My boyfriend and I dined this past Saturday at Tellers to celebrate his birthday. We made a reservation ahead of time and because of this we were seated immediately upon arrival at a cute corner table inside of the Gold Bar section. Although it was a bit crowded at the bar thankfully the noise level wasn't too bad. Our server Robert was amazing from the beginning and made the experience that much better! The food was absolutely delicious!! We both got filets that were cooked to perfection, the mashed potatoes were so creamy and smooth and the five cheese Mac was my favorite for sure, it was so flavorful and luscious. I believe it was one of the managers that checked in on us mid meal and made sure everything was to our liking, which it was beyond our expectations. Robert made sure our glasses were always full and that we had such a great time! 10/10 will be returning to dine again soon!!
Emilie
Tables are very tight. We sat right next to the wait staff station which was less than ideal. Waiter had a bit of an attitude but warmed up a little as the evening went on. Food was the highlight. Steaks cooked to perfection. Decor is still well kept and lovely (we've been going for years).
Steven Damiano
Absolutely amazing. I have been to a handful of other high end steakhouses, but this one was by far the best.
Everything was cooked perfectly to our liking, the bernaise sauce and mac & cheese were the highlights of the meal. We had a unique fig and burrata appetizer, as well as an affogato dessert which they brought out with a birthday candle.
Our server Willie took great care of us, he was very attentive and explained the menu options in great detail.
The general manager, Miguel personally came over to the table to wish me a happy birthday and surprised us with a gift.
Its safe to say we will be returning in the very near future!
Paul Alcee
Best birthday dinner!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brian Lunn
Food and service is always phenomenal! One of the best steakhouses on Long Island.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Douglas
Had the special veal chop and thought it was amazing the other three people we were with totally enjoyed their meal and are still bragging about it. The price is heavy but can't complain about the quality.
Our anniversary dinner was memorable due to the excellent food and drinks, but what truly made it stand out was the exceptional service provided by our waiter, Carlos. His recommendations were spot on, and he took the time to explain the intricacies of our cocktails. To cap off the night, he even offered us a champagne toast! We will definitely be back and requesting his superior service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Kris Conway
Please do not order the whipped potatoes, they do not taste real, very disappointing. Also please do not order the creamed spinach. It is very watery and too pureed. The filet was good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Allison
First time going to Teller's and it exceeded my expectations. The food was fantastic, the wine list and signature cocktails were solid and the wait staff were kind and courteous. We'll definitely be returning.
Luxurious atmosphere, absolutely delicious top notch highest quality ingredients and service . You want to experience a 5 star dinning experience this is the place!!!!
Me and my fiancé are just finishing the process of selecting a location for our wedding, and while we didn't end up booking with Tellers, I had to write a review about what a lovely experience we had with their event manager, Lisa. She was so kind, charismatic, personable, and knowledgable! She was quick to respond to my inquiry, provided everything I needed to know to decide if we were interested in coming in for a tour, and walked us through all of our options and how we could bring our vision to life when we came to see the space. We ended up deciding to do a smaller elopement style ceremony, but deliberated on the decision for an extra day or two just based on how much we would have loved to work with Lisa for our wedding! I highly recommend considering working with her for your events
Service: 5
Gina
I had a great experience! It was my first time at Tellers, I was celebrating my 33rd birthday and the host was incredibly kind and accommodated me, I had a party of 4 and last minute had to add another person so we only had to wait 20 minutes for the restaurant to find us a table for 5, I also had a friend show up late due to a flat tire but thankfully we were still able to be seated while we waited for my friend. My waitress was also very sweet and energetic, I wish I remembered everyone's names but I felt very welcomed, 10/10.
Allison
I've had the privilege of dining at Teller's several times and it is always a wonderful experience. This most recent visit saw my party of six out for a family celebration. Our table was a corner booth which had been requested ahead of time and was the perfect spot for us, very comfortable. Our server was outstanding an knowledgeable, he had a great personality and was attentive without being intrusive, allowing us to converse and really enjoy our meal. For appetizers we enjoyed the seasonal watermelon and feta salad, the burrata caprese and the crab cakes, all of which were promptly devoured and enjoyed. We were sad to learn our favorite app, Steak Tar Tar had been removed after the recent seasonal menu changes, but hope to see it back on the menu in the future. Out of the six diners, we ordered 5 steaks Delmonico style (if you know, you know), and an order of the lamb. Each dish was cooked perfectly to desired temp and tasted divine. For our shared sides; we ordered the scalloped potatoes, creamed spinach and roasted carrots, which were all delicious as well. For desert we had Creme Brulé, and the star of the show, the Affogato Sundae which was a huge hit. We all had a cocktail with dinner and then shared two bottles of Bordeaux with our entrees. It was a truly enjoyable experience and although its an expensive meal; it's one my family never regrets.
