Cayuga Lake Creamery
8421 NY-89, Interlaken
(607) 532-9492
Customers' Favorites
Hard Ice Cream or Sorbet
Mocha Chocolate Chunk
Soft Serve Custard
Waffle Cone or Dish
Sea Salt Caramel
Waffle Cones
Three Scoops
Purple Cow
Sundaes
Menu
Photos
+54 photos
+53 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Great ice cream selection, friendly staff. Small lot right off the road. Easy to pass if you aren't paying attention. The only complaint is that single serve prices are high compared to buying a pint or quart. Def way more bang for your buck buying a larger size.
Would go back if I'm in the area!
Would go back if I'm in the area!
What a wonderful place to get an old fashioned ice cream on a hot day.
Pistachio is my favorite & paired with Mocha Chocolate Chunk was the bomb diggitty!
I’m allergic to gluten and didn’t have any problems finding options. They also take it serious with precautions.
Vegetarian options: Plenty to delight in.
Dietary restrictions: Sorbets for vegans, gluten free, dairy free too.
Pistachio is my favorite & paired with Mocha Chocolate Chunk was the bomb diggitty!
I’m allergic to gluten and didn’t have any problems finding options. They also take it serious with precautions.
Vegetarian options: Plenty to delight in.
Dietary restrictions: Sorbets for vegans, gluten free, dairy free too.
You May Also Like
Finger Lakes Cider House - 4017 Hickok Rd
![]()
Cideries, Cocktail Bar, Pet Friendly, Vegetarian
Shepherdess Cellars - 8189 NY-89
![]()
Wineries
Lucas Vineyards - 3862 County Rd 150
![]()
Wineries
Would go back if I'm in the area!