Delicious peanut butter ice cream. Staff was efficient and friendly. All Covid guidelines are being followed here. Some tables are set up outside so you can sit, relax and enjoy your ice cream. Slightly pricey, but that comes with the territory up in Huntington. On street parking, could be tough to find a spot.
Jim Zarifis
Great ice cream. The crumb cake ice cream was amazing and had crumbs in it
Katherine B.
I unfortunately was very under impressed with this place. The service was less than friendly and the ice cream unfortunately was mediocre. I really wanted to like this place because I have heard such great things but I didn't. I ordered the Baileys Ice Cream and my boyfriend got the multi flavored vanilla. We were both very underwhelmed. We are big ice cream people and this just didn't hit the spot for us personally.
David R
Cute place with lots of interesting ice freak flavors. The burnt butter & sugar flavor was tasty. Maybe a tad expensive but I suppose one has to spend those dollars to get the lift. That is the paradox of thrift.
Ellen W.
Possibly the best ice cream in the world. We go out of our way to visit this little shop, which currently does not permit eating inside. We're so lucky to have a Herrell's on LI.
Sarah Fishwick
They charge an extra $2.20 to make the milkshake double thick but it’s like drinking a cup of milk. If I’m paying $9 for a small milkshake, it better be very good! The perfect milkshake is thick enough to stand a spoon in but still drinkable. If I wanted a glass of milk I would’ve went to King Kullen! This has happened the last few times I’ve went so unfortunately I had to make a review. I usually ask the girls to remake it and they’re nice enough to do it but it sucks to have to do that every time.
rodney xxx
One of the best ice cream. So many delicious flavors
Saul Roth
Was excited to have ice cream here tonight for the first time. . Until I entered and met two nasty girls who work there. I kept asking where the ice cream actually was and they pointed to the sign only. Just nasty when inquired about the price ( $ 2.75 ) for a miniature kids cup and about two flavors in a small cup. My wife and I looked at each other and knew we were leaving because I don’t patronize places with nasty help. Went over to Kilwins and had toasted coconut with friendly staffAppreciate the owner answering my review. I doubt i would go in and show my complaint for free ice cream. I’ll change my star review based on the concerned owner
Jorge Parada Cisneros
If i could give this place 100 stars i would !!! This place brings me happiness and joy! The people that work there are the kindness people that you can meet. The coconut ice cream is delicious, it remind me of my country! It brings the entire community together as one! Love it! Can't wait to go this weekend !
Ella Bianculli
Herrells has the most heavenly ice cream and hot fudge. Perfect for a cheat day!! lol. Came in this afternoon and received the most incredible customer service. It is a must-try!!!
Great little ice cream spot! Try their coconut chip flavor!
Brian W.
The best in Huntington village!!
Matt M.
As we were eating dinner outside in Huntington, we saw lots of people walking down the sidewalk with ice cream and knew we had to get some for dessert. The ice cream shop was a couple doors down and had hand chalked menus giving it a local charm. We waited in line with socially distanced spaced tape on the floor and gave our order across the plexiglass barrier between the customers and the ice cream bar. Our order of a sundae with the high definition vanilla ice cream and hot fudge was pretty disappointing. While the ice cream was good and brimming with vanilla flavor, the hot fudge tasted a bit burnt. Overall, the steep $7 price tag for a small single scoop sundae will keep us from coming back.
R O
Best sundaes around. The home-made fudge is perfect
Delicious peanut butter ice cream. Staff was efficient and friendly. All Covid guidelines are being followed here. Some tables are set up outside so you can sit, relax and enjoy your ice cream. Slightly pricey, but that comes with the territory up in Huntington. On street parking, could be tough to find a spot.
Great ice cream. The crumb cake ice cream was amazing and had crumbs in it
I unfortunately was very under impressed with this place. The service was less than friendly and the ice cream unfortunately was mediocre. I really wanted to like this place because I have heard such great things but I didn't. I ordered the Baileys Ice Cream and my boyfriend got the multi flavored vanilla. We were both very underwhelmed. We are big ice cream people and this just didn't hit the spot for us personally.
Cute place with lots of interesting ice freak flavors. The burnt butter & sugar flavor was tasty. Maybe a tad expensive but I suppose one has to spend those dollars to get the lift. That is the paradox of thrift.
Possibly the best ice cream in the world. We go out of our way to visit this little shop, which currently does not permit eating inside. We're so lucky to have a Herrell's on LI.
They charge an extra $2.20 to make the milkshake double thick but it’s like drinking a cup of milk. If I’m paying $9 for a small milkshake, it better be very good! The perfect milkshake is thick enough to stand a spoon in but still drinkable. If I wanted a glass of milk I would’ve went to King Kullen! This has happened the last few times I’ve went so unfortunately I had to make a review. I usually ask the girls to remake it and they’re nice enough to do it but it sucks to have to do that every time.
One of the best ice cream. So many delicious flavors
Was excited to have ice cream here tonight for the first time. . Until I entered and met two nasty girls who work there. I kept asking where the ice cream actually was and they pointed to the sign only. Just nasty when inquired about the price ( $ 2.75 ) for a miniature kids cup and about two flavors in a small cup. My wife and I looked at each other and knew we were leaving because I don’t patronize places with nasty help. Went over to Kilwins and had toasted coconut with friendly staffAppreciate the owner answering my review. I doubt i would go in and show my complaint for free ice cream. I’ll change my star review based on the concerned owner
If i could give this place 100 stars i would !!! This place brings me happiness and joy! The people that work there are the kindness people that you can meet. The coconut ice cream is delicious, it remind me of my country! It brings the entire community together as one! Love it! Can't wait to go this weekend !
Herrells has the most heavenly ice cream and hot fudge. Perfect for a cheat day!! lol. Came in this afternoon and received the most incredible customer service. It is a must-try!!!
Restaurantji Recommends
Great little ice cream spot! Try their coconut chip flavor!
The best in Huntington village!!
As we were eating dinner outside in Huntington, we saw lots of people walking down the sidewalk with ice cream and knew we had to get some for dessert. The ice cream shop was a couple doors down and had hand chalked menus giving it a local charm. We waited in line with socially distanced spaced tape on the floor and gave our order across the plexiglass barrier between the customers and the ice cream bar. Our order of a sundae with the high definition vanilla ice cream and hot fudge was pretty disappointing. While the ice cream was good and brimming with vanilla flavor, the hot fudge tasted a bit burnt. Overall, the steep $7 price tag for a small single scoop sundae will keep us from coming back.
Best sundaes around. The home-made fudge is perfect
Great ice cream. Fresh and delicious. Nice staff.