I stepped into the Treatery for first time as I was waiting in queue to have brunch at the Main Street Biscuit Company across the street. It was a great decision! The cheerful owner and employees gave me a great impression. The cookies were out of this world! While I was bummed that they were out of their chocolate chip and walnut, the triple chocolate was amazing and so was the oatmeal raisin. I love to support women in business with a positive outlook and quality product. I highly recommend you step in as the summer season is approaching and beyond! A wonderful retreat on the way to wherever you’re heading east or even if you’re a resident! So glad I came in:)Kid-friendliness: They were cute kids in there enjoying their cupcakes! I also noticed a few custom orders being picked up for cupcakes, which was assumably a birthday party or special occasion!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
joanne macchia
Cake pops for my 12-year-old granddaughter, both delicious and beautiful! Thank you Treatery Bakery -Jamesport NY! You are the best!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Callie Mendenhall
Can’t even explain how incredible this bakery is. If you don’t stop in you are missing out. Ask for a last minute gender reveal cake and she made do in 5 minutes. The owner is maybe the nicest person I’ve ever met and her chocolate cake with Oreos was PHENOMENAL. She made our day so special but she also just makes amazing baked goods. Do not miss this!!!! Thank you so much Treatery ? ? ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
rustandgrain
Amazing staff and atmosphere, be sure to try one of the Grilled cheeses and some cookies and Wutella? highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Donna P.
Stopped today on the way to the ferry. Although it was early afternoon, there was very little selection. I bought 4 lemon ricotta cookies. They were fine, tasted more like almond extract than lemon. The bad part? $16 for 4 small cookies. Ridiculous price, won't be coming back.
Charlotte D
We ordered a mini cake from here for our wedding. Communication wasn't great and they didn't confirm our order until 2 days before the wedding even though I reached out 3 weeks in advance (it was a mini cake so did not require longer notice). The design came out nice and looked good in photos—simple chocolate frosting with edible flowers, but the cake itself was very dry. Unfortunately it ended up going to waste because nobody wanted to eat it.
Brittany & Taryn
I was introduced to Christina from The Treatery by Danielle at The Montauk Distilling Co. The Treatery catered mine and my wife Brittany’s Rehearsal Dinner held at the Distillery this past September 2023. The girls at The Treatery did an AHHHHmazing job, with a huge assortment of dips, chips, snacks, sandwiches and boujee desserts, our guests were so impressed. Everything was delicious and displayed so beautifully. Thank you ladies for making our Wedding Weekend kickoff utterly delicious!!T&B
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dee Stephens
A wonderful bake shop! Everything is always delicious and the atmosphere is warm and welcoming. We ordered cakes for a party, they were so pretty and delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nicole Edmonds
by far, the GREATEST bakery on the half of the Island that is Nassau & Suffolk County. Christina and her staff are absolutely incredible, and the product that they put into the world is next level.Pro Tip: GET A GRILLED CHEESE. you're welcome.But, seriously. Go here. Regret nothing and remember fondly that moment where you knew about a thing, before it was a THHHHIIIIINNNNNNGGGGG(cause Christina & Co gonna be a THING)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lia S.
I drive from selden to Jamesport just for this grilled cheese and the cookies they have are an added bonus. The inside is so cute with the flower wall and wood! I cannot recommend this business enough, I drove out there and unfortunately they were not opening for another 2 hours- I reach out to the owner just stating I was sad, because she deserves to know how good her grilled cheeses are- and he gave me her personal number for next time- and I went back and she made it completely right, not that's that was what I was looking for but she is an amazing business owner and I will continue to support her small business over and over! If you haven't been- get there!
Love when you find an unexpected treat! Walked into this bakery to discover some really yummy gelato and home made baked cookies and muffins. It so happens that that day the owners Aunt was back baking some bananna bread and blueberry muffins. My friend ordered the blueberry muffin which came out warm and oh boy - it was moist full of fresh blueberries, not too sweet which I prefer just the right amount of sugar and the perfect amount of blueberries, then we were offered no charge a taste of the banana bread muffin which they are considering offering. I am a big banana bread baker and I have to say this was better than my version! Hoping they add this one to the menu!Ps if you like lavender than the lavender gelato is for you - yes you can taste and smell the lavender! A must try!Can’t wait to go back!
