Cayuga Lake Creamery at The Dewitt Mall

Every flavour was amazing! The quality and quantity of ice cream was good .

Lovely ice cream, with the cones well filled. Swift service from staff.

Delicious but pricy.

Price, omg. Taste, good. Atmosphere, vibey. I got the maple pecan.

Best ice cream in Ithaca and lovely customer service.

The creamiest ice cream in the area, and without a doubt, getting the one with coffee and coffee beans (when they have it) in a homemade waffle cone is the best.

Delicious homemade ice cream and waffle cones.

Homemade ice-cream this place is amazing! Pistachio ice cream on their fancy cone is superb and no regrets! Place is cute and pretty with a nice indoor and outdoor spot. Street parking wasn't too bad either. One of the best ice-cream I have had, strong recommend!!

We came in to get some ice cream, got to the register and asked to sample a flavor, we tried one flavor and then the person helping us went to check out about 8 people behind us and we waited for about 10 minutes waiting to try another flavor while everyone else was being served. They never came back to us to sample anything else or check out, after a while we just left.... No ice cream. Kind of disappointing.

Google hours say closes at 830pm today. I showed up at 740pm and while walking to the door the girl flipped the sign to closed and locked to door. After speaking with a buddy about this he informed me that that happen to him as well. Been going here for years. Don't think I will be anymore.

Seems the ice cream isn't the same. Used to be hard and dense and taste homemade. Now is like store bought with gums and fillers. Very disappointed after coming here for years.

Came here because the reviews are so good, and yes the ice cream is delicious. But the service was some of the worst I’ve experienced in my life, and I’m not over exaggerating. 3 young people behind the counter just staring at us. Not a word. We then spoke up to order, they plopped the ice cream cup down on the counter, and still not a word. No eye contact, no thank you, not a word. I was confused. So I said “thank you so much”… and again, not a word no acknowledgment at all. I’m pretty stunned. I know people can sometimes have a bad day, but this was unusual.

Quite expensive and small portions, also they charge extra for certain flavors (something that’s not disclosed until you see the charges on the register)

I LOVE THIS PLACE!!! The flavors are fire

Six stars. I had pistachio and blueberry cheesecake. The pistachio had various sizes of pistachio with only the real taste, no fake pistachio. The blueberry cheesecake was exquisitely creamy.

If you can’t decide between two flavors, definitely get them both, it will be worth it.