Very good pizza. We were coming home from the Yankee game and this place gives you NYC pizza without having to trek into the City. Not many tables, more of an informal spot, but the owner is right there cooking delicious Brooklyn style pizza.
John IsCool
Great pizza. Nothing better in the area.Kid-friendliness: Loves the school kids, always happy.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: BBQ Chicken, Cheese Pizza
Gabriel V.
2/21/2024 Absolutely horrible. waited 2 hours for my food, had to call after 1.5 hours for them to say, " it was on the way". 30 minutes later it arrived everything was cold; the burger bread was soggy from sitting the patty was cold. My fried raviolis were cold as well. and I never got my coke. I called back to ask for a refund and was denied, so $30 went right into the trash. please if you read this don't waste your time. The Owner should refund me, but whoever was running the place that day, failed at his job.
ApatheticBroadcast
I’m an Uber eats driver. I never review places strictly on service but the other reviews here are spot on. I came in to pick up an order for delivery and was told it would be about five minutes. No big deal. Then the guy tells me they haven’t started it because drivers will come to pick up and then leave because it’s not ready. (Uber eats lets you cancel a job if the wait time is excessive, which usually means over a few minutes in my experience. This is because in most cases Uber eats doesn’t pay hourly, they pay by delivery, so why wait for a job if it’s time you could be using to complete other jobs? Pay rate does not increase if you have to wait). Apparently every time a driver would come in and leave they’d stop making the order (the guy told me this) so they’re not doing themselves any favors. As I sit here writing this it’s been 22 minutes. Three other people have come and gone with their food, and not just slices in the case. At least the food’s fresh I guess.By the way, the delivery app warned me to double check the items as they apparently frequently forget stuff.
Service: 1
RJ Q3
Pizza is that classic football pizza that is really good where the sauce is the star. Calzones are delicious to with the ricotta and mozzarella blend perfectly together and remains light not too heavy. Its small inside so take or delivery is recommended.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Samantha G.
We paid extra for a margarita pizza and we got a cheese pizza with chopped basil on it. While i was waiting i saw them take my pizza out of the oven, put it in the box, left the box open and answered the phone for 5 mins until someone else had to come and finish the pizza. By the time we got home we had to reheat it. Disappointed and frustrated that we didn't get the pizza we expected.
Marc S.
I feel qualified to give an opinion on pizza having grown up in Brooklyn during the 70s to the 90s. Tony's pizza reminds me very much of the pizza I grew up in. Crisp crust, tasty sauce and cheese. In my world, it doesn't get much better. Order and enjoy from them!
Nineteen Eightyfour
Very good regular and Sicilian slice.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tony's Pizza, Cheese Pizza
Analicia G.
Went out looking for late night pizza and this definitely satisfied all cravings! Food was made fresh in front of us, even made us a special slice to try (BBQ chicken & Mac-n-cheese). Amazingggg
Nakcole Simpson
Thank you very much ? ☺️. The chicken tenders and fries are my favorite...blue cheese and BBQ sauce. Thank you so much tony for making my lunch choice nr favorite.
Was visiting from California with my family for a medical conference and looking for a true NY pizza experience. I wasn't expecting much, being outside in the suburbs, but let me tell you Tony's absolutely delivered. The pizza was EXCELLENT, service was above and beyond, and the owner went out of his way to make sure my 6yo daughter, who is in a wheelchair, was accommodated with the seating. I will say there was only enough seating for a family or two, but we were lucky enough to secure a table. We also got some warm, fresh cookies for the hell of it. Also delicious.Loved this place so much I am leaving a review over a year later. If I ever get back to New York, I'm heading here ASAP.
Allison P.
We love this place. The chicken fajita pizza really rocks. Everything is great. Great customer service.
Juan Muriel
Tony and his staff have the best chicken ceasar salads!We look forward to ordering from them. Every time, a great quality meal.
Never had a worse customer service experience in my life. Called an hour after I place my order just to check in (1 large pizza, 10min from my house). The system was down so my order hadn’t gone through, good thing I called! They said it would be another 45min. I asked if I could get some sort of discount for the inconvenience and they laughed at me and said “no, other orders have arrived much later than this”….Don’t order here if you’re hungry lol!!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
H3LLHAWK
I ordered pizza and it was over 2hrs late and cold. The owners didn’t care or offer a discount or refund. Might as well buy frozen pizza next time. Definitely will taste
Very good pizza. We were coming home from the Yankee game and this place gives you NYC pizza without having to trek into the City. Not many tables, more of an informal spot, but the owner is right there cooking delicious Brooklyn style pizza.
