Tellers: An American Chophouse
605 Main St, Islip
(631) 277-7070
Customers' Favorites
Tellers Signature Duck Fat Fries
Tellers Black Label Burger
Tellers Signature Ribeye
Classic Italian Tartufo
Filet Mignon Wellington
Clams on the Half Shell
Classic Crème Brûlée
Tellers Duck Fat Fries
Tomahawk Steak Dinner
Tomahawk Ribeye Steak
Menu
Photos
+60 photos
+59 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
We had a party of three and decided to do family style and shared a variety of dishes and desserts. We started with crab cake, pecan salad and the mozzarella appetizers. For main course we had a 38 ounce porterhouse steak, burnt broccoli and scallop potatoes. We had several cocktails, the teller's old fashion was over the top and the wine was an excellent Stags Leap. Then Expresso martinis with several desserts. Chocolate cake, banana cream pie were so delicious
Had an amazing family birthday dinner in a great corner booth with a talented server. Shared the signature 40 oz — 26 oz of beef— ribeye among four of us and also had the scrumptious Miso Cod with delectable crab fried rice. Sides are enough for 2-3 so we had a bag of leftovers. Server chose a great Cab and brought a nice birthday treat at the end. We always play a guessing game on how much the check would be and it was below our lowest estimate. Highly recommend Tellers.
My fiance and I came to dine with our families as a treat for them and as an informal tasting for our wedding next year. The staff was very friendly and comped some dishes for us to try. In addition, my uncle's birthday just passed and we wanted to celebrate him and the staff generously put a candle on the dessert and sent him home with a gift. We are so excited to have our wedding at Tellers Next Door!
You May Also Like
Manhattan Sweets Boutique Bakery - 547 Main St
![]()
Bakery, Cupcakes, Donuts, Gluten-Free
Harp & Hound - 528 Main St
![]()
Irish Pub, American, Irish