I came 3/17 on St Patrick’s day. We got the corned beef and cabbage. The corned beef had a tough spot that I couldn’t eat. Also I expected corned beef to be saltier and more flavorful, as it’s brined in salt and spices for days, but it wasn’t, so I had to add salt to give it flavor. Potatoes were a bit softer than I liked (i prefer more firm) and no real flavor either (i know that’s typical for this dish but could have been boiled in salt water at least) so I had to add salt as well. Cabbage was cooked well but also needed salt. And nothing was hot unfortunately. Just warm. Also the dish was 27 dollars and potatoes and cabbage are cheap and the only costly item was the corned beef and they really don’t give that much. Also I would have loved a piece of rye bread or irish soda bread. Great atmosphere and staff working hard but wish the food was better.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Stephen Sywak
The food and atmosphere are great. The only problem was that the wait staff kept trying to clear my plate!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Shepherd's Pie, Burgers, Guinness Pot Roast
Cheryl Collins
Been going here for 40 yrs. Great food n cocktails.Parking: Great restaurant in Huntington Village.
The food's presentation and taste are perfect! Beer was also excellent ?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Burgers
LongIsland Foodtastic
Excellent experience all around!The food was cooked perfectly, the drinks are great too! Right now during the Christmas season, they are decorated with wreaths and right outside is Wall Street (the closed off road with the large decorated tree, Christmas music, Santa)What we ate:Guinness Pot Roast(Outstanding comfort dish, so tender, flavorful)Finnegan Burger(Juicy, thick, cooked perfectly)Buttermilk Crispy Chicken Sandwich(Crispy, seasoned nicely, chicken cooked just right)This is a small Irish pub, there's tables(small and large), and a bar to sit at as well. They have a large assortment of beers (we had Stella and Corona), and cocktails(I had the Hot Chocolate Martini, tasted like an adult Yoohoo).Service was excellent as well, everyone is super friendly, everything came out quickly, and was cooked perfectly (even with a full house).
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Karen Silvestri (Inspired By God's Beauty)
Excellent burgers and a very friendly place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Burgers
Kerri B.
Excellent experience all around! The food was cooked perfectly, the drinks are great too! Right now during the Christmas season, they are decorated with wreaths and right outside is Wall Street (the closed off road with the large decorated tree, Christmas music, Santa) What we ate: Guinness Pot Roast (Outstanding comfort dish, so tender, flavorful) Finnegan Burger (Juicy, thick, cooked perfectly) Buttermilk Crispy Chicken Sandwich (Crispy, seasoned nicely, chicken cooked just right) This is a small Irish pub, there's tables(small and large), and a bar to sit at as well. They have a large assortment of beers (we had Stella and Corona), and cocktails(I had the Hot Chocolate Martini, tasted like an adult Yoohoo). Service was excellent as well, everything came out quickly, and was cooked perfectly (even with a full house).
Corynne Evans
Charlie and Alex made my night! I was visiting from Seattle on a random Sunday and wanted to immerse myself in the culture. They both clearly love their jobs and are super amazing humans. We sat and watched the Jets play SNF and cheered together. Another regular came in and he was a cool dude too. If you're looking for a dive where you can get some authentic Long Island hospitality, I highly recommend finnegans!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dr. Jerald Feinstein
An old Huntington meeting place for politicians where the deals are made. Goes back many years and has always had the best food, service, and drinks in town.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Christian Torres
Friendly staff, great atmosphere and delicious food!
Local pub with long history in Huntington. Very good food and great selection of draught beers on tap, as well as full bar. Fun atmosphere and great service. In addition, they have a legendary bartender named Tom who is the best ever at Trivia. Makes the time spent here all the more fun.
lynn tucker
Fixture in Huntington for decades. Been going there since college in the 80s. Great then and great now. (And I got my mittens back!!!)
Madeline C.
Beloved family bar with personal team and comfort eats and drink
lqj2022
Plenty of other restaurants with better food for the same price. Price a little high for bar food. Service Ok.
Allison L.
Love this place! Love the family friendly, historic and well rounded place. I like that it is a hidden gem that so many people come to to enjoy their regulars every day and weekend. The only *complaint* is the uniforms do not match the atmosphere. Finnegan's is an Irish Pub, not a formal restaurant. The whole khakis and gingham dress shirts is ridiculous. Coordinate the vibe of the restaurant not the cookie cutter ambiance.
