New York Bagel Co.
$ • Bagels, Coffee Shops
Hours:
1716 Veterans Memorial Hwy, Islandia
(631) 630-0547
About New York Bagel Co.
Customers' Favorites
New York Bagel Co. Reviews
Share your opinion about New York Bagel Co.
The works bagel with garlic & herb is perfection. ❤️
Kids just had the Oreo bagel with strawberry cream cheese and loved it. We come here alot great food and great prices
Wow. Haven't been here since last owner. A lot has changed. Tuesday, not quite noon. No turkey. No swiss cheese. No everything bagels. Any one of those would have been forgivable. Three strikes in a row, and the counter person needs to get a personality. No "I'm sorry we're out of that right now." Just: "We don't have that." Guy after me was totally ignored as he waited, only to be told "No turkey today." Finally, got back to work with my 'nothing special sandwich'. Definitely...read full review
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 6AM - 2PM |
| Tuesday | 6AM - 2PM |
| Wednesday | 6AM - 2PM |
| Thursday | 6AM - 2PM |
| Friday | 6AM - 2PM |
| Saturday | 6AM - 2PM |
| Sunday | 6AM - 2PM |
People in Islandia Also Viewed
Based on the reviews, New York Bagel Co. serves quality food and drinks, including great bagels, hot coffee, breakfast sandwiches, a bacon egg and cheese SPK, and a bagel w/ cream cheese and lox. The staff is described as kind, friendly, efficient, and polite. One reviewer noted a wonderful lady with a beautiful smile who was hard working. The atmosphere felt nice and homey inside. However, nobody answers the phone when trying to make an order, which has happened several times. Also, while they advertise having gluten-free bagels, they only have regular bagels when asked.