We had a baby shower for my daughter at Eatalia. Al and Jean and the whole crew could not have been more kind, helpful and wonderful. They were a pleasure to deal with, the food was amazing and they looked after every detail. the space was cozy, inviting and intimate. I would recommend this restaurant 100 percent. W will always remember this event and the wonderful people at Eatalia. Thank you for everything.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stephen Samuels
A very nice restaurant with a nice sized party room. The food is very good. And the service is great. Rates are reasonable.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmigiana Pasta
Michael Prestia
It was our first time at this restaurant. Everything was wonderful. Food was fantastic as well as the service. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Beet Salad, Chicken Parmigiana Pasta
Susan Pedersen
We recently hosted our sister’s 60th birthday party here and from the moment we booked the party with Greg, to the moment we paid the bill with Al, it was a phenomenal experience! The food was delicious, the room was cozy and elegant and the service was impeccable. Overall an excellent experience and highly recommended!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
jon ferrara
I attended an event here on July 27th. I can not say enough positive things about Eatalia!! The service was amazing, the food exceptional, the drinks fantastic, the atmosphere welcoming. If you haven't checked this place out, you should, they will not disappoint!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeanine Franke
We had a lunch for a funeral and I dealt with Al and he did an amazing job. The private room is absolutely beautiful. The food was delicious, everyone loved it. The service was amazing. I can’t thank them enough for making a beautiful lunch for us on a sad occasion.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Eric Castellucci
The service was excellent! The restaurant has a homey atmosphere in a great location.
The food was just alright. The stuffed mushrooms were great, but the pasta and sauce were bland. The pizza was very salty. Wasn't bad, but didn't feel like it was worth the price.
Kid-friendliness: They were very friendly with our kids and had kid friendly plastic cups.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Richard
Posted on Yelp June 6, 2024: Was at Eatalia for a retirement party 06/05/24. All servers and bartender wore faces as if they were doing you a favor, not one smile. The food was buffet style and it was mediocre in taste and presentation. The bar was a cash bar. Mixed drinks such as a Jack Daniels & ginger ale was $24, a tequilla & selzer was $23, plain ginger ale was $4 each (no refills). Total of $51 for those three beverages. I returned to the bar to inquire if I was over charaged and the bartender confirmed the prices I had paid were correct. Outrageous prices!!! I do not recommend this restaurant.
Repsonse from restaurant Jun 6, 2024 Hi Richard, I am sorry to hear that you were disappointed with your experience at Eatalia. It sounds like you were charged the wrong prices for your drinks-I agree $23 for a mixed drink is absurd and that is not what we charge. Please reach out so that we can rectify this mistake.
UPDATE Posted June 25, 2024: Within one hour of my poor rating (June 6th), Britany S. whom I later learned is the owner's daughter, posted back saying the prices were absurd and asked me to reach out to rectify this mistake. I called the following Tuesday and was told Al, the owner, would call me Wednesday. Thursday I had not heard anything, so I called again. Brittany eventually got on the phone and said I was mistakenly overcharged and she would refund me the overcharge which would take 3 - 5 days to appear on my credit card. Brittany said the price of a mixed drinks is $18. I was charged $24 for one and $23.75 for the other. Note, I was not in Manhattan or a Long Island waterfront eatery. Today is 13 days later and still no refund. I had to contact my credit card company to request a refund through a dispute. Also, I was not mistakenly overcharge. The night of the retirement party when I was given my receipt, I questioned the amount charged with the bartender and he looked at a price list posted on a wall and confirmed the prices I had paid were correct. I had told Brittany that someone is purposely overcharging and pocketing some of the money which she denied. I heard from a friend there was another teachers retirement party held there the following week and that some gossip was going on about the high prices of the drinks. I was not the only person complaining. Again...STAY AWAY FROM EATALIA RESTAURANT, 34 New St, Huntington NY. HUGE RIPOFF!!!
Jesse Wemyss
The pizza was tasty, I'm saying that visiting North Carolina from Long Island...I hadn't had much hope going but it was delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Maria Diaz
We had an event here and they were amazing!! Service, Food and the party room!! Staff was very attentive!
Food was amazing with an incredible atmosphere. Everyone is extremely friendly and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Leon Zohrabian
My family and I were surprised to see some empty tables on Valentine’s Day and even more surprised after we had an amazing dinner. Fresh and delicious food at reasonable prices. Best chicken parm I ever had (tastefully breaded with tender organic chicken), crispy pizzas and fresh/large fish filet portion. Service was friendly and quick. Chef knows what they’re doing back there. Please come and eat here for the sake of yourselves and us because we want this place to last and you will too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Florentine, Veal Parmigiana, Chicken Parmigiana Pasta
Sandra A
I used to really enjoy this place... But since bad experiences kept me away for a while and decided to give it another try albeit thru take out. Still disappointed... Ordered the cacio e pepe and found it very dry and bland. I had to add olive oil, salt and pepper to lift it up. The boneless chicken scarp was a better dish but I found the size of the cutlets small. Based on other reviews maybe dining in is a better option.
Food: 2
Justin DeMaio
Food was good. Their arugula pizzaette was phenomenal. The bread can be warmed a bit. Overall a good place, with tasty food, and GREAT service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Kevin Sullivan
I had eggplant parm, which was nicely plated and delicious. The staff was very friendly, but professional. We will definitely come back.
