Jimmy Hays Steak House

4310 Austin Blvd, Island Park
(516) 432-5155

Recent Reviews

Customers' Favorites

Two Double Thick American Loin Lamb Chops

Medallions of Filet Mignon Au Poivre

Medallions of Filet Mignon

Steak for 4 and Potatoes

Garlic Mashed Potatoes

Chicken Scarpariello

Caramel Fudge Sundae

Creamed Spinach

Beef Wellington

Lobster Bisque

Photos

+30 photos

+29 photos

Add a photo

Recent Reviews

The place is fine and the front of house staff is nice, but 1. The they didn't refill my empty water glass the whole night, even when paying. They didn't miss asking if I wanted another cocktail, 2. My dad asked for the chop steak, which is easy for him to eat, and the waiter claimed they couldn't make it. My dad said it's just hamburger meat, grind a filet. The waiter walked into the kitchen, came back and said no. Why have it on the menu? If it were up to...

September 2025

This is the true definition of high class. From the moment you walk in, the staff welcomes you like royalty—it instantly makes you feel like you’ve stepped somewhere divine. The atmosphere is elegant, yet warm and inviting, the kind of place that makes every visit feel special.

The menu is absolutely amazing. Honestly, the steak is incredible, but it’s not even the best part—the appetizers truly steal the show. The lobster bisque tastes like gold, it’s...

August 2025

What a fabulous steak house. From walking in the door to leaving after dinner it was truly a welcoming experience. The atmosphere was warm, cozy and relaxing. It was our first time to Jimmy Hays. We ordered the Rib Eye for two and the Shrimp Hays, side of spinach for 3 to share. Both dinners were perfectly cooked, served hot and the service was outstanding by the waiter. I love that when we finished our dinner, the bus was attentive and cleared our dishes immediately without...

August 2025

More Reviews

Restaurants in Island Park, NY

Jimmy Hays Steak House

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Jimmy Hays Steak House