Restaurants near Islandia

Browse menus, reviews and photos of the best places to eat near Islandia.

Showing 30 of 30 restaurants

Cafe · $
1 The Stuffed American (Hidden Gem)

4.9 Superb 175 Reviews

Lower Level of Building, 275 Broadhollow Road, Melville
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Orchard Turkey Panini
- Chicken Classic Wrap
- Philly Cheese Steak
- Pressed Italian
“We worked the same event yesterday and I knew right away I would be visiting them for my lunch! So amazing and the ladies were super friendly! I tried the Taco, Bacon Mac & Cheese, Philly Cheesesteak, and Banana Nutella. I Hope to see them at another event soon so I can try the other flavors (I heard the spinach artichoke is a must have!)”
Menu Order
Pizza · $
2 La Slice Pizzeria

4.3 Superb 275 Reviews

1826 Veterans Memorial Highway, Islandia
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Garlic Knots
- Regular Slice
- Empanadas
- Chicken Bacon Ranch
“Both round and square.”
Menu Order
Bar · $$
3 Dave & Buster's Islandia

4.1 Good 544 Reviews

1856 Veterans Memorial Highway, Islandia
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Salad
- Chicken Fingers
- French Fries
- Spinach Dip
“I'm skipping school to come to your face and busters”
Menu Order
Health Food · $
4 Healthy Meals Direct

4.7 Superb 70 Reviews

1966 Veterans Memorial Highway, Islandia
- Delivery
“Love...Love....Love these meals. Just enough serving size, extremely tasty. Everyone is friendly and very helpful”
Menu Order
Sushi · $$
5 Mugi Sushi Hibachi And Bar

4.2 Good 204 Reviews

1708 Veterans Memorial Highway, Islandia
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Sushi
- Chicken Teriyaki
- Salmon Avocado Spicy Tuna Salmon Roll
- Hibachi Dinner Chicken Fried Rice
“Great food, friendly staff….”
Menu Order
Deli · $
6 The Garage

4.5 Superb 143 Reviews

170 Bridge Rd, Islandia
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Egg on a Roll Breakfast
- Chicken Salad Sandwich
- Cheese Pizza Slice
“I had a suprise 60 th and the Garage was excellent. Everyone loved the food and of course the main guy Big Frank Thank you again for everything”
Menu Order
Fast Food · $
7 Subway - Islandia - 54406

4.2 Good 38 Reviews

1714 Veterans Memorial Highway, Islandia
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
“Excellent ,I have an autistic son that will only eat Subway. This is the second time we been there this week. It was Closing when we got there today. and he saw us at the door and opened it up and made a sandwich for my son you don’t know how much I appreciated that thank you”
Menu Order
Bagels · $
8 New York Bagel Co.

3.7 Good 136 Reviews

1716 Veterans Memorial Highway, Islandia
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Everything Bagel
- Bagel with Cream Cheese and Coffee
- Whole Wheat
“The works bagel with garlic & herb is perfection. ❤️”
Menu Order
Coffee Shops · $
9 Starbucks Coffee Company

3.6 Good 194 Reviews

3701 Express Drive South, Islandia
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Sausage Cheddar & Egg Sandwich
- Spinach Feta & Egg White Wrap
- Cran-Merry Orange Refresher
- Bacon Gouda & Egg Sandwich
“Amazing service, they take the time to craft beautiful tasting drinks and also a pup cup for my cat Josephina… I have social anxiety and their vibe and friendly approach is so helpful to me. I also brought my cockatiels into the store and they loved them. 10/10 🩷”
Menu Order
Fast Food · $
10 McDonald's

3.5 Good 99 Reviews

1850 Veterans Memorial Hwy Walmart, Islandia
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Cheeseburger
- Quarter Pounder Hamburger
- Sausage Biscuit with Egg
- Crispy Chicken Sandwich
“This is Long Island's last McDonald's located inside a Walmart and it brings me a sense of nostalgia ordering from this McDonald's. I hope this McDonald's franchise will continue the journey inside Walmart for future generations to enjoy.”
Menu Order
Cafe · $
11 Panera Bread

3.2 Average 46 Reviews

1900A Veterans Memorial Highway, Islandia
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Fuji Apple Chicken Salad & Autumn Squash Soup You Pick 2
“This location is very clean and well kept. It is obvious staff take pride in their with they are kind and helpful. My compliments to the manager. Aaron helped me and was awesome. Food was fresh and delicious as well”
Menu Order
Coffee Shops · $
12 Starbucks