Great pizza. Nothing better in the area.Kid-friendliness: Loves the school kids, always happy.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: BBQ Chicken, Cheese Pizza
2/21/2024 Absolutely horrible. waited 2 hours for my food, had to call after 1.5 hours for them to say, " it was on the way". 30 minutes later it arrived everything was cold; the burger bread was soggy from sitting the patty was cold. My fried raviolis were cold as well. and I never got my coke. I called back to ask for a refund and was denied, so $30 went right into the trash. please if you read this don't waste your time. The Owner should refund me, but whoever was running the place that day, failed at his job.
I’m an Uber eats driver. I never review places strictly on service but the other reviews here are spot on. I came in to pick up an order for delivery and was told it would be about five minutes. No big deal. Then the guy tells me they haven’t started it because drivers will come to pick up and then leave because it’s not ready. (Uber eats lets you cancel a job if the wait time is excessive, which usually means over a few minutes in my experience. This is because in most cases Uber eats doesn’t pay hourly, they pay by delivery, so why wait for a job if it’s time you could be using to complete other jobs? Pay rate does not increase if you have to wait). Apparently every time a driver would come in and leave they’d stop making the order (the guy told me this) so they’re not doing themselves any favors. As I sit here writing this it’s been 22 minutes. Three other people have come and gone with their food, and not just slices in the case. At least the food’s fresh I guess.By the way, the delivery app warned me to double check the items as they apparently frequently forget stuff.
Service: 1
Pizza is that classic football pizza that is really good where the sauce is the star. Calzones are delicious to with the ricotta and mozzarella blend perfectly together and remains light not too heavy. Its small inside so take or delivery is recommended.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
We paid extra for a margarita pizza and we got a cheese pizza with chopped basil on it. While i was waiting i saw them take my pizza out of the oven, put it in the box, left the box open and answered the phone for 5 mins until someone else had to come and finish the pizza. By the time we got home we had to reheat it. Disappointed and frustrated that we didn't get the pizza we expected.
I feel qualified to give an opinion on pizza having grown up in Brooklyn during the 70s to the 90s. Tony's pizza reminds me very much of the pizza I grew up in. Crisp crust, tasty sauce and cheese. In my world, it doesn't get much better. Order and enjoy from them!
Very good regular and Sicilian slice.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tony's Pizza, Cheese Pizza
Went out looking for late night pizza and this definitely satisfied all cravings! Food was made fresh in front of us, even made us a special slice to try (BBQ chicken & Mac-n-cheese). Amazingggg
Thank you very much ? ☺️. The chicken tenders and fries are my favorite...blue cheese and BBQ sauce. Thank you so much tony for making my lunch choice nr favorite.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Was visiting from California with my family for a medical conference and looking for a true NY pizza experience. I wasn't expecting much, being outside in the suburbs, but let me tell you Tony's absolutely delivered. The pizza was EXCELLENT, service was above and beyond, and the owner went out of his way to make sure my 6yo daughter, who is in a wheelchair, was accommodated with the seating. I will say there was only enough seating for a family or two, but we were lucky enough to secure a table. We also got some warm, fresh cookies for the hell of it. Also delicious.Loved this place so much I am leaving a review over a year later. If I ever get back to New York, I'm heading here ASAP.
We love this place. The chicken fajita pizza really rocks. Everything is great. Great customer service.
Tony and his staff have the best chicken ceasar salads!We look forward to ordering from them. Every time, a great quality meal.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatball Parm Wedge Sandwich, Cheese Pizza
Never had a worse customer service experience in my life. Called an hour after I place my order just to check in (1 large pizza, 10min from my house). The system was down so my order hadn’t gone through, good thing I called! They said it would be another 45min. I asked if I could get some sort of discount for the inconvenience and they laughed at me and said “no, other orders have arrived much later than this”….Don’t order here if you’re hungry lol!!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
I ordered pizza and it was over 2hrs late and cold. The owners didn’t care or offer a discount or refund. Might as well buy frozen pizza next time. Definitely will taste
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1