked about the size of the muscles before ordering and they were very tiny, so not great. It was NYC prices and definitely not quality. Everyone was nice though which boosted their rating.

I have never done a restaurant review before, even after working in several over the course of 25 years. Today is different. For the first time in long time, I was wowed! Finally, a place to relax and enjoy attributes such as attentive service, absolutely delicious and beautifully presented food, along with generous portions. There was value here. Catch 25 has grabbed my attention and it should on your list to visit, if you have been looking to be WOWED as well. Going back ASAP!

We sat at the bar. Staff is very friendly and welcoming. Drinks were great. Appetizers - oysters Rockefeller and harvest salad were perfect. Entrees were large and great quality- halibut and stuffed shrimp. It's great to find a place that you get what you pay for without complaint and leave happy.

Absolutely amazing, James the waiter was incredible we will be back next time we are in Huntington. Compliments to the Chef our food was spectacular. All waiters should be trained by James he goes over and beyond. Thank you for incredible hospitality.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I have been here quite a few times and it has been amazing each time. They honor the reservation so your table is ready for you, there's an amazing selection of food to choose from. Everything is delicious and the service is top-notch. 

We have been there several times and always a 5 star. Not this time. The AC wasn't working so it was very warm. I'm always cold and have an emergency sweater for restaurants. The sparkling water was flat. My drink was extremely weak. I ordered a lemon martini. It tasted like only lemon and not filled as typically a martini is. I'm a light weight and felt nothing. The food however, was excellent and the waiter was nice and apologetic for the AC not working. Hence, the 4 stars.

Food and service was good. The air conditioning wasn't working. They should have contacted us before the reservation so we could have decided if we wanted to eat under those circumstances given that it was still 85 degrees at 7:30pm. They didn't tell us it was broken until we got the check.

Food was excellent and big portions. Faith our server was so pleasant and very attentive.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Didn't expect much based on previous experiences at similar places but was pleasantly surprised. The octopus was cooked properly. Oysters were fresh. Slightly sandy but not enough to lose a point. Butter was delivered soft and spreadable which is always a good sign for these types of establishments. The steak was good. Not excellent but definitely good.

Forgot our waiters name but he was great as well. Would definitely come back.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Went there tonight to celebrate our Anniversary! The food was delicious starting with the appetizers oysters Rockefeller and calamari both absolutely delicious! My husband had the stuffed veal chop with prosciutto mozzarella and spinach the best he’s ever had! I had the stuffed shrimp and they substituted the rice for me with no extra cost! Everything was served hot! Desert was delicious as well the blueberry pie dessert was so delicious! I have nothing but good things to say about catch 25,the owner came by twice to make sure everything was good, I admire that, we will definitely be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lots of places to go out to eat in this town, but this is one of the best. They have a nice eclectic menu comprising of various interesting dishes from both land and sea, and always have some nice specials on tap. Definitely a nice way to end this Mother's Day...thanks guys. ??

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The service (and our waitress) were terrible. The table next to us got their entrees before we even got our appetizers. We had 7:30 reservations and didn't get our appetizers until after 8:30. We were very disappointed, and will not be returning anytime soon.

Really enjoyed our meals. Rock shrimp tempura was delicious. The stuffed lobster tail was excellent. Also had the hanger steak cooked medium with mushrooms that was also delicious. We were so full we had to miss dessert. We will definitely return!

The diverse menu should satisfy any craving you have. Portion sizes were large. The food was well prepared and the service was great. Can't ask for a better combination. Leave room for dessert!!

What a treasure.. a wonderful experience. Johnny is fabulous. Makes you feel right at home. The staff is quick and ready to please. Dinner was delicious for my family of 4. We all had something different and all were very satisfied. Loved the seafood tower, what a great idea!!! Fresh and tasty. Good Job. Finally a great restaurant in the neighborhood.. love it and will see you again!!