Coyles Homemade Ice Cream

509 Main St, Islip
(631) 617-5014

Recent Reviews Order Online

Ice Cream Cups
Homemade Ice Cream Cup
All Homemade Ice Cream is Made on Premises
Quart Homemade Ice Cream
Quarts include a 4 oz. topping.
Soft Custard Ice Cream Cup

Waffle Bowl Sundae
Waffle Bowl Sundae
Includes 3 flavors and 2 toppings.

Boats
Banana Boat Homemade
Any 3 flavors of our homemade ice cream on top of a sliced banana with 2 topping of your choice.
Soft Serve Banana Boat
Vanilla and/or chocolate soft serve over a sliced banana with 2 toppings of your choice.

Specialty Sundaes
Sticky Finger Sundae
Your choice of any 2 flavors of our homemade ice cream, peanut butter sauce, hot fudge, crunch, and Reese's peanut butter cups.
Hot Fudge Brownie Sundae
Any 2 flavors of our homemade ice cream layered with warm brownies and hot fudge.
Fire Islander Sundae
Mint chip, Oreo, and cherry Garcia homemade ice creams layered with hot fudge, marshmallow sauce, and crunch.
Dirty Banana Sundae
Banana Oreo and Oreo homemade ice creams layered with sliced banana and hot fudge.
Blackout of '65 Sundae
Brownie nut fudge, rocky road, and chocolate homemade ice creams layered with hot fudge and black cherries.
Heavenly Ash Sundae
Healthbar and vanilla homemade ice creams layered with marshmallow and crunchies.
Alex's Candy Land Sundae
Cotton candy and crazy vanilla homemade ice creams topped with Swedish fish and sour patch kids or Gummy Bears.
Mama K's PB&J Sundae
Vanilla chip and peanut butter Oreo homemade ice creams layered with raspberry and peanut butter sauce.
Blend of the Best Sundae
Oreo and chocolate ice creams layered with raspberry sauce and chocolate chips.

Family Treats
Chubby Chipper Ice Cream Sandwiches (6 Pack)
Vanilla Ice Cream sandwiched between two chocolate chip cookies, rolled in chocolate chips.
Ice Cream Sandwiches (6 Pack)
Vanilla and Chocolate (3 of each) Ice Cream, sandwiched between two chocolate cookies
Mini Sundaes - Box of 5
Twist Soft Service with Chocolate Syrup, Rainbow Sprinkles and a Cherry

Ice Cream Cakes
Banana Split Cakes
Our most famous Cake with 20 of our most popular flavors together with a layer of sliced Banana and crunch. Each slice will reveal a variety of flavors for you and your guests to enjoy.
Vanilla/Chocolate Cakes
Our Homemade Vanilla and Chocolate Ice Creams with a gourmet Chocolate Crunch center.
Strawberry Shortcake
An 8" round Cake made with Our Homemade Strawberry and Vanilla Ice Creams layered with Pound Cake and Strawberry Puree, topped with Strawberries and Strawberry sauce. (serves 8-12 people)
Mississippi Mud Cake
An 8" cake made with our Homemade Coffee Ice Cream, blended with Gourmet Chocolate Crunch, Oreo Cookies on an Oreo crust with a Fudge top. (serves 8-12 People)
Blend of the Best Cake
An 8" cake made with our Oreo and Chocolate Raspberry Homemade Ice Creams filled with a layer of Pound Cake, Chocolate Chunks, and Raspberry Puree on a Homemade Oreo Crust. (serves 8-12 People)
Oreo Cake
Made with our Homemade Oreo Ice Cream filled with broken Oreo Cookies on an Oreo Crust.
Sticky Finger Cake
Made with our Homemade Vanilla Ice Cream, blended with Fudge, Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, Peanut Butter Sauce, and Gourmet Chocolate Crunch.
Chocolate Overload Cakes
Made with our Homemade Chocolate and Oreo Ice Creams, layered with Pound Cake and filled with Chocolate Chunks and Belgian Chocolate Sauce.

Extra Toppings on the Side
Side of Crunch
Side of Rainbow Sprinkles
Side of Chocolate Sprinkles
Whipped Cream Large Can
14 oz.
Side of Chocolate Syrup
Side of Swedish Fish
Side of Peanuts
Side of Wet Walnuts
Side of M&Ms
Side of Reese's Pieces
Side of Reese's Peanut Butter Cups
Side of Gummy Bears
Side of Strawberries
Side of Pineapples
Side of Banana
Side of Walnuts
Side of Black Cherries
Side of Peanut Butter Sauce
Side of Marshmallow Sauce
Side of Hot Fudge
Side of Hot Caramel
Side of Hot Butterscotch

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+31 photos
Photo credit: google
+30 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

My go to ice cream in long Island. That peanut butter cookie dough flavor is **perfection**

We tried the Brooklyn egg cream for the first time - cola flavor tastes like a float.

The one star is lost due to the staff. I'd say 90% of the time I go - the staff has a bad attitude. Disappointing when you're going for a fun ice cream experience.

The vibes are fun, 1950s ice cream parlor with a bunch of mirrors and chrome.
May 2025
I recently visited Coyle’s Ice Cream Shop and had an amazing experience! The variety of flavors is incredible, and each one I tried was delicious and unique. The staff was friendly and helpful, making great recommendations based on my preferences. The atmosphere was cozy and welcoming, perfect for enjoying a sweet treat. I highly recommend Coyle’s Ice Cream to anyone looking for top-notch ice cream and a fantastic overall experience!
December 2024
I ordered 2 different ice cream flavors, one chocolate based and one vanilla based, and both had very little flavor. I don't know what happened there, but very disappointing and considering the price I wouldn't return.
June 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

koiKOKORO / Islip NY - 501 Main St
Japanese, Sushi Bar, Vegan, Vegetarian
Bubba's Burrito Bar - 513 Main St
Tacos, Burrito, Vegan, Vegetarian
Bayberry - 501 Main St
Cocktail Bar, Seafood, American

Coyles Homemade Ice Cream

509 Main St, Islip, NY 11751
(631) 617-5014