Mercedes V.
The Website and several local articles advertised "The Treatery after Dark" open Sunday and Monday evenings 7-11.We pulled up on Sunday evening July 16th at 8 pm. The minute we stepped up to the door the lights went out. We were looking forward to enjoying a sweet treat after dinner .Not happy with the early closure on an advertised time.
Antoinette Merenda Carbone
Great grilled cheese sandwiches cookies are exceptional. Going back to taste the gelato. I’ve now been back because their grill cheese sandwich is delicious and made on great bread. Worth five stars. For families coming in to buy just cookies be aware that prices start at $3 each and upwards. This can get expensive when coming in with two children and they want two cookies each. The gelato is $6. For a small cup. In general the going rate on the North Fork. Surprise for-all who may have traveled to Sicily where brioche and gelato was born. Here it is $12. More than Double the patisserie price I paid on the eolian islands. And there the brioche and gelato tasted better. The decor and the ability to eat in the outdoor area is very nice.I wish they baked smaller loaves of bread. They are huge. Price $14. I would have bought one but I am a single person and the size is really over the top. Half that size and they would sell faster. There were several loaves and the walk-in trade just passed them by.June 2023. I went in to buy a gift card for a friend with several great grandchildren. Surprise to see her write on a business card the amount and put it in a small cookie bag. When I asked if they had a more familiar looking gift card I was told not yet. Really. A business card! Wont do that again until they have something more secure than a business card.I give them NO STARS for business smarts.July 2023. I give 5stars for the grilled cheese. I like the traditional. Very nice melt. I go back for this delightful tasting version. The bread on display still huge. Do try the chocolate cchip cookie. Marvelous.
Rinat Iakupov (EHDR.PRO)
Awesome food. Greatest services! Thank you so much!
Eric Mittelmann
Their cookies and grilled cheese sandwiches are out of this world
I stepped into the Treatery for first time as I was waiting in queue to have brunch at the Main Street Biscuit Company across the street. It was a great decision! The cheerful owner and employees gave me a great impression. The cookies were out of this world! While I was bummed that they were out of their chocolate chip and walnut, the triple chocolate was amazing and so was the oatmeal raisin. I love to support women in business with a positive outlook and quality product. I highly recommend you step in as the summer season is approaching and beyond! A wonderful retreat on the way to wherever you’re heading east or even if you’re a resident! So glad I came in:)Kid-friendliness: They were cute kids in there enjoying their cupcakes! I also noticed a few custom orders being picked up for cupcakes, which was assumably a birthday party or special occasion!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cake pops for my 12-year-old granddaughter, both delicious and beautiful! Thank you Treatery Bakery -Jamesport NY! You are the best!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Can’t even explain how incredible this bakery is. If you don’t stop in you are missing out. Ask for a last minute gender reveal cake and she made do in 5 minutes. The owner is maybe the nicest person I’ve ever met and her chocolate cake with Oreos was PHENOMENAL. She made our day so special but she also just makes amazing baked goods. Do not miss this!!!! Thank you so much Treatery ? ? ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing staff and atmosphere, be sure to try one of the Grilled cheeses and some cookies and Wutella? highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stopped today on the way to the ferry. Although it was early afternoon, there was very little selection. I bought 4 lemon ricotta cookies. They were fine, tasted more like almond extract than lemon. The bad part? $16 for 4 small cookies. Ridiculous price, won't be coming back.
We ordered a mini cake from here for our wedding. Communication wasn't great and they didn't confirm our order until 2 days before the wedding even though I reached out 3 weeks in advance (it was a mini cake so did not require longer notice). The design came out nice and looked good in photos—simple chocolate frosting with edible flowers, but the cake itself was very dry. Unfortunately it ended up going to waste because nobody wanted to eat it.
