New York Bagel Co
1716 Veterans Memorial Hwy, Islandia
(631) 630-0547
Customers' Favorites
Bagel with Cream Cheese and Coffee
Everything Bagel
Whole Wheat
Bagels Freshly Baked Daily on Premises
Onion Bagel
Everything Bagel
Plain Bagel
Egg Everything Bagel
Cinnamon Raisin Bagel
Sesame Bagel
Egg Bagel
Whole Wheat Everything Bagel
Salt Bagel
Garlic Bagel
Bialys Bagel
Whole Wheat Bagel
Sunflower Bagel
Poppy Bagel
Bagel or Roll
Bagel or Roll with Butter
Bagel or roll with Butter Choose your bagel
Bagel or Roll with Plain Cream cheese
Choose your bagel
Bagel or Roll With Flavored Cream Cheese
Choose you type bagel and flavor of Cream Cheese
Pastries
Blueberry Crumb Muffin
Brownie
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Sprinkle Cookie
Croissant
Red Velvet Muffin
Banana Chip Muffin
Chocolate Chip Muffin
Lemon Poppy Muffin
Apple Turnover
Corn Murrin
Pistachio Muffin
Black and White Cookie
Bran Muffin
Grand Slam
3 Eggs, Bacon, Sausage, Ham, and a Cheese on a Hero
Breakfast Platters
Pancakes
Your choice of bacon, ham, or sausage.
Western Omelet
3 eggs, peppers, ham, and onions.
French Toast
Your choice of bacon, ham, or sausage.
Omelet
Create your omelet. 3 eggs, any one meat, cheese, and vegetables.
Veggie Omelet
3 eggs, tomatoes, onions, green peppers, and cheese.
Original Sandwiches
Chicken Salad Sandwich
Chicken salad on your choice of bagel. All sandwiches are served with a side of macaroni, potato, or cole slaw.
BLT Sandwich
Bacon, lettuce, and tomatoes in your choice of bagel. All sandwiches are served with a side of macaroni, potato, or cole slaw.
Roast Beef Sandwich
Roast beef on your choice of bagel. All sandwiches are served with a side of macaroni, potato, or cole slaw.
Tuna Salad Sandwich
Tuna salad on your choice of bagel. All sandwiches are served with a side of macaroni, potato, or cole slaw.
Egg Salad Sandwich
Egg salad on your choice of bagel. All sandwiches are served with a side of macaroni, potato, or cole slaw.
Bologna Sandwich
Bologna sandwich on your choice of bagel. All sandwiches are served with a side of macaroni, potato, or cole slaw.
Oven Gold Turkey Sandwich
Oven gold turkey on your choice of bagel. All sandwiches are served with a side of macaroni, potato, or cole slaw.
Ham Sandwich
Ham on your choice of bagel. All sandwiches are served with a side of macaroni, potato, or cole slaw.
Pastrami Sandwich
Pastrami on your choice of bagel. All sandwiches are served with a side of macaroni, potato, or cole slaw.
Cheese Sandwich
American cheese sandwich on your choice of bagel. All sandwiches are served with a side of macaroni, potato, or cole slaw.
New Yorks Finest Specialty Sandwiches
Times Square
Turkey, bacon, American cheese, lettuce, and tomato on a parmesan toasted roll.
5 Boroughs
Roast beef, turkey, ham, American, and muenster cheese with mayo on a hero.
Bronx Bomber
Breaded chicken cutlet with melted mozzarella on a roll.
Broadway
Turkey and swiss with honey mustard on whole wheat toast.
Little Italy
Ham, salami, pepperoni, and provolone with lettuce, tomato, oil, and vinegar on a hero.
Verranzano
Chicken salad with bacon melted swiss cheese on your choice of bagel.
Park Ave
Hot roast beef with melted cheddar on a toasted garlic roll.
Manhatten
Grilled chicken with pepper jack cheese on a toasted garlic roll.
Cross Island
Pastrami with swiss cheese, sauerkraut, mustard, and butter on toasted rye bread.
Pizza Bagel
Pizza bagel on your choice of bagel.
The Metropolitan
Chicken salad with lettuce and tomato on toasted white bread.
White Stone
Tuna with lettuce and tomato on a tested white bread.
Lincoln
Grilled roast beef w/ onions and melted provolone or American cheese on a hero.
GW
Honey maple turkey with swiss cheese, lettuce, and tomato on pita bread.
Rockefeller
Grilled ham and American cheese on a fresh baked croissant with honey mustard dressing.
Salads
Central Park Ceaser Salad
Crisp romaine lettuce with grilled chicken, croutons, and freshly grated parmesan cheese. Served with your classic caesar dressing. Our fresh made to order salads.
Triborough Salad
Chicken, tuna, and egg salad served over a bed of lettuce with sliced tomatoes. Our fresh made-to-order salads.
Grand Central Park Salad
Your classic garden salad loaded bumper to bumper with crisp romaine lettuce, sliced tomatoes, croutons, onions, and your choice of salad dressing
Wall Street Chef Salad
Crisp romaine lettuce with sliced ham, turkey, american, swiss cheese and hard boiled egg with your choice of dressing
Empire Breaded Chicken Salad
Breaded chicken, sliced tomatoes and shredded cheese served over a bed of romaine lettuce with your choice of dressing
Beverages
Ice Tea
Coffee (16 oz)
Pint Trop. OJ
Lemon Snapple
Peach Snapple
Ginger Ale
Iced Coffee
Coke
Chocolate Quick
Dt. Peach Snapple
Sprite
Orange Soda
Tea (16 oz)
Pepsi
Sport Water
Snapple Apple
Trop OJ (1/2 Gal)
Grape Snapple
Strawberry Quick
Dt. Coke
Dt. Lemon Snapple
Dt. Pepsi
Cream Cheese Flavors (1/2 lb.)
Plain
Strawberry
Garden Vegetable
Scallion
Walnut Raisin
Olive
Lox Spread
Breakfast Specials Served all day
2 Eggs with Cheese
2 Eggs
Photos
+12 photos
+11 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Nobody answers the phone when trying to make an order, this has happened to me several times over the past few months, it sucks because they actually make good breakfast sandwiches.
February 2025
This is a nice friendly breakfast spot. Great bacon, egg & cheese sandwich on an everything twist this morning! I have been going to this place for several years and I am always happy with my breakfast sandwich. I'm in and out in less than 8 minutes. Good flavorful sandwich, with crispy bacon, and soft bagel. Every time I go to Dunkin up the road because it's across from my office, I'm disappointed and delayed. Yesterday at Dunkin, it took 20 minutes for me...
November 2023
Food is good. But they need to hire front counter ppl that understand the basics. this is the second time my order is wrong. On a slow morning, I asked for lunch sandwich with mustard. She said “sauce?” … Confused, I said “uhh, mustard. the condiment”. but my sandwich ended up with Italian dressing. Another time I asked for “ham and turkey” and they kept writing/saying “hot”. I said ham like 8times and still I got a hot turkey sandwich - which was corrected while...
August 2023
You May Also Like
Mugi Sushi Hibachi And Bar - 1708 Veterans Memorial Hwy
![]()
Sushi, Sushi Bar, Japanese, Vegetarian
Islandia Buffet - 1704 Veterans Memorial Hwy
![]()
Chinese, Asian Fusion, Vegetarian
subway - 1714 Veterans Memorial Hwy
![]()
Fast Food, Sandwich Shop