My boyfriend and I dined this past Saturday at Tellers to celebrate his birthday. We made a reservation ahead of time and because of this we were seated immediately upon arrival at a cute corner table inside of the Gold Bar section. Although it was a bit crowded at the bar thankfully the noise level wasn't too bad. Our server Robert was amazing from the beginning and made the experience that much better! The food was absolutely delicious!! We both got filets that were cooked to perfection, the mashed potatoes were so creamy and smooth and the five cheese Mac was my favorite for sure, it was so flavorful and luscious. I believe it was one of the managers that checked in on us mid meal and made sure everything was to our liking, which it was beyond our expectations. Robert made sure our glasses were always full and that we had such a great time! 10/10 will be returning to dine again soon!!
Tables are very tight. We sat right next to the wait staff station which was less than ideal. Waiter had a bit of an attitude but warmed up a little as the evening went on. Food was the highlight. Steaks cooked to perfection. Decor is still well kept and lovely (we've been going for years).
Absolutely amazing. I have been to a handful of other high end steakhouses, but this one was by far the best.
Everything was cooked perfectly to our liking, the bernaise sauce and mac & cheese were the highlights of the meal. We had a unique fig and burrata appetizer, as well as an affogato dessert which they brought out with a birthday candle.
Our server Willie took great care of us, he was very attentive and explained the menu options in great detail.
The general manager, Miguel personally came over to the table to wish me a happy birthday and surprised us with a gift.
Its safe to say we will be returning in the very near future!
Best birthday dinner!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food and service is always phenomenal! One of the best steakhouses on Long Island.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had the special veal chop and thought it was amazing the other three people we were with totally enjoyed their meal and are still bragging about it. The price is heavy but can't complain about the quality.
Lovely as always!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tellers Duck Fat Fries, Tellers Black Label Burger, Beef Wellington
Our anniversary dinner was memorable due to the excellent food and drinks, but what truly made it stand out was the exceptional service provided by our waiter, Carlos. His recommendations were spot on, and he took the time to explain the intricacies of our cocktails. To cap off the night, he even offered us a champagne toast! We will definitely be back and requesting his superior service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Please do not order the whipped potatoes, they do not taste real, very disappointing. Also please do not order the creamed spinach. It is very watery and too pureed. The filet was good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
First time going to Teller's and it exceeded my expectations. The food was fantastic, the wine list and signature cocktails were solid and the wait staff were kind and courteous. We'll definitely be returning.
Restaurantji Recommends
We had the lunch special and it was great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Luxurious atmosphere, absolutely delicious top notch highest quality ingredients and service . You want to experience a 5 star dinning experience this is the place!!!!
Parking: Steet parking and rear lot available
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Creme Brulee, Tellers Duck Fat Fries, Lobster Bisque, Scalloped Potatoes, Lobster Mac & Cheese, Filet Mignon Wellington, Beef Wellington
Me and my fiancé are just finishing the process of selecting a location for our wedding, and while we didn't end up booking with Tellers, I had to write a review about what a lovely experience we had with their event manager, Lisa. She was so kind, charismatic, personable, and knowledgable! She was quick to respond to my inquiry, provided everything I needed to know to decide if we were interested in coming in for a tour, and walked us through all of our options and how we could bring our vision to life when we came to see the space. We ended up deciding to do a smaller elopement style ceremony, but deliberated on the decision for an extra day or two just based on how much we would have loved to work with Lisa for our wedding! I highly recommend considering working with her for your events
Service: 5
I had a great experience! It was my first time at Tellers, I was celebrating my 33rd birthday and the host was incredibly kind and accommodated me, I had a party of 4 and last minute had to add another person so we only had to wait 20 minutes for the restaurant to find us a table for 5, I also had a friend show up late due to a flat tire but thankfully we were still able to be seated while we waited for my friend. My waitress was also very sweet and energetic, I wish I remembered everyone's names but I felt very welcomed, 10/10.
I've had the privilege of dining at Teller's several times and it is always a wonderful experience. This most recent visit saw my party of six out for a family celebration. Our table was a corner booth which had been requested ahead of time and was the perfect spot for us, very comfortable. Our server was outstanding an knowledgeable, he had a great personality and was attentive without being intrusive, allowing us to converse and really enjoy our meal. For appetizers we enjoyed the seasonal watermelon and feta salad, the burrata caprese and the crab cakes, all of which were promptly devoured and enjoyed. We were sad to learn our favorite app, Steak Tar Tar had been removed after the recent seasonal menu changes, but hope to see it back on the menu in the future. Out of the six diners, we ordered 5 steaks Delmonico style (if you know, you know), and an order of the lamb. Each dish was cooked perfectly to desired temp and tasted divine. For our shared sides; we ordered the scalloped potatoes, creamed spinach and roasted carrots, which were all delicious as well. For desert we had Creme Brulé, and the star of the show, the Affogato Sundae which was a huge hit. We all had a cocktail with dinner and then shared two bottles of Bordeaux with our entrees. It was a truly enjoyable experience and although its an expensive meal; it's one my family never regrets.
Loading...