I was introduced to Christina from The Treatery by Danielle at The Montauk Distilling Co. The Treatery catered mine and my wife Brittany’s Rehearsal Dinner held at the Distillery this past September 2023. The girls at The Treatery did an AHHHHmazing job, with a huge assortment of dips, chips, snacks, sandwiches and boujee desserts, our guests were so impressed. Everything was delicious and displayed so beautifully. Thank you ladies for making our Wedding Weekend kickoff utterly delicious!!T&B
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A wonderful bake shop! Everything is always delicious and the atmosphere is warm and welcoming. We ordered cakes for a party, they were so pretty and delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
by far, the GREATEST bakery on the half of the Island that is Nassau & Suffolk County. Christina and her staff are absolutely incredible, and the product that they put into the world is next level.Pro Tip: GET A GRILLED CHEESE. you're welcome.But, seriously. Go here. Regret nothing and remember fondly that moment where you knew about a thing, before it was a THHHHIIIIINNNNNNGGGGG(cause Christina & Co gonna be a THING)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I drive from selden to Jamesport just for this grilled cheese and the cookies they have are an added bonus. The inside is so cute with the flower wall and wood! I cannot recommend this business enough, I drove out there and unfortunately they were not opening for another 2 hours- I reach out to the owner just stating I was sad, because she deserves to know how good her grilled cheeses are- and he gave me her personal number for next time- and I went back and she made it completely right, not that's that was what I was looking for but she is an amazing business owner and I will continue to support her small business over and over! If you haven't been- get there!
Restaurantji Recommends
Love when you find an unexpected treat! Walked into this bakery to discover some really yummy gelato and home made baked cookies and muffins. It so happens that that day the owners Aunt was back baking some bananna bread and blueberry muffins. My friend ordered the blueberry muffin which came out warm and oh boy - it was moist full of fresh blueberries, not too sweet which I prefer just the right amount of sugar and the perfect amount of blueberries, then we were offered no charge a taste of the banana bread muffin which they are considering offering. I am a big banana bread baker and I have to say this was better than my version! Hoping they add this one to the menu!Ps if you like lavender than the lavender gelato is for you - yes you can taste and smell the lavender! A must try!Can’t wait to go back!
The Website and several local articles advertised "The Treatery after Dark" open Sunday and Monday evenings 7-11.We pulled up on Sunday evening July 16th at 8 pm. The minute we stepped up to the door the lights went out. We were looking forward to enjoying a sweet treat after dinner .Not happy with the early closure on an advertised time.
Great grilled cheese sandwiches cookies are exceptional. Going back to taste the gelato. I’ve now been back because their grill cheese sandwich is delicious and made on great bread. Worth five stars. For families coming in to buy just cookies be aware that prices start at $3 each and upwards. This can get expensive when coming in with two children and they want two cookies each. The gelato is $6. For a small cup. In general the going rate on the North Fork. Surprise for-all who may have traveled to Sicily where brioche and gelato was born. Here it is $12. More than Double the patisserie price I paid on the eolian islands. And there the brioche and gelato tasted better. The decor and the ability to eat in the outdoor area is very nice.I wish they baked smaller loaves of bread. They are huge. Price $14. I would have bought one but I am a single person and the size is really over the top. Half that size and they would sell faster. There were several loaves and the walk-in trade just passed them by.June 2023. I went in to buy a gift card for a friend with several great grandchildren. Surprise to see her write on a business card the amount and put it in a small cookie bag. When I asked if they had a more familiar looking gift card I was told not yet. Really. A business card! Wont do that again until they have something more secure than a business card.I give them NO STARS for business smarts.July 2023. I give 5stars for the grilled cheese. I like the traditional. Very nice melt. I go back for this delightful tasting version. The bread on display still huge. Do try the chocolate cchip cookie. Marvelous.
Awesome food. Greatest services! Thank you so much!
Their cookies and grilled cheese sandwiches are out of this world