Crabtree's New York & Main

Late night egg sandwich tonight was off the charts. Crispy mortadella edges, perfect eggs, fantastic. Best tots. Not ai btw

Food: 5

Service: 5

This was my 2nd time there after living in Huntington my whole life.This spot had the best view in Huntington village.The appetizer were great,the entrees were delicious and dessert was the cherry on top.I love the feel of the spot,the staff were very welcoming and always made sure we were good.I would recommend if you are in Huntington this spot is a must go.Hats off to Crabtree’s.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I’ve been a regular at Crabtrees in Huntington, and I can confidently say the food and service are absolutely outstanding. My go-to order is the strawberry reposado margarita with a tajín rim and the buffalo wings, and they never disappoint. The wings are hands-down the best on Long Island, paired with drinks that are always crafted to perfection.

A special shoutout goes to John, the bartender. He is one of the most respectable, hardworking bartenders I’ve ever come across truly dedicated to his craft and to making every guest feel welcome. Recently, the owner, Jack, stopped by our table, and it really stood out to me how much care he puts into the restaurant and the people dining there. His presence and attentiveness elevate the experience even more.

Crabtrees isn’t just a restaurant, it’s an experience. Between the incredible food, expertly made drinks, and genuine hospitality, it will forever be my favorite spot on Long Island.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I wish I found this place earlier in my stay... Great cocktails, good food, nice ambiance. Perfect for a later night drink.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Overcooked burger . Insanely loud.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 4

Lono’S long sip is the cocktail to have .. ask for the person who created that. Fantastic bartender .. wish I remember his name .. makes the best cocktails in town
Fantastic place . Great vibe and it’s the place to be after 5pm .

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Our absolute favorite spot! It’s our go-to for drinks, apps, dinner — whatever we’re in the mood for. The drinks are top-notch (the Cool Hand Luke is my personal favorite!) and the food is always delicious. The regular menu never misses (the pretzels are unreal), and the weekly specials are always creative, seasonal, and so much fun. The staff is amazing — super friendly, welcoming, and always going out of their way to make your experience the best. Couldn’t recommend this place more!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Absolutely Amazing Experience at Crabtrees!
I went to Crabtrees on Tuesday night with my sister and daughter, and we had an unforgettable experience. The place is beautiful, the food was absolutely delicious, and the service was exceptional.
Our server, Taylor, was incredibly attentive and made us feel so welcome. Everyone went out of their way to treat my daughter like a princess, which meant so much to us.

We ordered the short rib mac and cheese—rich, comforting, and packed with flavor. The steak frites were a standout, especially the chimichurri sauce—easily one of the best I’ve ever had. It came with diced potatoes and bacon that looked simple but were bursting with flavor.

The fish and chips were light, crispy, and unbelievably fresh, and the house-made tartar sauce was anything but basic—just delicious. My daughter’s favorite? The warm pretzel with cheese sauce—she couldn’t get enough!

We will definitely be back. Highly recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We selected Crabtree based on the Google & Yelp reviews. The atmosphere was pleasant and wait staff helpful. Unfortunately, the dinner was almost inedible. We ordered the following: medium-rare cheeseburger with cheddar and side of truffle fries AND the English meatballs with noodles and peas. The burger was server well-done (dry and grey) AND the meatballs were so overcooked that a fork couldn't pierce them. We sent the meatballs back for a do -over. The second batch came back as bad as the first batch. The noodles with peas and gravy weren't bad.
We ordered margaritas with no ice. They were tasty but tasted from a mix; not fresh limes. When the bill came, we saw we were charged EXTRA FOR NO ICE! Charging more for delivering less. So all-in-all, one of the worst meals we've ever had.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Stopped by for drinks after a concert at Paramount. Lovely place, chill friendly vibes. Bartender was friendly, considerate and made awesome cocktails (I had a Johnny Tsumami-Perfect ending to a perfect evening.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Food was good this place is a perfect spot for friends or a couple to enjoy a nice dinner the ambiance is so moody and romantic! I will say our server was not great never re filled our drinks and ignored us for a lot of it. But other than that the food was definitely a good

Such a cute place. Great menu, specials, drinks all unique. I’ll be back.

“Crabtree’s never disappoints! Great atmosphere, friendly service, and everything we tried was fantastic. Definitely one of my favorite spots.

Ate here for the first time. The restaurant is on the second floor so plan on walking up some steep, dark stairs. It's hard to see when entering because it is so dark, but once upstairs you will see a very quaint, charming group of tables and bar with great views of the area - what a surprise! We were immediately seated and service was excellent. Didn't feel rushed but were appropriately checked on by our waiter. Other staff readily brought water, more drinks, picked up our dishes and bill to keep things rolling. The menu was great. I ordered the Tuna tacos and my husband ordered a burger. We ordered beer but they had fun cocktail selections. The tuna was fantastic and the burger was juicy with generous toppings (he gave it a 9 out of 10, would have preferred less bun). I would definitely recommend this place and want to return!

Great staff !! Anthony & Mike the bartenders super nice , always make you feel like family! Their the Best! John & Liam and the whole staff are so welcoming! Jack the owner so accommodating & always looking for you to have a wonderful time . Nothing but positive feelings & comments overheard by those who experience this wonderful place . Keep up the great work !