I came 3/17 on St Patrick’s day. We got the corned beef and cabbage. The corned beef had a tough spot that I couldn’t eat. Also I expected corned beef to be saltier and more flavorful, as it’s brined in salt and spices for days, but it wasn’t, so I had to add salt to give it flavor. Potatoes were a bit softer than I liked (i prefer more firm) and no real flavor either (i know that’s typical for this dish but could have been boiled in salt water at least) so I had to add salt as well. Cabbage was cooked well but also needed salt. And nothing was hot unfortunately. Just warm. Also the dish was 27 dollars and potatoes and cabbage are cheap and the only costly item was the corned beef and they really don’t give that much. Also I would have loved a piece of rye bread or irish soda bread. Great atmosphere and staff working hard but wish the food was better.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
The food and atmosphere are great. The only problem was that the wait staff kept trying to clear my plate!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Shepherd's Pie, Burgers, Guinness Pot Roast
Been going here for 40 yrs. Great food n cocktails.Parking: Great restaurant in Huntington Village.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buttermilk Crispy Chicken Sandwich, Burgers
The food's presentation and taste are perfect! Beer was also excellent ?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Burgers
Excellent experience all around!The food was cooked perfectly, the drinks are great too! Right now during the Christmas season, they are decorated with wreaths and right outside is Wall Street (the closed off road with the large decorated tree, Christmas music, Santa)What we ate:Guinness Pot Roast(Outstanding comfort dish, so tender, flavorful)Finnegan Burger(Juicy, thick, cooked perfectly)Buttermilk Crispy Chicken Sandwich(Crispy, seasoned nicely, chicken cooked just right)This is a small Irish pub, there's tables(small and large), and a bar to sit at as well. They have a large assortment of beers (we had Stella and Corona), and cocktails(I had the Hot Chocolate Martini, tasted like an adult Yoohoo).Service was excellent as well, everyone is super friendly, everything came out quickly, and was cooked perfectly (even with a full house).
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent burgers and a very friendly place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Burgers
Excellent experience all around! The food was cooked perfectly, the drinks are great too! Right now during the Christmas season, they are decorated with wreaths and right outside is Wall Street (the closed off road with the large decorated tree, Christmas music, Santa) What we ate: Guinness Pot Roast (Outstanding comfort dish, so tender, flavorful) Finnegan Burger (Juicy, thick, cooked perfectly) Buttermilk Crispy Chicken Sandwich (Crispy, seasoned nicely, chicken cooked just right) This is a small Irish pub, there's tables(small and large), and a bar to sit at as well. They have a large assortment of beers (we had Stella and Corona), and cocktails(I had the Hot Chocolate Martini, tasted like an adult Yoohoo). Service was excellent as well, everything came out quickly, and was cooked perfectly (even with a full house).
Charlie and Alex made my night! I was visiting from Seattle on a random Sunday and wanted to immerse myself in the culture. They both clearly love their jobs and are super amazing humans. We sat and watched the Jets play SNF and cheered together. Another regular came in and he was a cool dude too. If you're looking for a dive where you can get some authentic Long Island hospitality, I highly recommend finnegans!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
An old Huntington meeting place for politicians where the deals are made. Goes back many years and has always had the best food, service, and drinks in town.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Friendly staff, great atmosphere and delicious food!
Restaurantji Recommends
Local pub with long history in Huntington. Very good food and great selection of draught beers on tap, as well as full bar. Fun atmosphere and great service. In addition, they have a legendary bartender named Tom who is the best ever at Trivia. Makes the time spent here all the more fun.
Fixture in Huntington for decades. Been going there since college in the 80s. Great then and great now. (And I got my mittens back!!!)
Beloved family bar with personal team and comfort eats and drink
Plenty of other restaurants with better food for the same price. Price a little high for bar food. Service Ok.
Love this place! Love the family friendly, historic and well rounded place. I like that it is a hidden gem that so many people come to to enjoy their regulars every day and weekend. The only *complaint* is the uniforms do not match the atmosphere. Finnegan's is an Irish Pub, not a formal restaurant. The whole khakis and gingham dress shirts is ridiculous. Coordinate the vibe of the restaurant not the cookie cutter ambiance.