2.6 Average 29 Reviews

1864 Veterans Memorial Highway, Islandia
- Take-Out
- Delivery
“Amazing service, they take the time to craft beautiful tasting drinks and also a pup cup for my cat Josephina… I have social anxiety and their vibe and friendly approach is so helpful to me. I also brought my cockatiels into the store and they loved them. 10/10 🩷”
Menu Order
Fast Food
13 Burger King

2.2 Poor 21 Reviews

1111 Old Nichols Road, Islandia
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Sausage Egg & Cheese Croissan'Wich
- BBQ Bacon Whopper Jr
“I read all these bad reviews and have to think people need to stop acting like BK is a 5 star dining room. Its freaking BK and the ladies I always see when I do in are hard working latin woman who do a great job completing your in a timely manner. Always smiling and willing to do anything to need to help with your order.”
Menu Order
Mexican · $
14 Chipotle Mexican Grill

2.6 Average 36 Reviews

1900 Veterans Memorial Highway, Islandia
- Take-Out
- Delivery
“I Always come to this chipotle, always clean, in order, Mason the manager keeps this place in check. Every other Chipotle near by is messy, long lines, never have straws/utensils. Workers can be a little more welcoming but other than that, this is my favorite Chipotle!”
Menu Order
Coffee Shops · $
15 Dunkin'

3.1 Average 117 Reviews

1966 Veterans Memorial Highway, Islandia
- Delivery
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Donuts
- Munchkins Donut Hole Treats
- Egg and Cheese
- Strawberry
“Dunkin' coffee isn't trying to sell you some mystical experience with beans harvested on an unreachable mountain peak. It is exactly the honest, warm, unpretentious rescue you need when your alarm goes off way too early. Its profile is unmistakably consistent: a smooth, comforting flavor without that aggressive, face-scrunching acidity, and just the right level of roast to jumpstart your brain. Whether you grab it iced to survive a scorching day or steaming hot to fight off the winter chill, that first sip always feels like catching up with an old friend who knows exactly how to cheer you up. It’s accessible, fast, and above all, absolutely vital for making the chaos of the daily grind a little more manageable. Five stars—not for being the fanciest coffee in the world, but for always being right there when you need it most.”
Menu Order
Chinese · $$
16 Islandia Buffet

2.9 Average 252 Reviews

1704 Veterans Memorial Highway, Islandia
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Buffet
- Sushi
- All You Can Eat
- Shrimp Fried Rice
“Nice selection, very clean and food was filled and overturned as soon as it was low. The staff was friendly,and attentive but didn’t hover or take your plate prematurely .”
Menu Order
Japanese · $$
17 JBBQ Hot Pot & BBQ

4.7 Superb 418 Reviews

11 East Main Street, Bay Shore · 7.03 miles
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Marinated Beef
- Seafood
- Takoyaki
- Beef Brisket
“We dine at JBBQ at least once a week. The staff is incredible, food is delicious and overall such a fun experience! If you haven’t tried it yet, don’t walk, run! You’ll thank me later!!!”
Menu Order
Mexican · $
18 Taco Island Mexican Cantina

4.9 Superb 678 Reviews

5507 Nesconset Highway Ste 16, Mount Sinai · 11.19 miles
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Fries
- Shrimp Tacos
- Salsa
- Fish Tacos
“Hidden Gem . Great food I will definitely be back!”
Menu Order
Halal · $
19 Shah’s Halal Commack

4.9 Superb 555 Reviews

2187 Jericho Turnpike, Commack · 6.75 miles
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Lamb over Rice
- Hummus
- Philly Cheesesteak
- Great Price
“Definitely will come again. The food is fresh and delicious”
Menu Order
Italian · $$
20 Butera's - Bay Shore

4.6 Superb 448 Reviews

8 Third Avenue, Bay Shore · 6.97 miles
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Lasagna
- Sauce
- Fried Calamari
- Chicken Meatball Pizza
“I grew up in a 100 percent Italian family and I have to say Nona’s lasagna was the best I’ve ever had in my life. At 58 years old I have had plenty of lasagna. This is my new go to spot for Italian fare.”
Menu Order
Seafood · $$
21 Voodoo Crab of Centereach

4.6 Superb 412 Reviews

1759-G Middle Country Road, Centereach · 6.36 miles
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Seafood Boil
- Crawfish
- Garlic Noodles
- Gumbo
“We have never had a bad experience at VooDoo Crab so we decided to place a catering order for Christmas. They did not disappoint. The food was just as amazing. Customer service was exceptional from the time we placed it to pick up. We were very happy we tried them for our catering needs!”
Menu Order
Sushi Bar · $$$$
22 Sora Omakase

