I stopped by just to check their slices and I had to give it a try since their pizza look good and smell delicious. Not disappointed at all, very tasty slice, I got the Sicilian and the fresh mozzarella, wow very delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian Pizza
Adam Stark
This is my new favorite pizza spot in Huntington, one of my favorite pizza spots of all time. Went from pizza fatigue to constantly craving their margherita slice and the buffalo slice. Staff is kind as well!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
G. A.
I've tried this place 3 times, for a slice in the afternoon. I keep giving it another try because the reviews always make it sound so good. Never again!!!! It has consistently gotten worse, every time I have tried it. IMHO it is hands down, the worst pizza in the Town of Huntington! I'll stick with Southdown Pizza, Little Vincents, and Portofino!
Hlgrm dr
Visited back in summer, hellishly hot inside. No AC! Super loud music, BURNT pizza (black). Bad tasting burnt pizza.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 4
Tom S.
Another amazing meal tonight from Dough & Co. My son had the penne vodka with breaded chicken, I had the Burrata chicken vodka Parm hero and the family scoffed 4 plain slices If you haven't been there by now , it's your loss
Robert F.
Great pizza, they have slices that you can't get at your local pizza place. The pizza was cooked perfectly and they use only fresh ingredients. It's a definitely worth the trip, no matter where you live.
drgoodman27 Goodman
Warm and appreciative staff. Very positive vibes. Amazing pizza.Great place to eat and great atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian Pizza
Joe P.
The owner of D&C apparently learned his craft at Umberto's so I was very tempted to try the Sicilian but Newsday really hyped their "pizza al metro", which is also a different type of rectangular pie. It reminds me of the pizza shops we visited in Rome. Some of the Roman pizza shops would sell "pizza al metro" (pizza by the metre), where they make long sheets of pizza and you would specify what length you wanted based on metres (or partial metres).ORDERING TIP: When ordering a metro pie, you actually get two pizza boxes worth of pizza as you can see from the picture. Each box has 6 above average sized square slices (versus 9 slices you usually get from a Sicilian pie) so keep that in mind when ordering. The squares are a little larger than an average sicilian but they are thinner than at Umberto's so the premium pricing is somewhat justified based purely on size. However, from a taste perspective, I am not so sure because I had a couple of issues with the metro Margherita pizza. First, the sauce to cheese ratio is very skewed towards being very saucy and the sauce is very acidic/tangy, which would not be that bad if there was more cheese providing richness to balance the acidity/tangy. But as you can see from the pics, the cheese is more of an afterthought rather than a co-star. Second, the dough is a bit dense, which I think is strange because it is supposed to be super-high hydration dough. The undercarriage is pretty good and there is a good amount of the bubbles that are characteristic of high hydration dough, but strangely, the airiness through the rest of the dough was missing.Given the owner's background, Ihave to come back and try their Siclian.
My go-to spot in Huntington village for pizza (Sorry Lil V's).Super crunchy slices and pies...they've got some awesome toppings. Lots of seating and a very accommodating staff. I recently came here with my entire family - about 20 of us (adults and kiddos). They helped to get us seating and even served our pies to us.This will remain my go-to spot in the village for pizza!
Eric
The two photos are from two different times I ordered. Can’t trust it anymore. Entire bottom was burnt. Gave them the benefit of doubt and got another burnt pizza. Is there good pizza on Long Island anywhere?!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Pie
Nicholas Manopella
The BEST pizza on the island hands down not even close. Quality ingredients, sauce to cheese ratio perfected. Crunch on every bite. Slices holds up phenomenally. I can’t say enough great things about this place. This is real deal pizza.