We had a baby shower for my daughter at Eatalia. Al and Jean and the whole crew could not have been more kind, helpful and wonderful. They were a pleasure to deal with, the food was amazing and they looked after every detail. the space was cozy, inviting and intimate. I would recommend this restaurant 100 percent. W will always remember this event and the wonderful people at Eatalia. Thank you for everything.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A very nice restaurant with a nice sized party room. The food is very good. And the service is great. Rates are reasonable.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmigiana Pasta
It was our first time at this restaurant. Everything was wonderful. Food was fantastic as well as the service. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Beet Salad, Chicken Parmigiana Pasta
We recently hosted our sister’s 60th birthday party here and from the moment we booked the party with Greg, to the moment we paid the bill with Al, it was a phenomenal experience! The food was delicious, the room was cozy and elegant and the service was impeccable. Overall an excellent experience and highly recommended!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I attended an event here on July 27th. I can not say enough positive things about Eatalia!! The service was amazing, the food exceptional, the drinks fantastic, the atmosphere welcoming. If you haven't checked this place out, you should, they will not disappoint!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had a lunch for a funeral and I dealt with Al and he did an amazing job. The private room is absolutely beautiful. The food was delicious, everyone loved it. The service was amazing. I can’t thank them enough for making a beautiful lunch for us on a sad occasion.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The service was excellent! The restaurant has a homey atmosphere in a great location.
The food was just alright. The stuffed mushrooms were great, but the pasta and sauce were bland. The pizza was very salty. Wasn't bad, but didn't feel like it was worth the price.
Kid-friendliness: They were very friendly with our kids and had kid friendly plastic cups.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Posted on Yelp June 6, 2024:
Was at Eatalia for a retirement party 06/05/24. All servers and bartender wore faces as if they were doing you a favor, not one smile. The food was buffet style and it was mediocre in taste and presentation. The bar was a cash bar. Mixed drinks such as a Jack Daniels & ginger ale was $24, a tequilla & selzer was $23, plain ginger ale was $4 each (no refills). Total of $51 for those three beverages. I returned to the bar to inquire if I was over charaged and the bartender confirmed the prices I had paid were correct. Outrageous prices!!! I do not recommend this restaurant.
Repsonse from restaurant Jun 6, 2024
Hi Richard, I am sorry to hear that you were disappointed with your experience at Eatalia. It sounds like you were charged the wrong prices for your drinks-I agree $23 for a mixed drink is absurd and that is not what we charge. Please reach out so that we can rectify this mistake.
UPDATE Posted June 25, 2024:
Within one hour of my poor rating (June 6th), Britany S. whom I later learned is the owner's daughter, posted back saying the prices were absurd and asked me to reach out to rectify this mistake. I called the following Tuesday and was told Al, the owner, would call me Wednesday. Thursday I had not heard anything, so I called again. Brittany eventually got on the phone and said I was mistakenly overcharged and she would refund me the overcharge which would take 3 - 5 days to appear on my credit card. Brittany said the price of a mixed drinks is $18. I was charged $24 for one and $23.75 for the other. Note, I was not in Manhattan or a Long Island waterfront eatery. Today is 13 days later and still no refund. I had to contact my credit card company to request a refund through a dispute. Also, I was not mistakenly overcharge. The night of the retirement party when I was given my receipt, I questioned the amount charged with the bartender and he looked at a price list posted on a wall and confirmed the prices I had paid were correct. I had told Brittany that someone is purposely overcharging and pocketing some of the money which she denied. I heard from a friend there was another teachers retirement party held there the following week and that some gossip was going on about the high prices of the drinks. I was not the only person complaining. Again...STAY AWAY FROM EATALIA RESTAURANT, 34 New St, Huntington NY. HUGE RIPOFF!!!
The pizza was tasty, I'm saying that visiting North Carolina from Long Island...I hadn't had much hope going but it was delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
We had an event here and they were amazing!! Service, Food and the party room!! Staff was very attentive!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Food was amazing with an incredible atmosphere. Everyone is extremely friendly and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My family and I were surprised to see some empty tables on Valentine’s Day and even more surprised after we had an amazing dinner. Fresh and delicious food at reasonable prices. Best chicken parm I ever had (tastefully breaded with tender organic chicken), crispy pizzas and fresh/large fish filet portion. Service was friendly and quick. Chef knows what they’re doing back there. Please come and eat here for the sake of yourselves and us because we want this place to last and you will too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Florentine, Veal Parmigiana, Chicken Parmigiana Pasta
I used to really enjoy this place... But since bad experiences kept me away for a while and decided to give it another try albeit thru take out. Still disappointed... Ordered the cacio e pepe and found it very dry and bland. I had to add olive oil, salt and pepper to lift it up. The boneless chicken scarp was a better dish but I found the size of the cutlets small. Based on other reviews maybe dining in is a better option.
Food: 2
Food was good. Their arugula pizzaette was phenomenal. The bread can be warmed a bit. Overall a good place, with tasty food, and GREAT service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
I had eggplant parm, which was nicely plated and delicious. The staff was very friendly, but professional. We will definitely come back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...