4.7 Superb 238 Reviews

1113 NY-25A Unit 3e, Stony Brook · 8.24 miles
- Delivery
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Sushi
- Tuna
- Mochi
- Miso Soup
“I have to admit, I DO NOT eat sushi at all. I brought my wife because she loves sushi and it was her birthday. I did my research and all the reviews were very positive. I decided to indulge even though I thought I wouldn’t like the meal. Much to my surprise I loved the meal and my wife was in all her glory. Watching the chefs prepare each course with the precision and attention to detail was great. These chefs really take pride in their craft. 10 out of 10!! Must try again!!!”
Menu
American · $$
23 Henley's Village Tavern

4.8 Superb 166 Reviews

184 Orinoco Drive, Brightwaters · 7.71 miles
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Steak
- Whistle Pig Pulled Pork Sandwich
- Pan Roasted Atlantic Salmon
- Henley’S Warm Brownie
“Staff, food, service, atmosphere and drinks are all stellar!”
Menu Order
Barbeque · $$$
24 The Barbeque King

5.0 Superb 237 Reviews

371 Lakeland Avenue, Sayville · 5.09 miles
- Take-Out
- Delivery
“What a pleasure to be able to enjoy our own party from start to finish! Keith was a pleasure to work with planning the event and his staff were absolutely amazing from set up, preparation serving and clean up! The abundance of delicious food and amazing selection made the party! Everyone was asking “who are these guys I need their number!” We cannot express our happiness enough and look forward to our next event with them! Thank you Keith and crew!”
Menu Order
American · $$
25 The Mad Batter Tea Room & Restaurant

4.9 Superb 289 Reviews

154 Montauk Highway, Blue Point · 7.79 miles
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Chicken Tenders
- Cheesecake
- Tea Pot
- Pot of Tea
“Very relaxing cozy tea room, delicious deserts and finger sandwiches, many teas to choose”
Menu
Fast Food · $
26 FLAME HALAL GYRO

4.9 Superb 275 Reviews

499 Sunrise Highway Suite 76, Patchogue · 6.92 miles
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Combo over Rice
- White Sauce
- Chicken Gyro
- Baklava
“Absolutely love the food here. My favorite hidden gem spot to bring foodie friends. They have the freshest, tastiest halal I’ve ever had and I’ve tried a bunch. This place is by far my favorite and I fear the standard they’ve set for me is so high that I’ll never be able to eat halal from anywhere else without thinking about how much better this place is. Owners are super nice and welcoming. Definitely ask for a sample of the butter chicken or lamb. If you don’t know what to get: My go-to order is combo over rice with extra white sauce and red sauce on the side (careful pouring the red sauce, it packs a decent amount of heat in a small drop).”
Menu Order
Italian · $$
27 Joey Z's Restaurant

4.8 Superb 434 Reviews

217 Main Street, Port Jefferson · 11.03 miles
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Tuna
- French Toast
- Stuffed Mushrooms
- Falafel
“I can not believe that this restaurant has been here on Main Street in Port Jefferson Village for over 20 years and I never ate there!!! This is my new Favorite place to eat. The food was exceptional and good size portions. The pita bread they put out on the table was so delicious I could have made that my meal. The service was extremely attentive and so personable. The Owner came around greeting everyone and made us feel like we were all family having dinner together. I am looking forward to my next visit.”
Menu Order
Mexican · $$$
28 IXCHEL Mexican Cuisine

4.6 Superb 222 Reviews

130 Old Town Road, Setauket- East Setauket · 10 miles
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Guacamole
- Tres Leches
- Tamales
- Burritos
“Went last night. 6 of us. We loved everything. Food and drinks were delicious. Our server was great! Can't wait to return.”
Menu Order
Pizza · $
29 Mama Mia's Pizza

4.6 Superb 193 Reviews

892 Johnson Avenue, Ronkonkoma · 2.4 miles
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Garlic Knots
- Lasagna
- Regular
- Sicilian Pie
“All I'll say is.. Mama Mia !!”
Menu Order
Barbecue · $$
30 Wuyang Casa BBQ

4.8 Superb 339 Reviews

2880 Middle Country Road, Lake Grove · 4.75 miles
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Sushi
- Cucumber Salad
- Yakitori
- Wagyu Fried Rice
“Finally went to this place. It was so good. The dumplings and buns were very tasty and not dry. The wonton soup was delicious. We both got chicken dishes and they were also very good. We got a free chicken kebab appetizer that was amazing. The staff were very friendly as well and even offered free ice cream but we were too full. I will definitely go back for the all you can eat bbq.”
Menu Order