Had the artichoke and spinach square pie and the regular Neapolitan. Amazing thin crispy crust, delicious!!!! Best pizza we’ve had in a long time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza was delicious and my companion enjoyed the
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Burrata, White Pizza, Margherita, Sicilian Pizza, Buffalo Chicken Pizza
I stopped by just to check their slices and I had to give it a try since their pizza look good and smell delicious. Not disappointed at all, very tasty slice, I got the Sicilian and the fresh mozzarella, wow very delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian Pizza
This is my new favorite pizza spot in Huntington, one of my favorite pizza spots of all time. Went from pizza fatigue to constantly craving their margherita slice and the buffalo slice. Staff is kind as well!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
I've tried this place 3 times, for a slice in the afternoon. I keep giving it another try because the reviews always make it sound so good. Never again!!!! It has consistently gotten worse, every time I have tried it. IMHO it is hands down, the worst pizza in the Town of Huntington! I'll stick with Southdown Pizza, Little Vincents, and Portofino!
Visited back in summer, hellishly hot inside. No AC! Super loud music, BURNT pizza (black). Bad tasting burnt pizza.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 4
Another amazing meal tonight from Dough & Co. My son had the penne vodka with breaded chicken, I had the Burrata chicken vodka Parm hero and the family scoffed 4 plain slices If you haven't been there by now , it's your loss
Great pizza, they have slices that you can't get at your local pizza place. The pizza was cooked perfectly and they use only fresh ingredients. It's a definitely worth the trip, no matter where you live.
Warm and appreciative staff. Very positive vibes. Amazing pizza.Great place to eat and great atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian Pizza
The owner of D&C apparently learned his craft at Umberto's so I was very tempted to try the Sicilian but Newsday really hyped their "pizza al metro", which is also a different type of rectangular pie. It reminds me of the pizza shops we visited in Rome. Some of the Roman pizza shops would sell "pizza al metro" (pizza by the metre), where they make long sheets of pizza and you would specify what length you wanted based on metres (or partial metres).ORDERING TIP: When ordering a metro pie, you actually get two pizza boxes worth of pizza as you can see from the picture. Each box has 6 above average sized square slices (versus 9 slices you usually get from a Sicilian pie) so keep that in mind when ordering. The squares are a little larger than an average sicilian but they are thinner than at Umberto's so the premium pricing is somewhat justified based purely on size. However, from a taste perspective, I am not so sure because I had a couple of issues with the metro Margherita pizza. First, the sauce to cheese ratio is very skewed towards being very saucy and the sauce is very acidic/tangy, which would not be that bad if there was more cheese providing richness to balance the acidity/tangy. But as you can see from the pics, the cheese is more of an afterthought rather than a co-star. Second, the dough is a bit dense, which I think is strange because it is supposed to be super-high hydration dough. The undercarriage is pretty good and there is a good amount of the bubbles that are characteristic of high hydration dough, but strangely, the airiness through the rest of the dough was missing.Given the owner's background, Ihave to come back and try their Siclian.
Restaurantji Recommends
My go-to spot in Huntington village for pizza (Sorry Lil V's).Super crunchy slices and pies...they've got some awesome toppings. Lots of seating and a very accommodating staff. I recently came here with my entire family - about 20 of us (adults and kiddos). They helped to get us seating and even served our pies to us.This will remain my go-to spot in the village for pizza!
The two photos are from two different times I ordered. Can’t trust it anymore. Entire bottom was burnt. Gave them the benefit of doubt and got another burnt pizza. Is there good pizza on Long Island anywhere?!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Pie
The BEST pizza on the island hands down not even close. Quality ingredients, sauce to cheese ratio perfected. Crunch on every bite. Slices holds up phenomenally. I can’t say enough great things about this place. This is real deal pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Burrata, Sicilian Pizza, Grandma Slice, Regular Slice, Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Pizza is AMAZING BEST PIZZA I HAVE EVER HAD!! This is a go to spot, clean, and so so friendly crust is my favorite! soooo worth it❤️? ? ?????
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Burrata, Metro Pizza at Dough & Co, Margherita
Probably the best pizza around. Very crunchy and fresh and light I highly recommend. I give it a 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5