Broadway Grill & Tavern

Went there for dinner with friends tonight. I was embarrassed to say the least. I called and made reservations for 4 at 6:30. We arrive at 6:30 and the woman behind the counter seemed flustered and shuffled around to find a table. One of the bus girls walks us to a make shift table built of two single tables end to end with 4 chairs facing a brick wall. Ridiculous. When we said that wouldn’t work we got an attitude and she just so happened to have a cancellation so they sat us at yet another make shift table set up where my wife and I and my friend and his wife had to sit with chairs in between us because if not one of us on each side would be eating at the separation of the tables. Waitress seemed not happy. We ordered our food I had the nachos. The most disgusting thing I’ve ever eaten. The taste of the meat and however they prepare it is putrid my stomach was twinging by the 3rd bite. Tasted like the meat was in a tomato sauce or something and was over cooked almost burnt taste. I sat it off to the side and the bus girl came past with no emotion at all and asks if she can take it away. Doesn’t ask why doesn’t say a word. I say yes you can take it I didn’t like it at all it didn’t taste good. She shrugs her shoulders and walks away with the plate. 5-8 minutes go past our waitress brings our everyone’s sandwiches and says nothing. My friend says did the girl mention to you about the nachos ? Waitress replies no why was something wrong ? I said yes they were horrible she didn’t tell you ? She says no you know these young kids and shakes her head. She walks away and then comes back and while everyone is eating 10 minutes later says I can get you something if you like. I said don’t bother they are already eating I’m not going to eat after them she says on do you want dessert ? Like seriously ??? Nothing from a manager or owner as far as an apology or anything. No one cares. Overpriced food, lousy service and its like they are doing you a favor. If these kids as she says don’t have a clue they shouldn’t have interaction with customers. I will never step foot in there again and I will make sure I tell anyone I know not to go there either. Should have stuck with going to Johnny Paisanos instead as we always are guaranteed a good meal and even a hello form Johnny while youre eating. I did stop at Imperial Pizza on the way home and got myself a pizza so at least I ate tonight.

One of the best bars in Westchester.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nice local hangout, beer was super cold and frosty, place was super local and friendly!

Atmosphere: 4

Service: 5

Capably handled 14 unannounced hikers and did a great job servicing. Food was well prepared. Hikers consider this as an option

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

My wife and I stopped in here on Memorial day. I am not entirely sure we did not interrupt a private celebration, but the bartender and the people where very welcoming and they had some free delicious food in celebration of the day. I think that was the best potato salad I have ever had. Thank you for sharing and caring!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

4 beers , burger, it was 45, including tip. Great bar, very nice people. Would recommend it around the area. Would come again if I can! Bartender Smith introduced him self to me.

Bartender was an OG, great place for a mid-day beer. Great prices, even in 2025. Would return whenever I’m near

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Wasted my time calling this place 2x when it said open till 2AM.. why did I call?
To ask where one can view their menus. No website not even a landline phone number only google voice no one answers… hopfully this place is closed for good. I’ll make recommendations to google to Permanently remove this scam Listing

Service: 1

A gem of its kind, this old bar has been restored and maintained lovingly. The bartender does it proud. We had a wonderful time and will be back when we’re in the area. Wish they were closer!

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

People were pretty nice but $20 for a High Noon? Never again will I step in foot here! My bar tab was less at Hudson Prime! Robbery, shame on you!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 4

Local bar, didn't have anything to eat there. Just drinks and watched a sporting event. It was ok.

Atmosphere: 3

Service: 4

Great little place! Food was excellent, beer is cold and the guy rubbing the place did everything! Bartender, cook, dishwasher, bus boy and all with a smile!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

-LastOfRKind Reviewz

Great bartender! Nice little bar. Good beer on tap

Atmosphere: 4

Service: 5

So fun!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wings